Cast the new Three's Company movie

So as we all found out from a recent thread, there is a new Three’s Company movie in the works. Let’s help the producers cast this upcoming period film with modern-day actors.

To refresh everyone’s memory, Three’s Company revolves around three young, single roommates—two women and a man—sharing a Santa Monica apartment in the late 1970s and early 1980s. The landlords, ever mindful of propriety, are adamant that unmarried men and women should not live together. They make a special exception for the three protagonists only because they are deceived into believing that the man is gay. The show is a comedy of errors, most of the humour arising from cases of mistaken identity and of overheard conversations being misconstrued.

Your job, should you choose to accept it, is to nominate modern actors for the following roles:

[ul]
[li]Jack Tripper, an affable but slightly clumsy cooking student who shares an apartment with two young women, Janet and Chrissy. His bachelor lifestyle is frequently frustrated by his need to maintain his cover as an openly gay man. Played in the original series by John Ritter.[/li][li]Janet Wood, a level-headed brunette who works at a flower shop. Originally played by Joyce DeWitt.[/li][li]Chrissy Snow, a blond-haired, airheaded office secretary. Originally played by Suzanne Somers.[/li][li]Stanley Roper, the trio’s hard-nosed, middle-aged landlord and downstairs neighbour. Though tolerant of Jack’s alleged homosexuality, he frequently mocks him for it. For his part, Mr. Roper seems completely averse to sex, at least with his wife. Played in the original series by Norman Fell.[/li][li]Helen Roper, Mr. Roper’s long-suffering, muumuu-wearing wife. She figures out early on that Jack isn’t really gay, but sympathizes with him and so keeps this information from her husband. Audra Lindley in the original series.[/li][li]Larry Dallas, the trio’s upstairs neighbour and Jack’s best friend. Larry is a smooth-talking used car salesman. He lives the life of a swinging bachelor and comes from a large Greek family. Role originated by Richard Kline.[/li][li]Ralph Furley, who replaces the Ropers as landlord after they sell the building and move away. Mr. Furley is timid, high-strung, and has a terrible fashion sense, yet considers himself a consummate Lothario, and is confident that as a role model he will one day “cure” Jack of his homosexuality. Originally played by Don Knotts.[/li][/ul]
If you really want, you can also cast actors for the starring but short-lived roles of Cindy Snow (Chrissy’s accident-prone cousin, who replaced her as the third roommate), Terri Alden (an intelligent, sassy nurse, who eventually replaced Cindy), and Lana Shields (an older female neighbour who relentlessly pursues Jack, and who is in turn pursued by Mr. Furley).

Jack Tripper - Taran Killam or Jimmy Fallon
Chrissy & Janet - Beth Behrs and Kat Jennings
The Ropers - R. Lee Emery and Shirley Knight
Larry Dallas - Kyle Mooney

Jack Tripper - Jason Bateman
Chrissy & Janet - Kat Dennings and Abigail Breslin
The Ropers - J.K. Simmons and Lisa Kudrow
Larry Dallas - Paul Rudd

I’ve said before that my choice for Jack Tripper is Neil Patrick Harris.

Oooh, nice ones!

I’m a bit surprised by a lot of the choices for Jack, Janet, Chrissy, and Larry that have been posted so far. Most of those actors are way, way older than the characters they’re meant to be playing. But I guess if the shoe otherwise fits…

I don’t have any strong casting opinions, but about 10 years ago I saw sketch comedians and frequent longtime writing/performing partners June Raphael and Casey Wilson do an extended sketch / one-act play in which they played feuding former co-stars from an old sitcom. The fictional sitcom was directly based on Three’s Company and June Raphael played the Joyce DeWitt role while Casey Wilson played the Suzanne Somers role. The two of them are brought back together for the funeral of their former leading man co-star (this was performed shortly after John Ritter had died).

I saw someone suggest comedians Pete Holmes, Riki Lindhome, and Kate Micucci, which is quite good.

What about using the cast of Big Bang? Parsons as Jack, Kaley as Chrissy, Mayim as Janet, Kuna as Larry, Keith Carradine and Laurie Metcalf as the Ropers and Johnny as Furley.

Well, I’m going for family tradition and I cast Jason Ritter as Jack.

And how about his costar from the forgotten TV show The Class, Lizzie Caplan as Janet?

Sexy naive blonde? It’s the XXI century, we should have more diversity than 1970’s TV. How about Gugu Mbatha-Raw in full Foxy Brown get up? Or Chanel Iman?

Larry Dallas should be played by Paul F. Tompkins. Because he should be everywhere and rocks the 70’s 'tache anyway.

No Ropers, let’s go straight for Mr. Furley, played by none other than Clint Eastwood. Wait. Hear me out, wait. The landlord should *SCAAARE *Jack. It never made any sense that they all would go through those lengths just because a regular person like the Ropers may be slightly peeved at them for breaking arbitrary rules.

I’d go with the cast of iCarly for Jack and the girls and Larry and with Tyler Perry and Tyler Perry as the Ropers.
Then I’d scrap the whole project and air reruns of Carter Country instead.

[ul]
[li]Jack Tripper - Kenan Thompson[/li][li]Janet Wood - Alison Brie[/li][li]Chrissy Snow - Alexandra Daddario[/li][li]Stanley Roper - Larry Miller[/li][li]Helen Roper - Jacki Weaver[/li][li]Larry Dallas - Zachary Levi[/li][li]Ralph Furley - Steve Buscemi[/li][/ul]

Sean Hayes as Mr. Furley as a Bible-thumping homophobe that everybody knows is gay except for him might work. Especially if he’s in love with Larry (Lance Bass) but doesn’t realize it.

How about a Married w/ Children Theme

Ed O’Neill and Katay Sagal as the Ropers.

Amanda Bearse as Mr Furley.

Tough call to replace John Ritter. Neil Patrick Harris has the skills, he’d have to recall the innocence of the teen character he left behind to do what John did. It’s possible. I think Ryan Reynolds could do it if he isn’t too old now to pull it off. Any young physical comic actor can do it by changing the character though, it just has to be someone who can make himself appear sexually ambiguous.

The girls don’t matter, the original show proved that.

Mr. Furley or the Ropers are wide open for casting, they were also replaceable characters. Really, you just need to cast Jack and and some hot blondes.

If they were doing this at all they should have twisted things around, somehow make Jack actually gay and pretending to be straight or something quite different about the show. I understand it’s taking place in the 70s, and it maybe it will be like a retrospective on the 70s as shown on TV in the manner of other sitcom based movies. It would be better IMHO finding new gender twisting situations done purely for fun in the modern world, but maybe that’s been done to death already.

Stunt casting: Suzanne Somers as Mrs. Roper. Jeffrey Tambor as Mr. Roper.

The Furley character should be left out. Wasn’t a good character on the show.

No love for Ann Wedgeworth’s Lana Shields? Stunt casting part 2: Priscilla Barnes.

I like this idea. Buscemi would be perfect as Ralph Furley.

For Mrs. Roper, I’d suggest Jennifer Coolidge. For Mr. Roper, Casey Sander (he plays Bernadette’s father on “The Big Bang Theory”).

[ul]

[li]Jack Tripper - Colin Hanks[/li][li]Janet Wood - Lily Allen[/li][li]Chrissy Snow - Bella Thorne[/li][li]Stanley Roper - Kurtwood Smith[/li][li]Helen Roper - Christine Baranski[/li][li]Larry Dallas - Nick Jonas[/li][li]Ralph Furley - Chris Parnell from Suburgatory [/li][/ul]

Brilliant! I love these even more than Elendil’s Heir’s suggestions.

I’m not so sure. Buscemi can definitely do the loner, unlucky-with-women type, but his characters are usually a bit dark, even creepy. Furley is a good-natured, knee-slapping, flamboyantly dressed guy. Beneath the surface he’s lonely and subservient, but disguises this with a comically overplayed veneer of bravado and machismo. Has Buscemi ever demonstrated an aptitude for that kind of clownish role?

On 30 ROCK, he got an Emmy nomination in the recurring role of a private eye who pretty much fits the bill: always trying to talk to his boss as an equal in between going undercover – which is to say, thinking his upbeat one-of-us line of patter is working, while thinking his latest outfit is a look he’s pulling off – sure as he’ll amiably do the finish-your-sentence bit, and think it went well, and grin.