AT&T proposed merger with Time Warner. What's your opinion?

AT&T is proposing to buy Time Warner for 85 billion dollars. AT&T-Time Warner Deal Is a Shot in the Dark - The New York Times

I’m still reading about the potential benefits and drawbacks to this proposed deal, and I haven’t reached a conclusion yet on what I think of it overall. It seems like this won’t really benefit the consumer. AT&T already has DirecTV, so won’t adding Time Warner just be duplicating a service they already provide? I’m hoping this will somehow reduce prices, but I don’t see how that will happen with this merger. On the other hand, Trump immediately came out against the deal, which raises a red flag with me. Obviously just because Trump takes a particular stand on something doesn’t make his position wrong, but I do wonder what else I might be missing. I’d like to hear what you all think about this deal.

Please feel free to point out the existing thread if there is already one. I checked here and in GD and didn’t see one.

DirectTV is satellite television, while Time Warner is Warner Bros movie studio, HBO, CNN and so forth. I don’t see duplication.

Remember that Time Warner sold its cable operations a while back.

Unimpressed. To bastardize the metaphor, why buy the cow when you can get the milk for a moderate licensing fee?

I think Trump is just opposing it as part of his populist message. Hillary seems to be opposing it too.

In general I’m wary of media consolidation like this, so I’d oppose it on those grounds.

I had forgotten about that. In that case it makes more sense.

Remember that AT&T has more TV customers, between DirectTV and Uverse, than any of the cable operators, including Comcast.

A distribution company buys an entertainment company to provide content, whatcould possibly go wrong?
Most mergers are bad ideas and I don’t see a reason to be hopeful for this one.

In general I think that producers should be able to distribute their own content but that people that distribute content for multiple producers should not be able to produce themselves. So I’m against the merger.

As an employee, my only reaction is to wonder how this might impact my job. They spun part of our operation off to IBM last year–who knows if they’ll spin the remainder off as a cost-cutting measure. I’m looking to retire at the end of 2017, so I don’t care what might happen after that.

There was a good article in the NY Times today about one ATT pitch that the merger is justified by the promise of 5G wireless service. I don’t quite see the connection, but according to the article I don’t have to. 5G will be 10-15 years from widespread adoption and isn’t a real factor in the merger. But it makes a good talking point for the ATT salespeople.

The rise of Ma Bell scares me. . I remember all the abuses of power she wielded. Want an extra phone in your house? That’ll cost you. Want to be excluded from the phone book? That’ll cost you. Answering machines had labels warning us that Ma Bell might get pissed for attaching them to their system.

I lived through the decade long Federal lawsuit to dismantle that monopoly. It cost this country tens of millions to kill that monster.

Now she’s back.

It’s true that people who don’t remember history are doomed to repeat it.

There was a time that my only contact with Ma Bell was my landline. That was one of the “Baby Bells” before they merged back into Ma Bell. My cell phone was Cingular. My TV was DirecTV. Life was good.

AT&T bought Cingular and DirecTV.

Now even the company that makes my movies is getting swallowed up.

Hard to imagine why that would bother me. :smiley:

Not good for anyone but the executives at the two companies. It’s not so much the vertical integration (which is always bad) but the sheer size makes it impossible for small operators to gain a foothold.

It still does if you have a landline, and the cost has risen steadily.

But rest assured, they have our best interests at heart. Ultimately we, the consumers, are going to benefit. Yep.

$85,000,000,000

That’s a lot of money … could be in stock options and stuff like that. I was against it at first, but someone said that they got rid of the cable company part, so I don’t see any conflict.

I use Verizon so I don’t personally care about at&t’s phone business and I use Dish so I don’t care about their sat/entertainment business, but it is a lot of money.

Why? Just to make money off of entertainment to broadcast it on their satellites to talk about it on their cell phones.

What is this world coming to anyway $85 billion dollars for what?