[QUOTE=DanBlather]
So I guess calling someone a money grubbing Jew is OK because jew is descriptive and not all Jews are money grubbing. How about bean-eating Mexican, lazy Puerto Rican, drunken Irishman, and cheap Scotsman.
[/QUOTE]
FWIW I’m of Irish descent and “Drunken Irishman” is fine with me. Just about every native Irish person (including Grampa from Limerick) I’ve known has been what I would consider a heavy drinker. It is a stereotype, which - while simplistic and sometimes offensive - are frequently used as a humorous way of generalizing about a group. If you are so sensitive that you can’t handle it, and want to pretend that there aren’t general characteristics of groups that don’t necessarily pertain to everyone in those groups…ummm…again…spend your time in MPSIMS.
Bean-eating Mexican is such a strong cultural trait that I’m tempted to call it a fact. Every Mexican I’ve ever known (including a former girlfriend) ate a lot of beans. Every single Mexican restaurant I have ever been in, including many in Mexico, have served beans as a side on virtually every platter. What do you find offensive about Bean-eating Mexican?
I haven’t known many Puerto Ricans, and those I did were drug dealers, but my sample is so small that I wouldn’t subscribe to a stereotype along those lines. I’ve never heard the Lazy Puerto Rican meme, so I don’t quite know what to say about it. Maybe factually inaccurate, and if so, not particularly offensive - more stupid than anything.
Of course Money Grubbing Jew has an enormously strong historical context, of which I’m sure you are well aware, and thus much more care should be used in pulling that out. Your joke using that stereotype had damn well better be pretty funny.
I can’t believe you can’t understand how cultural references should and shouldn’t be used, and that the context means a lot. The context of the OP is in a PIT rant. Figure it out.
[QUOTE=DanBlather]
BTW, I’ll concede “rent control” and substitute the longer but more descriptive “control of how often you can raise rent”.
[/QUOTE]
Thats the smartest thing you’ve written in this thread.