Could a Jew get elected POTUS?

To be fair, I think “Feingold” is a relatively normal-sounding name in America now. And that’s interesting.

Franklin Roosevelt got his name Germanized to “Rosenfeld” by enemies who thought making him sound Yiddish hurt him. But that sort of thing was a provincialism even then. Politicians got in trouble for assuming WASP majorities even 120 years ago. Much of the urban East Coast, & lot of Middle America, is not WASP. My hometown, for example, is heavily German & Scots-Irish, there are Irish Catholics almost everywhere, & there are all those Scandinavians in Minnesota.

“Feingold” cracks me up because I recognize it as an almost absurdly self-flattering ornamental name. Like “Goldberg” or something. It is stereotypically Jewish, & it’s part of a goofy legacy of over-the-top family names. But the funny thing is, in an America full of people whose ancestors spoke German &/or Yiddish, where guys with similarly Germanic names like Eddie Rickenbacker, Dwight Eisenhower, & Bruce Springsteen are great Americans, many people, like our friend Ludovic, won’t even think it sounds “ethnic” nor get that it’s Jewish.

As for anti-Semitism, I wonder how far that goes.

I confess that I worried about Lieberman becoming President after Gore were elected & assassinated (20-year curse, you know [& what’s up with that? Bush yet lives?])–for two reasons: One, I didn’t like Lieberman himself that much (Big Pharma ties, etc.) (I guess he was still better than Cheney, which is faint praise). Two, I thought a blatantly Jewish President might cause troubles for the US in countries with strong anti-Israel sentiment. In hindsight, I think a blatantly Jewish President might be just the person to draw a line between American interests & Israeli interests. And the serious Jew-haters will draw Stars of David on their caricatures of us anyway.

Because, in politics & pop culture, the USA is already pretty Jewish compared to other countries.

At least Fine-gold’s a Reform Jew. I found it hard to respect a guy who ropes his Gentile friends into flipping light switches for him on the Sabbath (yeah, like that’s less work).

Both of Wisconsin’s U.S. senators, Russ Feingold and Herb Kohl, are Jewish. The secret to getting elected in Wisconsin: German names! Governors Kohler, Schmedeman, Heil, Rennebohm, Schreiber, Dreyfus . . .

After Paul Wellstone’s death, Garrison Keillor did a piece on him: “The Norwegians voted for him because he wasn’t Swedish . . .”

foolsguinea:

That’s a misunderstanding of the “Sabbath Goy” concept. There are only specific circumstances under which an Orthodox Jew will ask a Gentile into doing something he or she is not allowed to do himself.

Wonder how a Jewish candidate would play with people like Jesse Jackson and Louis Farrakhan.

Regards,
Shodan

If the candidate were a Dem, I expect Jackson would bite his lip and work for the Jew’s campaign.

Farrakhan would just sulk.

Jessie Jackson supported the Gore-Lieberman ticket and who gives a shit what Farrakhan thinks? It’s not like he’s a political leader of any sort. Most of his views are ultra-conservative as far I can see (anti-abortion, anti-gay, pro-gun, anti-drug, anti tax, anti-welfare, racist) but I don’t think he’s aligned with the GOP or anything and they hate him anyway.

You’re describing about half of the electorate.

I think it could only happen if the Jew in question had a strong record, and was in the public eye before running for President. This wouldn’t have to be in politics, a career in the military leading to high rank, being the world’s greatest neurosurgeon, or a nice history of fighting his way onto the Fortune 500 would do.

President Franken! :slight_smile:

Franken D. Roosevelt?

Al Franken for President. I think I would vote no.

Jim

I just hope you get the chance!

Yeah. A far better choice would be James Caan. People would think they were electing an Italian Catholic. By the time they learned the truth, he’d already be sworn in.

Well, I would know.
Boy a NYC raised Hollywood actor that people think is Italian but is really Jewish and he used to hang out at the playboy Mansion. I might vote for him just for the shear absurdity of it all.

Jim

Yes, “Caan” is a well-known Italian surname.

But so many people think of him as Sonny Corleone, you know Caan is probably just his stage name. Helps him get parts with all those Jewish Directors like Coppola. :wink:

Jim {If he ever took a job from Shatner, would Bill Scream “CAA[SIZE=5]AAAAAAN!!!”[/SIZE]?}

No, that would be Ross Perot . . .

Hey, Shatner’s Jewish! Wouldn’t that be cool!

Damn. Forgot about the whole “Canadian” thing.

:eek: Star Trek is a Jewish plot!