Dancing with the Stars (DWTS), Fall 2009

Yeah. Whoa Nelly, he and Chelsea steamed it up pretty good tonight.

My other faves for this round were Mya/Dmitry (on what planet was that a 7?), Natalie/Alec and Kelly/Louie. All of whom I’d be more than happy to see reach the semis.

Something about Aaron bugs the hell out of me. Too much like Eddie Haskell or something, I don’t know.

At the moment, Chuck, Michael and Debi all look pretty much hopeless. The rest seemed…undistinguished.

I thought DeLay was out of his freakin’ mind to be going ahead, if the “stress fractures in both feet” thing was on the level. It’s just a tacky dance competition, fer cryin’ out loud. I suspect there may be a ‘surprise’ ending on the results show tomorrow night.

Tonight’s show was overflowing with “WTF?” moments, from Chuck’s poofy sleeves to Paula Abdul being, well, Paula Abdul, but perhaps the standouts were Bruno’s classy :eek: remark to Mya (“No price is too high for you!”) and, of course, Donnie and Bruno’s little make-out session on the judge’s stand. I was thoroughly entertained.

Did Debi and Maks make eye contact even once? Chelsie and the hobbit, on the other hand, have great chemistry.

I’m not at “rip my eyes out” but yes, he does. He needs to go home, but that was non-offensive…and better than Chuck or Michael. Who shouldn’t be there long.

Natalie borrowed Edyta’s husband and her wardrobe. I still didn’t buy the chemistry. I did for the hobbit, though I don’t think he danced so much as Chelsea danced around him while he was there. I liked that Donny tried the solo.

Aaron looked like he was doing karate up there - it was anti-romantic. The chairman & Lacey were without chemistry (though they had a bad song). And on my non-HDTV, it looked like Melissa Joan Hart kept frowning. It wasn’t a fun samba it was an angry one.

Len loved the leggy model, probably because she doesn’t move unless she absolutely has to. I thought Sabrina’s dance was waaaay better. Aaron looked like he was doing some sort of interpretive dance and I found him annoying as all heck.

Kelly, the swimmer and Irvin improved from last week. However, saying Irvin improved isn’t saying much since he sucked so bad last week (and the week before). He’s gone from sucking so bad to just plain sucking. Chuck was chuck. I give him extra points for putting on those ridiculous sleeves.

I thinking Len must be grading Mya as hard as he grades professional dancers. It’s the only explanation for his continued low scores.

I missed Iron Chef. I was in the bathroom and came down stairs 3 minutes after 8-- just in time to see him breathing hard in front of the judges. Poo.

Dancing on two broken feet takes the same amount of chutzpah that it takes to grin like an idiot for a mug shot, so I was not surprised by Delay at all.

Oh, I almost forgot: Didn’t I sound like an old lady when I saw the Hobbit’s slick backed hair and said, “So much better! Now we can see your handsome face.”

Unlike Debi who needs to cover that face. It looks like she had some plastic surgery done and by ‘plastic surgery’ I mean ‘encased her face in Lucite’.

I don’t like Debi at all. I can’t even watch her dance. Mark, OTOH, I find very appealing, even when his dancing can be improved. I thought the 5 Len gave him was terribly unfair. They’re judging him on a different standard than some of the others. (That’s what they seem to do - if the judges feel you have extra talant and should be better, they give you the same scores for a mediocre dance as the poor dancers get for a bad dance) I missed Chuck’s dance, maybe deliberately. Was he any good? As everyone else has said, Aaron just wasn’t right tonight. Maybe he has a hard time acting sexy with a woman, or maybe it’s just his youth. The Hobbit, OTOH, really was fun and got into the dance. Tom DeLay did okay, surprisingly. I didn’t think he’d be able to do latin dances. He’s not sexy, but he’s watchable. Kelly seemed to have redeemed herself a bit. I wonder why her mom wasn’t there to watch her?

StG

I gave all my votes to the Hobbit – should’ve kept half of them for Kelly.

And Tom DeLay should not be allowed to compete. Seriously, he can be all macho asshole that he wants to – the producers should step in and tell him he’s being benched.

My bet is that Debi will go home tonight. And much as I dislike Tom Delay, I can live with that. But the one who really ought to go home (not counting Tom’s injuries) is Chuck; I’m not seeing the so-called entertainment value at all. He just looks like godzilla stomping around the dance floor.

The judges have always applied double standards, grading good dancers much harder than bad dancers. But they seem exceptionally erratic this season, Len in particular.

YES!!!
(Tom Delay withdraws)

I’m sure he can use the time preparing for his upcoming trial.

Good.

Did they do an elimination in addition? (Wasn’t home, didn’t record.)

Yes.

It was Debi.

I think there were supposed to be two more double elimination rounds later in the season; I guess now they’ll cut that back to one.

Not too surprising – the person sent home wasn’t necessarily the worst dancer still in it, but also didn’t have the same kind of fan base as most of the rest of the really bad dancers. (Yanno, maybe circumlocutions aren’t actually any easier than using a spoiler box … :wink: )

OK, I finally figured it out. Aaron looks like a muppet, and not in a good way. He looks like one of the muppets that was always scared - was it Beaker or the Swedish Chef’s assistant? There is also an Eddie Haskell thing going on, as El Kabong noted. Hard to imagine the number of hot girls he has apparently dated (according to Wiki), as he comes across as unpleasant, sulky, arrogant, and effeminate. And a muppet, but not a cute one. (Which is why his quick-step, set to the Muppet Show intro music, worked so well)

He could probably gain about a hundred percent with me if he just smoothed his hair down a bit, instead of wearing it sticking straight up.

That would make him Beaker. And, yeah, I can see him as a Muppet.

Unfortunately, we’re stuck with him for the foreseeable future – though he performs, rather than dances, as someone observed upthread, his performances are still better than some other dross we need to get rid of first. 'Twill be interesting to see how he fares when we’re down to a half dozen or so.

Actually, this is a pretty good season. If we get rid of Chuck, Michael, and Melissa, we’ll be down to people who actually are reasonably competent. That seems sooner than usual. Maybe it’s just that there were more contestants this season, and we’ve had two weeks of double losses.

This looks like it’s going to be a good season. There isn’t any runaway favorite, a number of appealing dark horses, and no one who’s going to hang around 5 weeks too long. I might actually have to start watching this. (Recorded, of course.)

Called Tom Delay right…woo hoo!..but I have to admit it’s one of the weirdest exits I’ve ever seen. He overtrains, gets injured, aggravates it, guts it out nonetheless, and manages to avoid looking completely horrible. He avoids last place but has to drop out anyway because he’s too badly hurt to even practice. The lesson everyone should learn, of course, is to never get behind the frail geezer. It’s always a lost cause. (Yes, I know about Cloris Leachman. She was an anomaly. It’s not happening again.)

As for Len Goodman, I know he’s going to get absolutely roasted pretty much everywhere. I agree completely that he’s been giving bum scores and idiotic justifications for them. And I completely support what he’s doing. Yes, of course I’ll explain.

First off, he done this last-man-standing nonsense long enough to know that first place and rock bottom plus one (man, it’s been too long! :slight_smile: ) are worth exactly the same, absolutely nothing carries over, and things like consistency and taking risks are worth about as much as a Penn Jilette highlight video. Therefore, the worst, worst, worst thing he could possibly do to Mya is to give her high scores and lavish praise every week. Why? Because she still needs votes. The viewers see her monopolizing the top of the leaderboard, either they assume she doesn’t need the help or don’t want to vote for her anymore, and she makes an inglorious exit in the middle rounds. Hey, nobody roots for Goliath. The moment she comes across as a high-heeled juggernaut nobody else is within a football field of, she’s TOAST.

Now, all three judges can’t be in on the sandbag, otherwise it’ll look suspicious. But one loose cannon isn’t likely to raise hackles, and Len has that grumpy-old-man vibe down pat. He reminds everyone that nobody’s immune from lowball scores, and nobody can get by without votes. Thus ensuring…hopefully!..that Mya goes as far as she can.

And make no mistake, anyone with any stake in this show wants her to go far. She’s the ringer. She was brought on to provide a quality performance every week, set the bar, and prevent some lousy goldbricking Jerry Rice type from stealing the trophy. That’s her purpose. Getting bounced early would be disastrous, not only crippling ratings immediately but severely damaging prospects for getting future ringers on board.

Or…maybe Len’s just having a little fun. Lord knows you have to take what you can get on this show. And given Simon Cowell’s (inexplicably, bizarrely, insanely) amazing popularity, can you really blame him for playing the ignorant jerk? I mean, why does pretty much every reality program have at least one? If this were a normal dancing contest, where everyone who starts finishes and early scores damn well do influence the final tally, then he’d be a lot more serious, put more thought into his scores, and make sure his critiques were justifiable. Here, if No-hope Schlub #3 finishes 3rd to last instead of 5th to last, who gives a crap? Let the joker be; at least we now have something to talk about other than “Man, is Chuck Liddell stiff or what?” and “What country is she queen of again?”

Oy! - Okay, here’s what you do.

Vote for the one you want to get through the most.

Yes, that’s it; yes, I’m dead serious.

Don’t try to figure out which Y’s and Z’s you have to back to get X out. It’s a huge waste of energy, and it never works anyway. (Ever hear of Scott Savol?) Even if you could find out exactly where everyone placed this week, this has no bearing on what’s going to happen the next. Ask any skilled gambler what a fool’s game using the past to predict the future is.

Pick your horse and stick with it. That’s the best you can do. That’s all you can do.

Great analysis, DKW – thanks! And it really does make a whole lot of sense – Len is too knowledgeable to spout some of the crap he spouts … unless … hm. Yup, I think you’re right.

Are you kidding? I’ve been having far more fun this season trying to get the ones I hate canned than I ever did this early in the season before! Of course, now that Satan and Former Super Model from Hell are gone, I have no personal animus, but I can still enjoy strategizing. My mission now is to see Chuck go, not because I dislike him, but because he’s bad on the dance floor. It’s much more fun to watch with a mission.

Oh not Chuck! Irvin first, then Chuck. Then Leggy Model. I think Sabrina’s last dance was far better than Leggy Model’s. But Len loves her, probably because she moves as little as she possibly can while still be considered dancing. Len likes that, it seems.