Any Food Feuds You Know of? Where do You Stand on Them?

I’m fine, just busy. But now that I have a minute:

  1. Ketchup on any form of sausage is just so…unsophisticated. A proper tied-off pig intestine filled with packing plant sweepings should be dressed with mustard. Relish, onions and the like are optional.

  2. The only edible clam chowder is Manhattan style. Period. (The wife just called me an idiot and stomped out of the room.)

  3. Western NC>Texas>Eastern NC>KC>Santa Maria

  4. Coke

  5. Pizza should be thin. Pineapple optional. No nationwide chain is within light years of NYC pizza. Chicago thin is delicious.

  6. There are no beans in chili.

  7. There are no raisins in anything except carrot salad.

  8. There is no sugar in cornbread. There may, however, be chilis.

  9. Hot apple pie demands a slice of sharp cheddar cheese.

  10. Cincinnati “chili” isn’t, but is delicious in its own right.

Having been raised right by a native of Nash County, North Carolina, I know that real barbecue can only be found east of Goldsboro, N.C., in a restaurant that serves brown sugar water as “sweet tea” and offers banana pudding for dessert. I’m not an intolerant bigot, though - either corn sticks or hushpuppies are acceptable sides with your Brunswick stew.

I’m only about three-quarters kidding. I do prefer vinegar-based East Carolina pulled pork to just about anything else. Lowcountry mustard-based 'cue from South Carolina is a thoroughly acceptable alternative, though. And I’ll eat tomato-based Memphis-style 'cue, if nothing else is available. But I really do think that braised brisket or ribs or chicken are not the same thing as real barbecue. They are beef or chicken or whatever that has been barbecued - in Texas and Kansas, it’s a verb; in the Carolinas, it’s a noun.

And it’s better.

You want Chik-fil-A, then. I can attest from personal experience that their lemonade is made of water, sugar, and chilled lemons, cut and juiced by a poor minimum wage slave with frozen hands. That lemon juice finds every little cut and nick on your hands.

My dad (native Brooklynite) used to say there are two kinds of pizza in the world - that which is from New York, and everything else, which is a pizza-like product. Isn’t there a NY vs Chicago style pizza feud? (I, personally like them both).

How about corn on the cob? Around or across? Me - across, like a typewriter.

In the battle of mayonnaise vs. Miracle Whip, the only correct answer is NEITHER.

Things did get pretty nasty.

(Old Pace Picante sauce ad)

:wink:

And yet Pace Foods is a division of Campbell’s Soup, based in Camden New Jersey. So I’m not sure what right they have to complain about another brand of sauce made in New York City. (If the other brand really is made in New York; is there any manufacturing left there?)

Another vote for Chili = no beans. While this is obviously a personal choice, the varying opinions mean that every time I’m anywhere that advertises chili, I have to ask if it includes beans or not. Who in the world puts bean-chili on a chili dog?!? But it happens, so I always have to ask (and 80% of the time, it’s with beans so I pass).

I don’t know what that white dessert topping crap is called:

Should I even mention soft boiled eggs?

So long as you break them on the larger end

People who are bothered when *someone else *uses a fork and knife to eat pizza. Eat it the way you want to eat it, and be at peace with yourself and the universe. Sometimes pizza is really hot, and sometimes it’s really messy, and a fork and knife work like miracle inventions in those cases.
And Two Many Cats, take back what you said about celery salt.

I’ve never been able to get very worked up about the terminology-based ones. Is Cincinnati chili “real chili”? Is Chicago deep-dish a “real pizza”? I dunno, but they’re both good.

On the actual feuds, let’s see…

You can put clams in tomato soup, but I have no idea why you would, as neither the tomato nor the clams are improved by it. The tomato tends to drown out the clams. Much better to put the clams in a cream soup, where their flavor can shine through.

On every North vs. South feud save one, the South side is correct, and I say that as a loyal Yankee. I will quibble slightly with JcWoman a bit about cornbread: Sugar is allowed within ten miles of cornbread, if the bread is baked without it, and the sugar is in the form of honey, molasses, or maple syrup added topically to the bread. It’s certainly not required, but it’s allowed.

The one point on which the South is just wrong is sweet tea, which takes the worst components of tea flavor, turns them up to 11, and throws the rest out. Making the result so sickly sweet that you can stand a spoon up in it not only does not cover for this sin; it makes it worse.

Chili is best the way it was originally served, back when it was invented: With beans. Beef is good, too, but is not mandatory. And yes, people have argued this point with me before, but even their own cites say that it was served with beans.

Apple pie with cheese is just weird. I don’t care if others swear by it, but the flavors don’t complement each other at all. A scoop of vanilla ice cream, however, while not necessary, is never unwelcome.

And the only stand I’ll take on the Barbecue Wars is that if you’re cooking, I’ll eat it.

Yeah, the only “two sides” I know of on that one are those who’ve never tried it, and those who love it. We’re sort of the neutral arms dealer in the Hot Dog Wars: Coney Island, Chicago, whatever, try some of this stuff on it.

In & Out versus Five Guys has started a few wars.

Pepsi, though I drink more Mountain Dew and way, way more seltzer/sparkling water

Screw you and your 2% milk

BBQ Sauce is not a condiment, quit putting it on burgers and chicken sandwiches

Sriracha is too sweet, Sambal Oelek is what you want from Huy Fong

I don’t understand ketchup, it does nothing for me, I use it on nothing

Corn on the cob, I’m an asymmetrical kind of guy and I will both “typewriter” across and go around.

To correct a post up-thread, yes there are two types of pizza, Chicago and everything else. Chicago is Pizza Heaven. Also don’t be fooled, deep dish was invented here, and we eat it, but we eat way more thin than deep, pan, calabrese, or stuffed or whatever else is out there.

I find chili, (like soup), a culinary challenge and adventure. What do I have in the fridge, in the pantry, what is on sale? I still get &$^@ at work for my “Lentil Chili”
.
.
.
.
I threw the last of a bag of lentils, a small amount into a chili but the “legend” has gained a life of it’s own :o

Except, of course, they don’t. Some say beans were served on the side, but many don’t even say that. I don’t even think this is a point of argument among food historians. It doesn’t matter. Cook it how you want it. How it was originally served or authenticity is, really, immaterial, but Texas chili was originally a meat stew, not a bean one.

Never! The sausage is salty, the pickle spear is salty…why do you want to dump more salt on it?

Barbecue sauce is a condiment to be served on the side. I do not spread it on meat I am smoking or grilling. I want the rub and the wood smoke to enhance the meat.

My chili has three kinds of beans. Cook yours however you want.

I like Pizza but I don’t favor one style over another. Hawaiian pizza is nasty. No pineapple on my pizza.

I live in Omaha. Not exactly the seafood capital of the USA. I have sampled clam chowder, but it is not a prominent dish here. I have no real opinion over the New England vs. Manhattan Chowder.

Sweet tea is horrible.

  1. Wrong. The reason Manhattan style is superior is so you don’t taste the fucking clams, which are just solidified snot.

  2. Totally correct in every particular. Don’t forget sorghum syrup!

C. Sweet tea is the only way it is to be served in Heaven.

Quatro. No matter how many times you try to sell this Big Lie, it will always be proven WRONG.

Fünf. A good sharp cheddar sets off the apples perfectly.

Six. Well said.

On the Pizza crust question I am team Thick Crust. I want my free bread stick at the end :slight_smile:

Pork roll vs Taylor Ham. In the northeast part of New Jersey they call it Taylor Ham. The rest of the state calls it pork roll. I’m from the border region hence my location. It’s pork roll by the way but whatever you think it’s called it’s part of the best breakfast sandwich ever.