I wanted to love you, “Moulin Rouge.” I really did. I saw the commercials, which made you look like a stunning visual masterpiece. I heard the buzz surrounding your arrival, which got me pumped about seeing you. I saw that you had Nicole Kidman, whom I love, as one of your stars, so I decided that I would go to see you.
To tell you the truth, “Moulin Rouge,” I DID like you. A whole lot. I thought that your story, while not the most creative in the world, had enough twists on the old formula to keep you interesting. Your farcical use of modern songs (especially “Like a Virgin” and “Heroes”) had me laughing heartily, and your use of “Roxanne” actually succeeded in making Sting sound dark and foreboding. Kidman did a wonderful job, as did, and I’ll admit this even though my SO is currently infatuated with him, Ewan McGregor. Hell, you even had John Leguizamo playing a midget with a lisp! (This being, of course, the only part that John Leguizamo is fit to play).
But alas, Rougey, I did not love you. There was something there, something that got in the way of my ever being able to say that you were a “wonderful” movie.
This dark cloud over your silver quality, this urine in your breakfast cereal, was, I hate to say it, the entire first half an hour of you.
While watching you during these opening scenes, it became apparent that your director, Baz Luhrmann, attempted to edit your introductory sequences and nightclub dance scenes while under the influence of speed. What resulted was a nauseating churn of tantric camera angles, none of which lasted for more than 2 seconds. The entire first night club scene was reduced to nothing more than fleeting glimpses of colorful hoop skirts and scary ladies with too much make-up on.
Baz, I know that you were just trying to show the confusion of a place like your Moulin Rouge. The only problem is that the entire scene looked more like an acid flashback than a nightclub. Instead of forcing your actors to pose for quick millisecond shots, you could have expanded the scenes just a BIT, and let them actually, get this, act. Once you slowed things the Hell down, your movie got to be very good. But, alas, the memory of that first half hour lingered, and put a damper on any emotional flame you were trying to light.
So, I’m sorry, “Moulin Rouge,” but your story of a play about a poor Indian minstrel was good, but not great.
You made me like you, but not love you.
In other words, you were close, but no sitar.