Choose which of these tragedies to avert.

New week = new Skaldthetical with a longish storytelling OP and possibly a poll. Let’s see what I can come up with in ten minutes.

Your nation’s biggest city has become a wretched hive of scum and villainy, so Pallas Athena, Queen of Olympus, has decided to clean the place up. Through subtle means she’ll be guiding systemic reform, but she’s also appointed a super-powed champion to deliver emergency asskickings, and that’s you.[sup]1[/sup] Your powers include Captain-America-level physical skills; short-range teleporting; limited shapeshifting (you can only mimic humans, so you fight crime wearing looking like either Pam Grier or RipppedShirt!Kirk; and, most importantly, minor clairvoyance. Mostly you use the ESP to warn you of danger and aim your teleports, but by concentrating you can get precognitive flashes of up to 6 hours in the future. [sup]2[/sup] Use too much power too quickly, and you’ll run out till you get sufficiently rested and fed. You’ve been at this for about two years. The public is torn about you, and the cops definitely dislike you, as you not only helped bring down the former commissioner to prison on corruption charges, but on two occasions prevented traffic-stop murders through the power of sweet reason and right hooks.

Anyhoo, as our story opens, it’s an hour before dawn, and you’re just finishing up a particularly busy night of do-gooding. Before 'porting home, you decide to do one last ESP sweep to make sure nothing needs your attention. Unfortunately you don’t pick up one crisis, but three.

  1. At that very moment, thirty miles away–at the very limit of your teleport range–an abusive husband has decided to punish his wife for leaving him by tossing their six-year-old son off a bridge and into a raging river. The kid has already hit the water. Going to his rescue will almost exhaust your teleportation ability, leaving you just enough juice to jump home, but you’ll still retain your other powers. You’ll be able to save the kid and swim to shore. The most direct route there will take you into the sight of a TV news crew, who will laud your heroism and give you some much-needed good publicity.

ii) Also at that very moment, ten miles miles away, a warehouse is ablaze; three firemen fighting the inferno have been separated from their comrades by falling rubble. They’ll be dead in minutes unless you get them out. But you can carry only one adult at a time while teleporting, so you’ll need at least six jumps, and you’re already tired. By the time you’re done, you’ll have exhausted all your power for at least a day. That means you’d have to get home by normal means, wearing your own face but otherwise in full costume and gear.

Oh, and speaking of fire …

Ɣ) Five minutes from now, five miles away, a pair of corrupt, racist police officers will set fire to the city’s oldest white church. The cops themselves are white; they’re aiming to frame a group of black peace activists who have been criticizing the department on several fronts (one of whom has made some unfortunate inflammatory statements about arson at historic black churches) in order to discredit them. No one is in danger from this fire, but it’s certain to aggravate racial problems in the already tense city. (There have been riots recently, and much of the reason you were so busy tonight is that you were unstirring shit started by jackholes on both sides.) You could 'port there now and kick their asses preemptively, but in that case it will seem that you attacked a pair of cops without provocation, not to mention you probably won’t be able to save the baby or the firemen.

What do you do?[sup]3[/sup] Whom do you save?

Oh, and my pasta’s here, so screw the poll.

[sup]1[/sup] Yes, you get a costume, but nothing fancy: basically Kevlar body armor and whatever mêlée weapons you judge most useful. No, you don’t get supertech or magic talismans. Because I said so.
[sup]2[/sup] Of course you used the precognition to win the lottery early on. Super-heroing is both expensive and a full-time job.
[sup]3[/sup] No, you can’t call Athena for help or even advice. She’s busy with her own shit. A group of Brobdingnagian space gods are currently judging whether humanity should be exterminated, and She is occupied arguing for the defense.

I make myself look like Donald Trump, and push the kid under.

Regards,
Shodan

Save a kid, save 3 firemen, or stop a riot which might claim a few lives short term and many more later? This is why I quit being a superhero. Damn, the kid I guess, I can call the papers about the church fire. I’d also be all over whoever put those firefighters in such danger since apparently no other lives were at stake.

Hmmm. I guess I save the kid. He’s helpless and innocent; the good publicity for me is just a bonus.

The firefighters are doing what they feel called to do; I honor their service but I can’t help them and the kid.

I know who the crooked cops are and can soon tell an honest local cop (or the FBI) who they are, and that they should be the focus of any investigation into the arson. Even if that doesn’t pan out, I can let them know I know what they did, and keep them on their toes in the future.

↑ ↑ ↑ Close nuff to save me typing it out. Thanks… :smiley: :cool:

I’ve probably read too many comic books,* but…

First, I’d change my appearance to resemble the activist that the cops are trying to frame, then go rescue the kid. No one is directly in danger from the arson, and by giving the activist an alibi I may be adding just enough uncertainty to keep the city from erupting into riots, and prompt an investigation.

Then, instead of returning home, I’d teleport to the warehouse (changing back to my crusader guise) and lend what aid I could to the firefighters with my Captain America skills and melee weapons, hoping that the fact that I’m still soaking wet from the river will give me at least a few moments’ protection from the flames.

  • Just kidding. There’s no such thing as reading too many comic books.

All of them.

I’m that good.

I really like Elendil’s Heir’s answer, and will fall back to it, but, alas, my Utilitarian instincts say to prevent the church burning, solely on the basis of the number of lives saved.

Yes, the kid in the river is innocent…but there might be five or fifteen kids in the church, and they’re just as innocent.

Utilitarian calculus is famously flawed: it can go straight to hell in a heartbeat. But in this case, that’s how I’d be guided.

Apart from the fact that you’re fighting the hypo (which is about a moral dilemma, not being clever), the problem with your plan is that it’s a wasted effort. The problem facing you is that you have a limited amount of power and are running low; that’s why you have to choose between the kid and the firefighters. Mimicking the activist for the river rescue will make you less effective in the firefighter rescue, which you already know will leave you so exhausted you’ll be temporarily non-super. Moreover, yes, you’ll be giving one of the activists a televised alibi – but you’ll also be outing him or her to the world as the mysterious grey-garbed vigilante resented by cops and hated by crooks. Now your enemies will be going after the activist, who DOESN’T’ HAVE SUPER-POWERS TO DEFEND HIMSELF.

Melee weapons aren’t going to help in the warehouse. You haven’t any supertech or magic weapons, so there’s no adamantium blades or vibranium shield. You also will be out of teleports once you jump from the river to the warehouse, and probabably out of power entirely, so you’ll be moving around trying to help without any special advantages–or, for that matter, breathing gear. Whyn’t you just stab yourself and spare yourself the trouble?

There are no kids in the church; the OP is explicit about that, and as the information comes from your clairvoyance you presumably believe it. And if there were 5kids in the church, there might be an emotional dilemma but there’d be no ethical one.

The church is a problem because its burning MIGHT cause bigger problems, but then again might not. You don’t have that information.

I’d have to save the kid myself. The firemen would bother me because of their greater numbers, but given that they’re firemen I’d be willing to bet that, if there were time to ask them, they’d want the kid saved over their own lives. I’d have to roll the dice on the church, hoping that I’d be able to get the activists off the hook for the arson and that cooler heads would prevail re: the social unrest.

Save the kid. This sucks.

Afterwards, help in the investigation that will exonerate the black peace activists and indict the racist cops. Shouldn’t be too hard since I already know who is really responsible.

Oops; sorry, missed that. I thought the church-burning would kill a bunch of people. The threat of future riots is not relevant to my decision, because it might not happen. There are good people all through the city who will work to calm down tensions and forestall a riot. But I’m the only one who can save the firemen or the kid.

Firemen, then. Three is better than one.

(Also, although this, too, is slightly fighting the hypothetical, someone else nearby might jump into the river and save the kid, but only superpowers will save the firemen.)

Definitely the firemen. If the kid is truly an innocent (and you’d have to prove it - I know too many kids!) then Athena will insure he reaches the Elysian Fields. Then in the morning, when I’ve recharged and had my coffee, I’ll go pound the shit out of some cops.

If I save the kid, Daddy does, what? five to fifteen best?, and gets out with plenty of time to kill Mommy and her new sweetie, and seriously screw up said kid’s life. I leave the kid to Athena’s tender mercies.

Saving the church will do nothing - tensers gonna tense; if I save the white church, everyone will ask why I couldn’t save the 173 churches of various congregations that have been burned already this year; others will doubt the police were going to bomb the church, except for a few CTers who believe in False Flags, and I don’t want them on my side.

So, I save the firemen.

They will save more people that I will over time; one of them is Black and will be a good media hero to offset the church burning; they are not a religious institution, so I don’t have to worry about assisting in undercutting the separation between church and state; and, being older, they are more likely to have pissed off Athena and be heading for Hades, unless they have some time to repent

But, I scoop up and teleport one fireman in with me so s/he can lead one out; a teleport one fireman out, go back in a get the third, teleport her back to the bridge so she can try to save the kid. (The woman is likely to be smaller - easier to transport - and have more fat - better insulation and buoyancy - and so more likely to be able to save the kid). I have just enough energy to hide under the bridge until I regain my strength to shift into my mild-mannered alter-ego.

Does that add up? Either way, I save the firemen.

If I get home safe, I shape-shift into the corrupt cops (one at a time, obviously) and commit heinous crimes under CCTV.

I avert tragedy number 1.

Awesome thread idea by the by.

Firemen. And I really don’t need a costume or anything - but if I could get a new pair of jeans, that’d be cool. And shoes and maybe s cute top - but only if they’re on sale. I don’t want to push my luck.

Fool of a Took!

The OP is explicit that the costume is just a Kevlar vest and similar protective gear. Because you’re not bulletproof. You need more fear in your heart.

Ok. Kevlar I can work with. I have a black scrunchy for my hair to make a ponytail so it’ll match. I’m good.

Don’t know what a fool of a took is so I’m good there, and I have fear in my heart, believe me! I just don’t know WHAT I’ll do if Chicago Fire’s new season doesn’t start soon - tv is sucking these days.

Ponytails are like capes. They’re only good for Kryptonian-level heroes. Why are you voluntarily giving people a handle to grab onto?

Never mind. I’ve made arrangements for you to take some classes at Avengers Academy. One of the doors in your house is now a portal to Marvel Earth. I’m sure nothing bad will happen to you there.

Thanks!!! WAY cool! I bet recess will be excellent there!!! :smiley: