Jose Antonio Ferrer Benimeli’s “The Judeo-Masonic conspiracy-communist” seems to debunk the Protocols in of themselves by doing a paragraph by paragraph comparison. Does any body have it?
Oh, good lord. You’re not fooling anyone, you know.
What are the paragraphs being compared to, I ask out of curiosity.
The linked article compares passages from The Dialogue In Hell Between Machiavelli and Montesquieu and The Protocols of the Elders of Zion, so as to demonstrate that portions of the latter were plagiarized from the former.
What human action said. Sorry, I have a bad habit of not explaining enough.
I brought up this subject because there really isn’t a full list online comparing the two works. Sure you find several paragraphs but not the whole thing.
Is there a debate, here? It is nice to have a serious and nearly scholarly debunking of the Protocols, but you are unlikely to find anyone on this site claiming that they were real.
I suspect that this will do better in IMHO.
[ /Moderating ]
You might want to have someone look at that knee. It seems to be jerking rather violently.
The posted links are a pretty thorough debunking of the Protocols, not an invitation to promote them.
Outrageous! Anti-semitism is bad enough, but unoriginality?! Harrumph, I say, harrumph!
Here’s Dialogue In Hell in English.
Here’s The Protocols in English.
I was all set to jump in on this, but now I realize we aren’t talking about HTTP protocols.
IS there something that makes you think they need debunking on this message board, or that those that are rabid enough to believe in them would listen to anything you have to say?
I feel happy…
…I was hoping somebody could find the comparison not do it myself. I am lazy dammit.
Well, at least you’re honest about it.
Serious question: Has anyone here ever actually seen the Protocols?
I’ve HEARD about them for decades, but I’ve never met anyone who ever tried to show them to me, or to tell me, “You’ve gotta read this!”
Are the links, above, valid? I mean, do they point to the “real” Protocols and Dialogue, in a fairly accurate English translation? Or are they hoaxes of some sort?
How can we know?
(Also, I rely heavily on my right not to inspect ugly stuff. I’ve never watched the Zapruder film of JFK’s assassination, because I know it’s icky.)