Any arguments with any? Keep in mind it’s not the best novel set in every state, it’s the most famous novel set in every state. So if you want to say there’s a more famous novel set in Washington than Twilight, you’d better have something to back it up other than the book’s quality.
I’d say Michener’s Chesapeake is more famous than Anne Tyler’s Dinner at the Homesick Restaurant for Maryland.
Even for Tyler, wouldn’t The Accidental Tourist be more famous? The film version got Geena Davis an Oscar. I don’t know, I’ve never read anything of hers.
ETA: Plus, there are some Tom Clancy novels that have a lot of Maryland settings, although his novels are literally set all over the world.
The Great Gatsby is a good choice for New York but I think Ragtime by E.L. Doctorow would have been a better one. While arguably The Great Gatsby is a better novel, I think Ragtime is more “set” in its location.
I would put any of Raymond Chandler’s novels over Steinbeck for California. Not even close. Heck, The Maltese Falcon probably would beat out even those.
In fact, they made a huge mistake by allowing any genre or bestselling books in at all, because it makes their literary choices nonsensical. Peyton Place should win for New Hampshire, Love Story for Massachusetts, The Bridges of Madison County for Iowa, and I’d agree about *Chesapeake *for Maryland. You could also have a real interesting battle for Mississippi between Faulkner and the three novels Grisham set there.
The Shining is what I first thought of before seeing the list. I would’ve liked to have seen Michener’s *Centennial * instead (it inspired the 1978 miniseries and, to me, it is much more representative of the state), but one really can’t argue that it’s more famous than The Shining.
I thought of In Cold Blood for Kansas; I’m guessing less than 10 percent of The Wizard of Oz is set in the Sunflower State (but it is somewhat more uplifting than Capote’s book).