I recently finished watching this series on DVD and had to come and post about it, because it’s one of the best Masterpiece Theatre productions I have ever seen, and I found it so exciting, and I want to share my excitement! pant
[QUOTE=pseudotriton ruber ruber]
For example, I was very impressed by how they tightened whole chapters on Nemo early on, eliminating Dicken’s subtle, and mysterious, characterizations of him and employing just a shot or two of his face and his carriage to convey “honorable,” “decent,” “long-suffering” etc.
[/QUOTE]
Ah, John Lynch! I thought he was used masterfully: he barely said a word, he was in (what?) 2 episodes? – but what an impression he made because of that face! The misery and degradation and woe he conveyed just with his hooded eyes…brilliant.
I thought Anna Maxwell-Martin was just perfect as Esther. I have cough skimmed the book and I know she was supposed to be the spitting image of her mother, which in this production she is not…and I have read criticisms and posts on other message boards taking her to task for the non-resemblance and, worse, the plainness of her features…but I thought she did a wonderful job bringing Esther to life. She wasn’t the cloyingly sweek, dismally-low-self-esteemed creature of the novel: she was practical and modest and loyal and warm and true, and I loved her. And I loved Mr. Jarndyce, and my poor heart was wrung in two when he gave her up at the end. I didn’t shed a tear for the doofus Richard, but when Mr. Jarndyce told Esther he couldn’t marry her, I couldn’t stop myself from crying along with her. Dear, sweet man! I’m glad Mr. Woodcourt was fleshed out the way he was in the miniseries (more so than in the book, IIRC) – handsome and self-sacrificing and kind-hearted and good to Esther, and I couldn’t fault her for loving him. But I wish Mr. Jarndyce’s story could have ended happily. Or that I could have married him, but never mind that.
I loved the very last scene, though, with everyone waltzing together on the sunny lawn, even Mr. Squod. Which brings me to another reason I loved this miniseries so much – so many of the more minor characters were interesting and delightful in their own right, even Guppy’s silly mother. (Loved Guppy.) There were no boring parts or side-plots you couldn’t care less about…everybody was in on the drama.
And “Shake me up, Judy!” has become a catch-phrase in my house. 