I have a dish I make with chicken thighs. Generally, what I do is take a couple of bell peppers (anything but green) and julienne them into relatively skinny sticks, then toss them into a small square casserole dish with a bit of olive oil and balsamic vinegar, season with pepper and garlic salt. I also season with flavored meat tenderizer. which seems weird but somehow works with the peppers.
Then I take a small packet of boneless chicken thighs (can’t remember the size, my wife gets them in bulk at Costco), towel them dry then coat them completely with “Lawry’s Perfect Blend Chicken & Poultry Rub”. This gets layered on top of the peppers in the casserole dish, generally it’s enough to fully cover the peppers.
Finally, cover the chicken with shredded cheese. The actual cheese varies on a whim. It could be sharp cheddar, or swiss, pepper jack, or a blend of them. After that, seal the top of the casserole dish (mine comes with a lid but you can use cling wrap or foil). Leave it in the fridge until next day’s dinner time. I try to let it rest for at least 24 hours as that lets the peppers marinate and the seasoning will really get into the chicken.
Once it gets close to dinner time, I preheat the oven to 425 degrees. I take out the dish, remove the lid, and sprinkle some mini croutons (you can get them in a shaker bottle at the grocery store, they look like this). The croutons will add a really good texture to the top, but you have to wait until shortly before you put it in the oven to keep them crisp. I have tried using breadcrumbs but they don’t quite have enough texture.
Once the oven is preheated, stick the whole thing in there for 30 minutes. Then pull it out, let it cool a few minutes, and serve. The peppers will be tender and almost like noodles, and will soak up not only the spices and flavors you toss it with, but all the drippings above from the chicken and cheese. The peppers are set as a side dish on a plate next to the chicken with a serving.
It’s extremely easy and pretty delicious. The great thing is that when it’s time to cook it, it’s pretty much ready to go, and you just leave it in the oven for a relatively short time. It’s good to prep ahead of time when you want some home-cooked food and don’t have a lot of time or energy to make it.
I mix it up a bit with spices, sometimes also coat the chicken in a sauce on top of the seasoning. Sometimes I try to make it a bit more Mexican, or Italian, etc. But it’s one of my go-to chicken dishes.