Cooking with Gas: Your Humble Opinion...

This is an opinion poll of sorts which is why it is here.

For those dopers who have experience cooking on a natural gas range and on an electrical range, which do you prefer?

Mrs. Prefect and I are in the market for a new stove since our current 10 year-old range’s Ceran top shattered and will cost us %66 of a new stove to replace. I have been intrigued with natural gas ranges, but have no experience with them. I have heard they are the cat’s ass for cooking once you get the hang of it.

As a collorary, is there anything to look out for? Must have features, must not have features?

thanks.

Cat’s ass. Only way to go.

The only feature I can think of is that it should be self-lighting. You shouldn’t need a match.

Well, my experience with electric ranges is they’re much slower to adjust to the desired temperature than gas. Plus, there are a lot of fun things one can do with an open flame.

[QUOTE=tdn]
Cat’s ass. Only way to go.

The only feature I can think of is that it should be self-lighting. You shouldn’t need a match.
[/QUOTE]

Electric ignition seems to be standard for the models we are looking at.

Gas is way better IMO. Also, I’m not sure there is any such thing anymore as a gas stove you have to light yourself.

Gas is the best. Period. Only good thing with electric would be one of the sealed-glass surfaces, since that’s the easiest thing in the world to clean. But other than that ease of cleaning … gas.

Absolutely gas.

Every gas stove I’ve had we ended up lighting the burners with matches sooner or later - something always mucks the self-ignition. Unfortunately, we couldn’t find one with a pilot light for the oven - evidently they don’t make them anymore. They’re all electric ignition with cutouts to prevent gas from flowing if the power is off. :frowning:

Definitely look for a sealed top - makes cleanup much, MUCH easier. I also recommend the ones that have touching grates so that you can slide pans from one burner to another - very handy if you’re playing musical pots while you’re cooking.

While I love gas now, it was hard for me to learn it after spending my formative years growing up with electric. There WAS a learning curve for me. Now, though, I wouldn’t go back to electric burners, but I do prefer electric in the oven.

[QUOTE=toadspittle]
Gas is the best. Period. Only good thing with electric would be one of the sealed-glass surfaces, since that’s the easiest thing in the world to clean. But other than that ease of cleaning … gas.
[/QUOTE]

Even those sealed glass units have their cleaning issues. And that whole shattering business too :frowning:

Gas. I can’t tell what the hell I’m doing on an electric stove.

[QUOTE=redtail23]
Absolutely gas.

Every gas stove I’ve had we ended up lighting the burners with matches sooner or later - something always mucks the self-ignition. Unfortunately, we couldn’t find one with a pilot light for the oven - evidently they don’t make them anymore. They’re all electric ignition with cutouts to prevent gas from flowing if the power is off. :frowning:

Definitely look for a sealed top - makes cleanup much, MUCH easier. I also recommend the ones that have touching grates so that you can slide pans from one burner to another - very handy if you’re playing musical pots while you’re cooking.
[/QUOTE]

Really? My family had a gas stove for at least ten years, and it always performed beautifully. We never had to light it with a match or even get it repaired. Then we moved, and are now stuck with a crap-ass electric, which doesn’t work very well and is harder to clean.

Gas, absolutely. Much easier to clean, cheaper in use, responds much faster. I moved into an apartment with state of the art induction-cooking system. While I’m used to it now, I still miss my gas-stove.

Don’t go for a fancy stove. Oldfashioned is best, all modern extras are just gilding the lily.

A good gas stove is far superior to an electric range. My parents were actually prety good with letting me use our stove while I was growing up (one of my favorite things was boxed mac adn cheese, and they realized it was a lot easier to just teach me how to use the dam stove myself.) It was an electric, but then when I was about 12 or so we added an addition to our house, put the klitchen in there and got all new appliances, including a fancy gas stove. Good GOD was that so much better. You can actually go right from a boil to a simmer.

My current apartment has an electric range and I realzied after having been spoiled with gas for the last ten years how horrible they truly are.

Has anyone recommended gas yet?

Ok, then I will.

Gas.

With gas prices like they are now, don’t you “gas gas gas” people spend more money? Or does it not really matter?

Gas. And frankly, it’s not even close. I just moved into an apartment with electric for the first time and I pretty much hate it.

[QUOTE=Zsofia]
With gas prices like they are now, don’t you “gas gas gas” people spend more money? Or does it not really matter?
[/QUOTE]

It doesn’t matter. A gas stove doesn’t use THAT much gas. And its clear superiority makes it worth it.

So, gas it is then :slight_smile:

Let’s get specific then.

This is in our price range well, not really, but we gotta have a stove. We installed a dishwasher after Christmas which necessitated about $1200 in kitchen maintenance. Which means we can’t justify too much more than a grand, before installation. We can get this stove for $900.

Gas.

And, it’s not even close. I’d rather cook with crappy pans, crappy knives, and crappy utensils while wearing a hair-apron rather than cook on electric.

My mom likes electric better, because you can turn off power to the burner, and it will stay warm for a bit while you set the table.

I think this is a dubious advantage.

GAAAAAAASSS!!!