I once was in the awkward position of being the person who had to tell someone her new girlfriend was bad news. In fairness, L was trying to get her shit together, and was going to AA and Al-Anon meetings, but she had been sober only a couple of months, and she had abused her last girlfriend, which I got an earful of, because the ex camped on my couch after she ran out of the apartment they shared. She was terrified to go back and get her stuff. I solved that problem for her.
I was still friends with L, who had spent a night crying on my shoulder about how she had fucked everything up, and she was in love with J (the woman on my couch), but she knew she’d lost her for good.
So L seemed to be working hard-- going to meetings, working at a new job, seeing a therapist, taking antidepressants, and working out-- frankly, I don’t know where she had time to date. But she starts going out with S. S was a college friend of a good friend of mine, W, going back to middle school. W has heard rumors about L’s last relationship, and asks me for the straight dope. I tell her what I know from the part I played. Together, we take S out for coffee and tell her the same story.
I related this story on another MB, and got taken to task for “trashing my friend.”
What could I do? I thought L was redeemable, and I was happy to help her, but at the moment she was bad news in a relationship. She was verbally abusive to J and had her in tears almost daily; finally one day she became physically abusive, and that was when J got out. She still fortunately had enough self-esteem to have the courage to do that. But barely.
Can’t you care about someone, and still think that they are bad news in certain situations, kinds like taking the keys away from someone who is drunk? [/hijack]