Coffee, Tea and Thee

I went out with Nym last night and I’ve got a headache. So let’s get right to the point without a lot of rigamarole.

Why, when I’m sick and my throat is sore and raw, do I reach for tea to soothe it, bypassing the coffee that I drink every day of my life?

Black Tea and Coffee are both caffienated (in my house at least)

They’re both hot, drinkable liquids

They’re both just water filtered through some crushed up stuff to extract flavor and aroma

So why is tea the ‘soothing’ drink of choice?

jarbaby

I think it’s because coffee gives you a jolt of caffine while tea releases the caffine more slowly. It doesn’t give you the energy burst of coffee but does satisfy your craving and so is relaxing.
I have also heard (from a drunk in a pub so I don’t know) that tea actually has more caffine than coffee.

That’s news to me. Do you have a source for this information?

On average, a cup of tea has about half the caffiene as a cup of coffee. A very strong cup of tea and a very weak cup of coffee are about equal.

Tea also has two other chemicals that coffee does not. Theobromine and theophylline, which relax the smooth muscles.

You can try these sites that I just found though they both also say that generally coffee has more caffeine than tea. So never beleive a drunk!

http://www.culinary.net/columns/cybercupcafe/teaandcoffeetalk.html
http://www.java-n-jazz.com/tea.html

Eh, Beatle, my WAG would be that it’s “there’s more caffeine in coffee than tea”, not “it’s released at different rates”.

Which has more caffeine, tea of coffee, depends on what kind of tea or coffee it is, and how long they’re brewed. A cup of really strong tea can have more caffeine than a cup of instant coffee.

http://www.healthyeating.org/general/tea-coffee.htm

To address the OP, caffeine can give you an upset stomach. So if you’re already feeling unwell, slugging down a big dose of caffeine won’t help, and you instinctively opt for tea, and probably weak tea, at that.

http://www.cyberdiet.com/modules/gi/maintain/problems/caffeine.html

My mother’s sovereign remedy for illness, and especially upset tummies, was Canada Dry Ginger Ale.

Seems to me that in addition to being hot, tea has substances that are soothing which coffee lacks–and coffee seems to be more of an irritant to me. The oils in coffee and tea must be different, and have different effects.

If you want to talk herbal teas, too, then you’ve got your licorice root, your peppermint, your camomile, and so on–which definitely ease cold symptoms.

Plus, well, coffee tastes lousy with honey and lemon.

WHAT? But he said I was the most beautiful woman he’d ever seen! Ever!

:smiley:

Thanks for the info, all Duck, I guess I wasn’t so much speaking of upset tummies as sore throats…actors are notorious for wandering around with giant vats of tea to ‘soothe’ their voices and I always wondered why they didn’t just stick with the vats of hot coffee they usually carry around.

But I think we all know…

actors are silly.

jarbaby