I used to have a pair of Naot, years ago. I liked them fine. They’re very similar to Birkenstocks, but I found that mine didn’t last as long as the Birkies I’ve owned. (Although one data point is probably not very meaningful.)
I don’t know anything about Birkenstocks, but I have had a couple pairs of Naot for about 6 years. I will say that after 6 years the soles are kind of worn down. I still like them though, as does everyone I know who has them.
I have a pair of the Matai flats, and they were really comfortable initially (about three months), but they stretched out quickly and look disappointingly dingy for how expensive they were.
I’m a lifelong birkenstock wearer, but I bought a pair of Naots about two years ago on a sale. I like them better than birks now. I recently bought this pair: Sandals, Shoes, Boots & More | NAOT, and they are wearing in really well.
I’ve been wearing Birks for 20 years (Boston’s are my house slippers and run around shoes.), Dansko’s ( sometimes work shoes. These things last forever.) for about 10 and I have a pair of Naots.
My only problem I’ve had with them is that there is no way to tighten up the toe strap on the pair that I own, so it always felt too loose on the sandals I bought.
Kinda looks like this, only with an ankle strap. Because of this glaring problem, I haven’t even thought of looking at another pair in years and apparently, they’ve expanded their shoe selection and I am digging the boots in a major way.
Other than that, they were very comfortable.
( I have feet issues and find that spending $120 or so for a pair of shoes that actually don’t hurt my feet and last 10 years or more are worth every penny.)
I wanted some closed shoes and for some reason the shoe-style Birkenstocks don’t feel right on my feet whereas my Boston clogs are divine. I just hate wearing clogs in the snow.