Jim Brown
Lawrence Taylor
Ronnie Lott
Walter Payton
Jerry Rice
Randy Moss
Bart Starr
Jack Lambert
Deion Sanders
Reggie White
Dick Butkus
Kellen Winslow Sr
Tom Brady
Joe Montana
Steve Young
Peyton Manning
Barry Sanders
Norm Van Brocklin
Sonny Jurgensen
Lance Allworth
Gayle Sayers
Deacon Jones
Mean Joe Greene
John Stallworth
Anthony Munoz
Larry Allen
Dwight Stevenson
Jim Thorpe
Nobody who played with a round ball?
You know somebody who used their foot to control the ball?
Nobody who played with a different ellipsoidal shaped ball?
Primary criteria being they must have graced the cover of Sports Illustrated?