Buddy Holly did NOT die in 1959. What has he been doing since???

Definitely one of the most talented of the earliest Rock n’ Rollers. Also, in my estimation, one of the only “auteur” Rock artists pre-Beatles. What if he hadn’t died at the age of 22?

I think he goes strong until about 1962 focusing more and more on songwriting. At this point popularity declines a bit as it did for all of the early Rockers at this point. As popularity declines he startes to make an effort to record “hits” which results in less quality work and the attempts at “hits” would consequently be unsuccessful.

He may or may not find a place in the late sixties hippie era. His big comeback comes in the early seventies a la Chuck Berry. He securely holds a respected role of elder statesman and possibly collaborates with Dylan, and former Beatles.

He rides this new popularity through the seventies, he is paid respect by the musicians of the emerging punk scene which influences the young punk fans take an interest in his work.

Things slow down in the early eighties, albums and touring less frequent, new work goes unnoticed. Puts out one of the best albums of his career in the late eighties with one single becoming a big hit probably produced by Jeff Lynne (a la Roy Orbison). Collaborates with Elvis Costello. May possibly join the Traveling Wilburys or the Highwaymen.

Puts out a new album no more frequently than every three years, at least one produced by Mitchell Froom. Performs an all-star “celebration” concert, similar to the Chuck Berry “Hail! Hail! Rock n’ Roll” concert, and the Dylan 30 year anniversary concert.

Has lived a private life since 1997 with no touring and no new recordings.

So, what do you think?

He’s been hanging upside down in Rick, Vyvyan, Nigel and Mike new house of course.

Ok, I’ll go away now.

After losing the coin toss, and narrowly escaping death by airplane crash, he tragically dies later that night after choking on his own vomit.

[Mike [snip] looks over the corner and sees Buddy Holly hanging upside down by a parachute, covered in spider webs.]

[snip]

MIKE: [stares, amazed] You’re Buddy Holly!!

[snip]

MIKE: I thought you were dead!

BUDDY: Lots of folks did, but it ain’t harmed my career any. [laughs]

MIKE: No. [pause] You got any new material? [grabs tape recorder]

BUDDY: Well, it just so happens I’ve been writing a song up here. It’s a song concerning my diet. It’s called “Kinky Daddy Longlegs”. You wanna hear it?

[snip]

BUDDY: [starts playing guitar and singing]
Saturday night
Hanging round for a bite
Find a real cutie with the dust mite blues
Hangnail, high tail, fairy tale, very well
Finding anything that I can chew

MIKE: [punching numbers into a calculator] Records and tapes. Videos. Overseas sales. Cable TV. 60 percent McCartney, 40 percent me. It’s got to be 25 million at least.

BUDDY: Coo coo daddy longlegs
Rough it up, rough it up, oh oh oh oh
Rain fly pie with a mosquito side salad
23 years on a meat-free diet
Beetles, crickets, gonna get you sick
It’s here’s a little sucker and you ought to try it
Coo coo, daddy longlegs
Hope it makes more money than “Peggy Sue”-ue
Ha ha ha ha ooooh

[Buddy’s parachute lets loose and he crashes down, his head breaking through the floor. Mike sighs, puts down the calculator, goes over to Buddy]

MIKE: Well, I’ll probably get a few quid on the guitar.

I think Holley would have drifted into country music like several other early rockabilly stars did.

At the time of his death, Holly was moving away from basic rock ‘n’ roll toward orchestrated pop/rock of the sort Bobby Vee late created. Some of Holly’s late recordings, like “Moondreams,” are pure orchestral pop songs. Vee’s style was in many ways a direct continuation of Holly’s since Vee debuted at the show Holly would have played if he hadn’t died, and overtly patterned himself in Holly’s image.

So I think Holly would have continued to have hits in the '60s in this teen idol vein, then, when the British Invasion happened, he might have tried to create music in that style as Vee and the Crickets did, but wouldn’t have had much success. Then he would have moved toward country-rock like Sonny Curtis and Ricky Nelson, in the late '60s, eventually making straight country music hits in the '70s. Tons of '50s rockers and '60s teen idols had country hits in the ‘70s: Pat Boone, Paul Evans, Jumpin’ Gene Simmons, Johnny Tillotson, Dorsey Burnette, Elvis, Billy “Crash” Craddock, Mac Davis, etc.

Then he would have been rediscovered by the rock audience in the '80s to go through that whole thing.

According to the movie The Buddy Holly Story Holly’s wife was pregnant at the time of his death.

I’ve never heard anything about Buddy Holly having a child, though. Does anyone know what became of that potential offspring?

After the Russians dropped an atomic bomb on America, the last bastion of civilization is the kingdom of Lost Vegas, where Elvis ruled for decades as king. The king is now dead, and dozens of wandering musicians and fighters travel through the vast American wastelands on their way to Lost Vegas, where the greatest among them will ascend to the throne.

Buddy is one of them, a taciturn man in a black suit and glasses, armed with a hollow-body Gretsch guitar and a razor-sharp katana sword that has tasted blood many times. He will take a small child under his wing, and duel to the death with evil bowlers, a cannibal clan styled after a 1950s sitcom family, a Siberian surfabilly band up to no good, the entire Russian army, and Death himself, in the guise of a heavy metal guitarist.

Buddy is… the Six-String Samurai.

I hope I’m wrong but I think I heard she miscarried…possibly because of the trauma of his death :frowning: :frowning: :frowning: .

Wouldn’t you have liked to see Buddy Holly and Elvis Costello on the same stage, circa 1990?

My thought exactly.

Jerry Lee Lewis and Elvis both recorded country music after their pop careers flamed out. Ditto the Everley Brothers. Johnny Cash began his career at Sun Records with Elvis and Jerry Lee.

Conway Twitty started in rockabilly.

Even Ray Charles made the switch to country music in the 60s.

Waylon Jennings was a Buddy Holly associate and sometime bandmate.

It would make perfect sense for Buddy to have made the switch to country.

Screaming, “Let me out of this coffin! For god’s sake, I’m alive! Let me out!”

Of course he didn’t die in 1959. Buddy Holly is alive and well on Ganymede. Everyone know that!

He probably survived, gave up the music business, became a carpenter, and spent the last 50 or so years decking halls.

Buddy Holly appears in one of the “Wild Cards” books alive and well. The story is about some benefit concert and Holly plays and becomes some sort of rock and roll shaman or something… I read it as a teen and thought it was silly then.

Deck the halls with Buddy Holly?

That’s terrible.

While on his way home from the airport, Buddy Holly was in a terrible car accident. He was taken to the hospital in a coma. He never came out of it, dying in 1974.

You are correct. From this informative article:

Buddy’s original name was Charles Hardin Holley – he later dropped the “e” from his surname.