Daddy, I want a dog for Christmas!

Now what do I do? I’m alergic to dogs and cats. My daughter wants a pet dog more than anything else in the world! She’s breaking my will. I have a big back yard (not fenced). I’m considering a small in house type dog. Maybe a poodle (without that Godforsaken fru fru cut!) I know there are some other no-shedding breeds out there. What are they? I would really like to get a dog from a pound or something like PetSmart where people adopt dogs their on Saturdays (I’m told).

My questions above are mostly rhetorical, I suppose. I just want other dog owners and lovers to chime in and give me the silent hello (You know, where you look at someone you recognize, and raise your chin up slightly as you make eye contact. Commonly done as you pass someone in a hall way) I’ll take advice too on what to expect on owning a dog (since I haven’t owned one in like 30 years).

woof woof
E3

Many humane societies will not process an adoption just before Christmas. There is an all-too-common scenario where a puppy is adopted and then the family looses interest, and the puppy finds itself either on the street or back at the humane society.

I am NOT saying this would happen in your family, just that you should be aware that you may encounter obstacles to adoption at this time of year.

How old is your daughter? To what extent does she understand the responsibilities of having an indoor dog? Do YOU want a dog? Are you prepared to care for the dog if she is temporarily unable to or for whatever reason looses interest?

I know that some people are allergic to hair, and others are allergic to dander (skin flakes). Do you know which you’re allergic to?

Good luck!

If you and your spouse do not want a dog, my advice is to NOT get one regardless of what your daughter wants. You’re making a committment to care for an animal for it’s natural life, which for small dogs could easily be 15 years. If your daughter is old enough to care for the dog (say 13 or 14) then you will be left with the dog when she moves out in a few years. If your daughter is too young to care for the dog, then YOU will end up having to do it. And remember that “care for” doesn’t just mean feed and walk, it means train and pay adequate attention to.

I always wanted a dog as a kid. I didn’t get one til I moved out on my own and circumstances allowed me to do it.

Once allergic, always allergic. And getting a dog, a pack animal, to let it live in the yard, is not an okay thing in my book.

And I don’t know how bad your allergies are, but it is very common for allergies to grow more severe if the sufferer is exposed to the allergens on a daily basis. If you plan on getting a dog, and yet plan to not be exposed to it, don’t get a dog.

I’m sorry, I misread this:

I thought you were saying you’d get a dog house for the yard. My mistake.

OTOH, it doesn’t really change your allergic problems, does it…

Please, please, please do not get a dog unless you are really enthusiastic about it, and have given it a LOT of thinking over. Like several months worth. Make sure you research different breeds, and seriously consider how much money and time and energy owning a dog takes.

If you think it would be selfish to deny your daughter a dog, you’re wrong. It would be selfish to adopt a dog and then only give it half-hearted love and care. Your daughter may be disappointed, but she WILL get over it. The dog cannot “get over” being neglected.

I’m sorry if this post has come across as harsh. I realize I don’t really know your situation at all, Enright, and this post wasn’t meant as a jump down your throat. I’ve just had some recent experience with this and I’m on edge about it. (My roommate thought it would be fun to own a dog. So she went out and got two Great Dane puppies. Two. After thinking about it for about 24 hours.)

I just want to say that if you want a dog you sould get one. Because of your allergies I recommend that you talk to you doctor about allergy pills of some kind. I have a friend who is allergic to dogs and cats, and she has 2 St. Bernards, a Hemilayan cat and a Siamese cat. She does all right. Most small dogs don’t shed a lot, and are fun and cute to boot. But absolutely don’t get a dog if you are going to have to stay away from it. That’s not fair to the dog or you. Maybe you could consider getting her a different kind of pet. to start out with. Perhaps something that doesn’t need as much attention. Maybe a bunny or something. She would probably love it just as much. You could tell her that if she takes good care of the bunny,you will consider a dog.

Poodles are really attractive dogs without the stupid haircuts, and they come in a range of sizes. A poodle would be a good dog.

I’m not sure how you would go with a silky terrier, but I seem to recall hearing some people found them less of a problem allergy-wise than most dogs - their coat is more like hair than like fur. If you can spend some time around a silky, you might find it’s a good breed to consider. They’re small and intelligent.

I’m going to do a “me too” on the don’t get a dog side. A dog is a committment for 8-14 years. It’s going to have to go outside the house sometime. You didn’t say how old your daughter is, but can SHE take care of it? Will she?

Maybe you could try having her volunteer some time at a kennel (or accompany you) as a walker or to play with the dogs. See if she is willing to do it for 8 weeks in a row. Maybe start with a hamster or something and work up to a dog. Of just get a cat.

As a cat owner, I’d like to say that not all cats are less demanding than dogs. True, they don’t need to be walked, can be left along during the day and sometimes for a weekend, and training is much less of an issue in general. However, some cats can be incredibally demanding of your time and attention. Truthfully, when one of my cats wants attention, they want it then and there and are pretty annoying if they don’t get it. Much more annoying than the dog, frankly.

So “get a cat if you don’t have time for a dog” is not necesarily good advice. Get a cat because it’s suited to your lifestyle and personality, not because a dog isn’t.

As a general thing, I’m with the “don’t do it” crowd.

However…

How old is your daughter? If she is less than 8 or so, a dog small enough to meet your needs is too small to be trusted with a little child. You don’t want to put the dog in line to get mauled by a child who is too young to put the dog’s safety before her impulses.

Think “dog” – not puppy.

In terms of allergies: my friend had five cats, a very good allergist and a spotless home which she cleaned constantly to reduce hair and dander. This year, she had to get rid of all of her cats because her immune system just couldn’t take it any more in spite of all available medical interventions, and she was in serious danger of dying from her allergies. She managed to find homes for them all, but she has an extraordinarily large group of friends who love cats, most of her cats were purebreds and she still had to let one go to a stranger – albeit a stranger who she met through a vet, thank god. Don’t get the dog unless you are prepared for the fact that you might have to take it away from your daughter again if your allergies get too bad. It is a real possibility. If you can’t say no to your daughter now, imagine how goodthat’s going to feel. And don’t get it unless you KNOW someone will take it off your hands and give it a good home if it comes to that. The older the dog gets, the harder it will be to find someone to adopt it. If you would even consider taking it to the pound in case of emergency – for God’s sake do not get a dog. You may not be the kind of person who would ordinarily do such a thing, but what if your daughter turns out to be allergic too, and it comes down to getting rid of the dog fast or endangering your child? Think and think again.

Ask a vet to recommend a shampoo which will do the least amount of harm to a dog which has to be shampooed more often than is normally recommended.

In terms of breeds – why not ask your allergist? I understand Bijons (they look sort of like little poodles) are fairly hypoallergenic.

In terms of breeds – once you find out which breeds are least allergenic, resesarch their health and temperament on the internet or, again, ask a vet. I suggest the latter. Some dogs just do not like children at all.

In terms of adoption: look into breed rescues. These are groups which specialize in rescuing and adopting out dogs belonging to specific breeds. You can ask your pound if they know of any poodle or bijon (or whatever) rescue groups in your area, or you can look on the internet. Please do not buy a puppy mill dog from a pet store, no matter what the temptation or the provocation. My guess is that you will be most likely to hit pay dirt a few months after Christmas, when the people who bought dogs without knowing what they were getting into get fed up. Of course, you will have to be prepared to patiently work with the dog to remedy whatever bad habits such ignorance and neglect have caused in the dog. Don’t write off the local “kill shelter” as a resource. You can call them and ask if they have any of the breed you are looking for before visiting. If they are willing to help, it will mimize your “pound wandering time” and your exposure to allergens. Do not take your daughter with you to the pound no matter what. Begging and tears will ensue.

Be prepared to be infinitely patient. Adopting a “used” dog is absolutely the way to go, and the plusses usually vastly outweigh the minuses, but there are occasional minuses. God help you if you end up with a former pet shop dog who spent too many months in a cage at the store – they are very difficult to housebreak once they lose the aversion for going to the bathroom in their own den. Dogs five and up usually make excellent pets – as long as they are not so old that your child will have pet loss heartbreak too soon.

Good luck and don’t rush into anything.

First of all my daughter is 11. I also have a 15 year old daughter who wants a dog, and my 37 year old wife who wants a dog or a cat. The reason I’m deliberating on this is because I don’t make rash decisions, and I don’t take this decision lightly. The fact that it’s near Christmas is actually a coincidence. I wouldn’t wait until Christmas. I appreciate the animal lovers out there who don’t want me to take a pet that would end up neglected. Let me assure you all, there’s no way that would happen. My wife was a dog owner all her life before we were married. I had a dog until I was about 16, (he got hit by a car :() I’ve never heard that allergies get worse if you own a dog… Uh… allergy shots work on the premise of desensitization. I’m a living testament to that. My wife and I lived with a Golden Retriever when we were first married (Cinnammon Toast V), and I was horribly allergic to her. After a while it hardly bothered me unless I played with her a lot or brushed her coat.

Thanks for the advice, everyone. I promise I won’t let you down.

E3