Your analogy is only partially valid for a number of reasons. The political war in Ireland falls along religious lines and it is basically between 2 versions of the same religion. There was a lack of cleric condemnation of the events but that is also true of cleric INVOLVEMENT. There was no call to arms (for a religious cause) by either side. It is not a religious war as much as it is a clash of cultures. It is very similar to the infighting that occurs in Afghanistan between warlords.
Nobody expects every Muslim to condemn every act of terrorism that was done in the name of Islam. However, when a Muslim Cleric openly encourages this activity then it is useful for members of the same religion to stand up and protest. This is helpful because it gives all the followers of that religion another voice…. a voice of reason. It also alleviates the fears that all Muslims feel this way.
You have mentioned in past debates that there is no such thing as a Muslim terrorist because that activity is not approved under Islamic law, therefore the terrorists can’t be representing Islam. You’ve also stated that you cannot judge terrorists and that only Allah can judge them. I can accept that. Using that logic, it would benefit the World if respected leaders of Islam would stand up and point out the obvious.
**
If you think we don’t have enough to do with trying to prevent fundamentalism to take over inside our own nations and with trying to prevent that we ourselves come under attack…
We don’t get much help in that from the West, on the contrary.
Please USA invade some more Islamic nations and shoot some more holes in the bucket we have to fight the flood.
Well… in fact there is now thanks to the nice peaceloving US president and government no bucket left. And the result is now surfacing inside Iraq.**
Your bucket anology didn’t translate well. I’m not sure what you meant to say. You asked for Western help with fundamentalists but in the next sentence condemmed the US for removing Saddam. What should the US have done in Iraq? Should the US concentrate on fundamentalist/terrorists and ignore people like Saddam and Milosevic. I would point out that we had no vested interest in removing Milosevic and establshing what is basically the new Islamic state of Kosovo.
This is the first time I’ve seen someone mention the elephant in the room, and that is the rise in fundamentalism within Muslim nations. I can see only 1 solution and that is to establish a desire for freedom and a respect for alternate religious views.
The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing.
Edmund Burke (1729–1797), Irish philosopher