Some random train of thoughts led me to wonder whether or not there were conscientious objectors in Israel.
Note that I know that 1) there has been members of Tsahal who refused to serve in the occupied territory, but those were sent to jail 2) Jewish guys studying religion aren’t obligated to serve in the armed forces 3)Most Palestinians who are Israeli citizens aren’t even allowedto serve.
So, my question is whether or not there’s a legally sanctionned “conscientious objector” status open to everybody (for instance to, say, an agnostic Israeli Jew), if there is one, what are the conditions (say, would saying “I vaguely object to the current policies, so I’m not really that eager to join the military” be enough, or would you have to submit to a commission of high-ranking officers a 147 pages long essay explaining why your morals prevent you from staying within a 100 yards distance of a swiss army knife?), is there some form of alternative service (a civil service, for instance, or a service within the military in a non-combattant position) for these objectors, assuming they exist and finally, if there’s such an alternative service does it aplies to to the students in religion I mentionned above, or are they just exempt from all obligations?
And while I’m at it, a question maybe more difficult to answer to just crossed my mind : Let’s assume a family immigrate to Israel. 16 y.o. child, contrarily to mom and dad, isn’t particulary interested in living in Israel. S/he now turns 18 and is especially not interested in putting his/her life at stakes in the Gaza strip or something similar… He presumably got Israeli citizenship, an is on Israeli soil. Assuming he’s still citizen of his former country, does he have a way out? Will the Israeli authorities let him leave the country/ renounce Israeli citizenhip before he’s drafted?
Note that this is a purely hypothetical, I don’t have any friend who’s currently dragged in Israel screaming and kicking by his parents, or who’ s envisioning immigrating to Israel but is unwilling to serve in the military or somesuch, so don’t be affraid of giving potentially bad advices (even though I would rather not get factually wrong answers to my questions, of course).