Appetizer/Starter Ideas - Christmas Dinner

The wife and I are doing Christmas dinner at our house this year, and I’d like to do a couple of interesting appetizers/starters that people can nosh on before the meal while visiting. We’ll be providing the protein, starch, and vegetable. The 15 guests (family) will be providing additional items (rolls, salad, etc.).

If the menu matters, we’ll be doing a soup course which will be a jalapeno bisque, and the main course will be horseradish encrusted prime rib roast on the rotisserie, mashed chive/garlic potatoes, and bacon-wrapped asparagus. We’ll have wine with dinner, beer and gin martinis before dinner. We’ll probably have a relish tray, but I wanted one, or maybe two more appetizers.

We have no dietary restrictions, and the guests tend to like spicy, well-seasoned foods.

And just to be a good sport, I’ll offer up an appetizer that I tend to do that people seem to really like. I used to make the traditional fried jalapeno poppers stuffed with cheese, but these are a bit easier and in my mind they’re healthier:

Grilled jalapeno poppers

Take some whole, fresh jalapenos and cut off the stem end. Clean out the seeds and ribs. I use a potato peeler for this. The long, pointy kind, not the Y shaped kind.

Stuff with cooked sausage (I usually buy links, cook 'em, and cut 'em lengthwise) and a good sharp cheese.

Now, I have a jalapeno rack I bought; it’s basically a piece of stainless steel with 21 holes in it that are about the size of a half-dollar (google 'em, you’ll find 'em). Put the jalapeno’s in the holes and skewer them with a tooth pick (they’re going to shrink and soften when cooked, and if you skip this step, they can fall through the holes when taking them off the grill - plus, people eat them off the toothpicks).

Take some raw bacon, and cut in about one-inch strips. Top jalapeno hole with bacon piece. Grill at around 400 degrees until soft and done, about 20 minutes or so. When the bacon starts to cook, all the greasy goodness slips down the side of the jalapeno and it takes on a bit of a char, and they sweeten up a bit. If you don’t have the rack, I’ve heard of people wrapping the entire stuffed jalapeno in bacon, and just grilling them on skewers, but I’ve never done it.

I’ve also done these stuffed with whole shrimp, pineapple, and glazed with teriyaki sauce.

They can have a little heat, but mostly they’re pretty mild. My sister and mother tend to be a little wimpy on the spicy foods, but they love these.

So, does anyone have an idea they’d like to share?

Not particularly Christmassy, but I am never unhappy when someone offers me prosciutto-wrapped cantaloupe. Yum. And so easy to make.

The ultimate Bachelor Appetizer: pour a bottle of Pickapeppa Sauce over a block of cream cheese. Serve with crackers. Gets eaten in a flash by just about everybody, takes 5 seconds to prepare, and can be modified presentation-wise to suit any occasion.
eta: Check Post #58 in this thread. kittenblue is a wonderful person for sharing that recipe. We make it every Christmas to rave reviews.

Three replies and I’m already the second person to suggest wrapping something in prosciutto. Frak.

Anyway, asparagus spears wrapped in prosciutto.

It’s Italian, I don’t know the name, but someone will hopefully recognise this and give you the proper recipe:

Little balls of mixed rice and mozarella, bread crumbed and deep fried then served with a spicy tomato sauce.

Oh, and for something more on the spicy side, my wife makes spiced mixed nuts, and they always go over well. As given, the recipe is not too spicy for most people, but you could always up the cayenne if you like.

Rumaki is very tasty and much easier than people think.

I like to brown a pound of spicy sausage and put it in a crockpot with a medium brick of velveeta and a can of rotelle (drained). Serve with tortilla chips.

Kyrie, if you add a teaspoon or so of vanilla to that recipe, it gets a lot more depth.

silenus, is this served cold, or is it heated like a fondue?

Hey, that sounds like it would be good. Thanks for the tip, I’ll give it a try.

Cold, or rather room temperature. Trust me on this one, the taste is out of this world.

Kyrie, de nada.

Since your dinner is on the heavy side, something light might be nice. Shrimp cocktail with a nice spicy horseradish-y sauce is always a big hit around here. Cheese balls (like biscuits) with a green olive tucked inside is tasty (will provide recipe upon request). Not light, but easy, wildly popular and addictive:
Spread thawed puffed pastry sheet with dijon mustard. Shave strips of parmesan from a block with a vegetable peeler and lay over mustard, leaving 1/2" at the short ends. Lay proscuitto (sorry!), ham, or spinach (for vegetarian) on top of that. Roll the whole thing up like a jelly roll and chill. Slice into 1/4" slices and bake til brown and cheese is bubbly…mmm!

Yeah I’d like it, jellyblue.

Since you’re having jalapeno bisque, a jalapeno appetizer is redundant. Likewise prosciutto-wrapped asparagus is redundant if you’re having bacon-wrapped asparagus.

How about mini crab cakes? Here’s a pretty good recipe you can make up in advance, then pop into the oven for 15 min.

Arancini?

I got this from AllRecipes:

Baked Cheese Olives

1 cup shredded Cheddar cheese
3 tablespoons butter, softened
1/2 cup all-purpose flour
1/8 teaspoon cayenne pepper
24 pimento-stuffed green olives

Preheat oven to 400 degrees F
In a small mixing bowl, combine cheese and butter or margarine. Stir flour and cayenne pepper into the cheese and butter mixture. Blend well. Wrap a tablespoon of dough around each green olive. Arrange the wrapped olives
on a cookie sheet. Bake for 15 minutes, or until golden brown.

They’re a bit of a PITA to make, so I usually double the recipe and freeze half - then you have supereasy great last minute appetizers.

My hubby’s website has some fast/easy/cheap appetizer ideas:http://www.cheffrankonline.com/rindex.php?recipe=ihorsdoeuvresrecipes

/he loves me because I’m fast/easy/cheap too