Can YOU tell?

Oh, please, Spider, I have said that I am not angry with you, and I don’t think for a moment you meant to offend, or evem thought it would offend.

But the site is a horror to the small number of us who don’t like being told that we are freaks or “in disguise” or being called “shemales.” It’s the equivalent to showing a photo of Halle Berry with the caption “Nigger or Not?” Only worse, in a way, because no one (I hope!) laughs and points at black people for being black anymore.

Again, I probably am being overly sensitive, but I am not blaming you for posting the site; only pointing out that, ouch.

In all fairness, not all drag queens are transgendered, and there’s nothing to indicate that these are transfolk, pre- or post-op, rather than drag queens. Non-transgendered drag queens are men, just as you are a woman.

CrazyCatLady, by definition, a drag queen is transgendered.

Anyway, those pictures look to me to be cropped out of porn. Virtually all transgendered individuals who do porn are pre-operative male-to-female transsexuals who are doing porn to pay for hormones. It’s a very exploitative business. And I’ve yet to hear of a drag queen doing porn. So I’d say that the odds are pretty damn good that those are transsexuals, not drag queens, and further that most of them are pre-op (the post-ops almost always quit the business, since they’re no longer equipped for the job).

Perhaps you can expound on this for the clueless among us. I would have thought that, although a drag queen can be transgendered, it doesn’t automatically make a person transgendered. I would also have thought, based on my limited experience, that there are a lot of drag queens who are genetically male and identifiy as either gay or straight males. I would consider “drag queen” to be a kind of theatrical transvestite.

So can you explain a little further what definition you are using and how it differs? Thanks.

Yumanite:

So while I’m not really comfortable with the use of “transgender” to refer to drag queens, the fact remains that the term is generally used to refer to a group that does include drag queens.

Well, regardless of all that, I think we can agree that “spot the shemale!” is pretty fucking inexcusable.

I don’t get it.

Assuming the grouping is females and pre-op females, I didn’t catch the humour.

There was NO humor, I just thought the link was interesting. I am confused as to all the PC terms for different lifestyles these days. I think I need a guide because the terms change so quickly.

And Homebrew, did I deserve a co-worker calling me that? If I messed up doing my job, I could possibly understand being insulted, which isn’t the best way to rectify a problem but it happens. I have been called cunt by my ex-husband but that is not what made me leave him. Honestly, it’s just a word.

Being a transexual is no more a lifestyle than being a diabetic is.

Imagine if you clicked on one of the pictures and a big X and “Diabetic” poped up. It would be odd, no?

I see, KellyM. Thanks for clearing that up for me.

Wow I got a 16/16, which pleasantly surprised me. What also surprised me was the test being available 13 years later, considering it’s a zombie thread. I have to say I had to say for some I had to really consider before choosing an answer. So I’m not rooting my horn.

That being said it is a stupid test that should not be taken seriously.

Don’t ask me how I came upon on this old thread and revived it after 13 years.

This is a 13 year old thread and a pretty outdated and offensive one at that.

Locked.