Are there any TV shows that fail the Bechdel Test?

The Bechdel Test is a test for whether a movie contains:

  1. Two named female characters,
  2. who talk to each other,
  3. about something besides a man.

It’s commonly used as a commentary about the lack of female representation in Hollywood.

TV shows tend to run far longer than movies and thus, most of them end up passing the Bechdel Test. On the list of TV shows I regularly watch, the only one I can point to that definitively fails is HBO’s Looking. It’s about a group of young gay men in San Francisco and the only named female character is Doris.

Are there any TV shows you can think of though that fail the Bechdel Test?

I’m not completely certain, but possibly the original Star Trek? There were a few named female characters, but they were all minor enough that it’s plausible that they never talked to each other.

Mr. Ed

Peep Show

I’m trying to remember any women on McHale’s Navy

Pretty sure Peep Show passes the Bechdel test. Dobby and Sophie have several conversations with each other for example and there’s multiple other examples.

When I’ve seen people discussing the Bechdel test with regard to television, they’re usually talking about individual episodes and not the series as a whole. A movie is typically no more than 2-3 hours long, while the complete run of a successful TV series could add up to over 100 hours. I don’t think it’s really within the spirit of the test to count a brief conversation in a single episode of a TV series that ran for years as a “pass”.

That said, I wouldn’t be terribly surprised if MASH** didn’t pass even that loose version of the test. There were several recurring nurse characters who had names, but when they talked to each other then IIRC it was usually about the male characters. Then again, it’s possible that the nurses exchanged at least a few lines complaining about their living conditions, talking about the war, etc., and a conversation about treating a patient who happens to be a man is arguably not really a conversation about a man.

Were there any women on F-Troop aside from Wrangler Jane?

Boardwalk Empire?

SuperJail, unless JailBot is female. But even then, she doesn’t really “speak”.

Go ahead and watch a few episodes while at work. Employment is overrated.

Law & Order in the early seasons wouldn’t have, with no starring female cast members.

Sherlock, if I recall correctly.

Hogan’s Heroes… maybe

I assume Yeoman Rand and Sulu don’t count. If so, then the very first episode aired passes.

But seriously, I can’t remember two female characters even talking to each other. I can’t remember a landing party with more than one female.* I can’t remember Uhura ever talking to Rand or Nurse Chapel.**

If there were ever a female landing party member and a love interest for Kirk in the same episode…they usually just glared at each other.

*Wait…“Shore Leave” has two women on the planet at the same time.

** Okay the first pilot actually has two women speak to each other. The sparkling, progressive dialogue pretty much consists of, “He doesn’t need you, he has me.”

And Andrea the android talks to Nurse Chapel about a man in “What Are Little Girls made of”

Most any military-based show. Gomer Pyle, Sgt. Bilko, and those already mentioned, have a good chance of failing.

Hm, Red Dwarf probably cuts it, too, with only one main character even arguably female, and very few appearances by any character not in the main cast.

Kristine Kochanski was a major character in seasons 7 and 8, but Holly had changed back to a male appearance by that point so I don’t think Kochanski ever spoke to the female-looking version of Holly.

Most of them fail, even ones full of female characters. If you have a mixed ensemble cast it’s not unusual for it fail both the Bechdel test and the reverse Bechdel test because it’s rare for only the men or the women to have a conversation without talking about the opposite sex. Remember the test was originally invented to help lesbians find movies they’d like.

Take Game of Thrones for example. It has a lot of well written three dimensional women, but they’re spread far apart from each other. When they do interact it’s usually to talk about their place in society with regards to the men and their plans. A lot of episodes do pass, but not as many as you’d think, and only barely.

I haven’t sat down to do a critical analysis or anything, but I bet 95% of Breaking Bad episodes would fail the test. There’s maybe 3.5 major female characters (Skyler, Marie, Lydia who came in late, arguably Andrea) and they rarely talk to each other. I remember Skyler and Marie in early seasons arguing about Marie’s shop lifting. Other than that every conversation I remember was about Hank or Walter.

I’d think similar reasoning would apply to the Sopranos, the Wire, The Shield, etc. The Wire had a lesbian couple, but they weren’t a focus.

For fun, how about shows that not only regularly pass the normal test but fail the reverse Bechdel Test? I’d guess most Orange is the New Black episodes would fail. Most of the cast is female. Piper’s boyfriend talks to his dad, but usually about Piper. There are a couple guys on the prison staff, but they tend to talk about the prisoners or their boss Fig, who is a woman. The readers of Dykes to Watch Out For (where the test originated) probably love this show.

How about Girls? Never saw it, but I’m to understand it’s woman centric.

Some Western animated shows would fail a reverse. The Legend of Korra might regularly fail both because of the ensemble, but later seasons have a majority female cast. Especially the last season, with its female villain.

The single episode with the most Nurse/Nurse interaction, they were basically spending the episode bitching about Maj. Hoolihan. While I’m pretty sure their husbands/boyfriends back home, and the 4077’s doctors did come up, it was mostly about Margaret.

[Bolding mine]

Um, no. The Bechdel test was designed to point out how infrequently women in Hollywood movies are presented as characters in their own right, as opposed to adjuncts or even accessories to the male characters.

Plus, it’s not as though failing the Bechdel Test means a movie is automatically terrible or sexist. It’s just something that makes you think how few fully developed female characters there are.