On average, are you ruder to people on the SDMB than in real life?
For me, the answer is definitely yes, unfortunately. I love to argue, and I find that I often call people out / debate them on the SDMB in situations where, in person, I would simply politely ignore them or overlook whatever objectionable thing they said. And I often debate a lot more harshly and bluntly on the SDMB than in person.
Only inasmuch as I’d get fired for telling people at work what I really think. Out in the real world, I’m about the same. I can be quite compassionate, but I’m not going to hold back on telling someone they’re being a fucking tardbasket if they really, really are.
I try to be polite both here and in the real world. I may be slightly ruder here, but that’s because I rarely run into complete idiots in the real world.
I am perhaps a little less… filtered… than I would be IRL, but then again when my sister introduces me to someone, she says, “This is my brother. He was born without a filter.” So I dunno.
But I do know that lots of people here begin slinging nasty insults really quickly, and my guess is if they did that IRL they would already be dead and unable to continue posting.
Bit of a softie online - don’t really have the e-warrior soul so I tend to be quite agreeable. I’m less amiable IRL.
I read threads like a magpie, so I rarely get involved with multiple posting. So if someone wants to nitpick a post or misrepresent it I generally can’t be arsed arguing the toss - it looks quite tiresome and time-consuming to go back and forth, in text, the way some people do to try and articulate their position. Kudos if you’ve got the stamina for it - if everyone posted like me there’d be no internet.
I guess I’m ruder on the SDMB, but it’s sort of like… in real life if I’m having a discussion with someone and they start spouting woo or arguing in bad faith or whatever, I’m probably not going to call them on it and say “Look, you’re arguing in bad faith and there’s no evidence for your positions” or whatever. I’ll probably just smile and walk away and not talk to them anymore.
I’m “ruder” in real life. I feel pile-ons and offence taking happen a lot easier on the internet than IRL. IRL life I can say the most shocking things with a charming smile and people will be fine with it, but here* I feel I have to phrase everything very carefully in order not to be attacked. It’s not that I can’t ever take people disagreeing with me, but a whole bunch of people laying into a post of mine does not brighten my day and I feel I just don’t need that. Therefore I tend to be significantly more “vanilla” than IRL.
*here = The Dope. Which I think has fewer problems than many other boards and is the only board I bother with at all.
I’m generally more polite when I’m writing than speaking, since my brain has more time to catch up with what I’m saying. Of course a lot of time this means I cancel the post before I click submit, so I end up ignoring fools instead of arguing with them.