[QUOTE=clairobscur]
I picked you randomly for this question : I’m an atheist, but were I still catholic, I would have found such a practice both superstitious and disrepectful, at best.
Maybe I would have found more kosher to ask a saint to intercede by praying, possibly in front of a respecteful displayed statue (preferably in a church), and even that would have disturbed me (I wouldn’t have liked the concept of praying in order to get money quick, except in case of dire financial hardship).
But burying a saint’s statue upside down so that it will magically attract people willing to spend a lot of money?
My question here is adressed to actually catholic posters. Aren’t some of you disturbed by such a practice?
[/QUOTE]
Great queston - thanks!
The statue I purchased included a prayer card. The idea was to pray the intercession to St. Joseph daily while the statue is buried. (I didn’t, maybe that’s why mine didn’t work so well.)
I find many of the trappings of the church interesting relics of a long ago age, and of little relevance to my daily practice of living my faith. But you bring up the interesting point of idolatry. Many non-Catholics accuse us of idol worship because of our supposed devotion to statuary. However, it was drilled into us again and again in Catholic school that we do NOT worship statues - they merely serve as reminders of the real people that they represent.
To say it is disrepectful to bury a statue would mean that the statue in and of itself is worthy of some particular honor. Or that the statue itself holds some sort of power. For contrast, consider other faiths that *do * believe that their statues are an incarnation of the diety that they represent. They treat their statues with honor, because they believe that the god is present in that statue.
The statue that I buried was a 4" tall hunk of plastic that happened to be in the supposed form of a man who lived >2000 years ago. I see no disrespect in burying plastic. I *do * agree that it is superstitious, because if the statue is just a hunk of plastic, why should it help? However, I see no harm in a little benign superstition.
As for the issue of praying for help in financial matters, people pray for all sorts of things. I was never taught that only certain matters are worthy of prayer, and that others are selfish. The financial difficulties of carrying two mortgages would have eventually proved a large burden on my family. Prayer is used as a means of dealing with burdens of all sorts, in all types of religions.