I was watching Dennis Miller on Bill O’Reilly at the gym last night and remembering how I used to laugh at his material but now it’s sad. It’s not that he’s an outspoken conservative, it’s the fact that he’s just another bitter old fart and he spews out a bunch of sound-byte pregnant partisan douchebaggery that sounds so completely non-spontaneous and over-rehearsed it’s hard to believe the man has done live performances for decades. But I swear that I used to laugh at his material- a lot, especially his rants- and it’s not just the political switch that made him not funny any more.
Was he ever funny to begin with? Or was it just a “you had to be there” thing? If he was funny, what was the big change? He was always libertarian with a conservative tilt in his politics after all.
I mentioned recently in a thread about Matthew Perry that smartassery doesn’t age well, and I think that’s a major part of his problem. You can be young and cute and a cynical smartass, but when you turn middle aged and you’re not cute anymore then you need to have something else- some serious wit and bite behind your comedy, because smartassing (as a verb) in and of itself isn’t funny.
I think another problem that I had with Dennis Miller even before his comedy became partisan was his South-bashing: he couldn’t pass up a chance to make some kind of joke about all Southerners being sister-fooking hicks. One time it bit him in the ass was on a talk show when a man with a southern accent from Huntsville, AL called in to speak to guest Tom Hanks about NASA. Hanks mentioned for the audience benefit that Huntsville is a key research and testing center for NASA and Miller of course makes some kind of “that’s reassuring- Alabama rocket scientists” joke, and then Hanks and the southern guy got into a surprisingly esoteric discussion of rocketry and funding that left Miller in the dust.
Which reminds me of another thing: for somebody who made his bones on esoteric and-or obscure references, it became clear watching him on talk shows that he isn’t particularly well read or well informed. Somehow diminishes from the rants, if only to me.
And trivial but I’ll mention it anyway: he named his kids Holden and Marlon after Caulfield and Brando respectively. I would be hard pressed to name two more “greatest generation” era self absorbed assholes than the fictional Holden and Marlon. But, his kids, his rules.
So in your opinion: Was Miller once funny and now isn’t? Was he never funny? Do you think he’s still funny? And what’s your favorite flavor of Tang?