Are Allen Edmonds supposed to be quite stiff?

I got myself a pair of A&E Van Ness last September. They’re the right size, 7.5D.
The inner sole (the part that’s in contact with the foot) is leather and the outer sole (in contact with the ground) is rubber. I use shoe trees.

When I first tried them on, they seemed quite stiff but I figured it would pass. I taped my heels to cut down on the blisters. I wore the shoes 1-2 times a week.

In March, I made the mistake of wearing them for a few hours without taping my heels. The blisters took a week to stop hurting.

We’re in June; 8-9 months later. The upper (the leather covering the foot) is still quite stiff, even after I had the heel broken. The shoes don’t seem to adjust to my foot.

The sole is also stiff; when I walk in them, I feel the shocks through my feet and my right knee hurts. I have no such problems when I wear a pair of Rockport or Florsheim.

What gives? How can I fix that? Did I just buy a pair that happened to be bad? They have a reputation as being the best non-designer dress shoes around so something’s wrong.

Mine don’t seem any stiffer than any other quality dress shoe I have, but they’re not like a tennis shoe. If they’re that uncomfortable, I’d say they just don’t fit you right. I’ve definitely had shoes that are the right size but due to the shape of the shoe aren’t comfortable.

Just think of how painful something like this would be, and quit whining :wink:

It’s not just the shape. I just wore them for about 15 minutes in front of my PC and walking about a bit and my right knees hurts.

Only if you rub him a little first.

Sounds like a fit problem. I’ve had six pair for 22 years. One for each day of the week with an extra.

^^This

Using a metal tape measure the heel to toe interior footbed length space in the shoes you have that are “comfortable”. Now measure the AE’s. Is there a discrepancy?

Shoes, even those from major manufs like AE, can be sized slightly differently depending on the last used. It sounds like you might need an E width or half size larger in that particular shoe.

ARRRRRHAHAHAHAHAHA! choke, sputter, fart!:D:D:D:D

Sorry, gotta give credit where it’s due.

As you were. :slight_smile:

Hope you get this sorted out, Michael. Those blisters sound painful!

Quasi

My A-E’s are generally a bit stiff initially but quickly break in and feel like gloves for my feet after that, even when I wear them for 14+ hours a day.

I loves me my A-E’s. I just wish they’d make the York style boot again.

Jesus! You guys made out of money, or what??? (went to the site)

I think I’ll just stick with my Lands’ End stuff! :):):slight_smile:

Quasi

nm

Does Lands’ End make anything that looks like this?

This is as close as they get.

:)Heh:)! Put me in a pair of those and I wouldn’t match the rest of me. Kinda like wearing a Rolex and driving a 2000 Elantra! :smiley:

Naw, but if I can find a pair of comfortable shoes for $55-60 bucks, I’m a happy boy. If I need something formal (black), then those things are cheaply bought and put away for the next time.

No spam, okay, but I’ve been buying from LE for 25 years and have always been satsified, and sorry for the hijack, but that’s just how I feel about shoes and most other forms of dress.

Thanks

Q