I agree, but ceremonial guards are also a greater target by virtue of their uniform and ceremonial duties. Maybe arming them isn’t the right answer, but it should be acknowledged that they’re a greater target.
Greater target in what way? How many times in history are ceremonial guards a terrorist target? As happened last week, off duty soldiers are far and away a more common target. Greater because killing one makes a bigger statement? Maybe to some degree but it’s debatable.
Feeling is mutual. Out of all the countries in the world, If I had to choose again… it still be the U.S. I’d want as my neighbour.
More details from CBC News. It’s amazing to think that the sergeant-at-arms is largely a ceremonial position that involves carrying a symbolic golden mace – this guy was more like an action-movie hero:
Except it’s not a largely ceremonial position. He is the head of security for Parliament.
I’m aware of that. It was even discussed earlier in this thread and his position as head of security is mentioned several times in the article you linked here. But as you also mentioned over here, this is the first time he’s fired a gun in the line of duty in his career, including 29 years with the RCMP. I was really just commenting on his amazing heroics for someone who spends a lot more time on ceremonial duties than shooting bad guys! He really put himself at risk throwing himself in front of the shooter like that – it’s the kind of stuff you usually only see in movies.
The fact that this is the first time he’s fired a shot in the line of duty speaks more to the nature of policing in Canada, and likely his own approach to the job.
That record isn’t that unusual, from conversations I’ve had with police officers.
Just because an RCMP officer can retire after 29 years without firing a shot does not mean that they hold ceremonial positions. 
I would think most police in Canada go a whole career without firing their gun in the line of duty.
Actually most police in the US, even those who work in the big cities like Chicago, LA, or New York go their entire careers without discharging their weapons.
Yes, people might be surprised at that based on the way things are portrayed in Hollywood and the media, but it’s the truth.
I’d love it if the media could best be exemplified by the slogan “nothing but the truth” but “if it bleeds, it leads” is vastly more accurate.
It’s my understanding that’s true of most police in most of the westernized nations, at least where they’re used for law enforcement and not oppression.
Maybe I’m out of line in wondering, but was the shooter perchance involved with the Ottawa Panhandlers Union?
Funny enough he was staying at a local homeless shelter but I doubt he was in that union.
You do realize, of course, that your are inviting a return of that nutter. ![]()
Oh come on, he was one of the most adorable lunatics the board has ever seen.
IIRC, he was banned.
Great, first it was Justin Bieber and now an unlicensed panhandler terrorist.
Oh, I wasn’t trying to suggest that Canadian policing was unusual. It’s just that I know a bit about Canadian policing, and not much about policing in other western countries, so was restricting my comment to what I knew about. I’m not surprised to hear it’s similar in other western countries.
Agreed, but one can have too much of a good thing. ![]()
I was just wondering if the Dope had a closer connection to this guy than we’d like to realize. The shelter-resident community on Ottawa can’t be all that large.
Well, here’s something to debate: was this crime or was it terrorism?
I say crime. It looks like the shooter was a lone nut who was trying hard to get involved in overseas conflict but since he couldn’t do that he decided to bring the conflict here. I don’t think he was specifically told by ISIS/Al Qaeda/etc that he should do this. I think his drug addiction is much more of a motivating factor than his religion. Most importantly, I think we should respond to it as if it is crime rather than terrorism. CSIS can have all the power in the world to investigate and detain and etc but what this guy needed was mental health authorities and addiction counseling.