Disney Animated Movie Madness

[Oredigger77]

1. Cinderella (First Round Bye)

2. The Sword in the Stone

3. The Emperor’s New Groove

4. Bambi (First round Bye)

5. 101 Dalmations

6. Lilo and Stitch (First round bye)

7. The Rescuers

8. Sleeping Beauty (First round bye)

9. The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh

10. Lady and the Tramp

11. The Little Mermaid (First round bye)

12. The Great Mouse Detective

13. Hercules (First round bye)

14. The Jungle Book

15. Beauty and the Beast (First round bye)

16. The Aristocats

17. Robin Hood

18. Mulan (First round bye)

19. The Three Caballeros

20. Pinocchio (First round bye)

21. Brother Bear

22. Aladdin (First round bye)

23. Oliver and Company

24. Peter Pan

25. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs (First round bye)

26. The Fox and the Hound

27. The Lion King (First round bye)

28. Home on the Range
    Wow all my favorites are ranked horribly (except for Aladdin). The only way that the Sword and the Stone could be ranked so low is for princess movie fanatics to do the selecting.

[as_u_wish]

1. Cinderella (First Round Bye)

2. Chicken Little

3. The Emperor’s New Groove

4. Bambi (First round Bye)

5. 101 Dalmations

6. Lilo and Stitch (First round bye)

7. The Rescuers

8. Sleeping Beauty (First round bye)

9. The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh

10. Dumbo

11. The Little Mermaid (First round bye)

12. The Rescuers Down Under

13. Hercules (First round bye)

14. The Jungle Book

15. Beauty and the Beast (First round bye)

16. The Aristocats

17. Robin Hood

18. Mulan (First round bye)

19. Fantasia

20. Pinocchio (First round bye)

21. Brother Bear

22. Aladdin (First round bye)

23. Meet the Robinsons

24. Peter Pan

25. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs (First round bye)

26. The Fox and the Hound

27. The Lion King (First round bye)

28. Home on the Range
    The only really hard one was Dumbo vs. Lady & the Tramp. I picked Dumbo but would rank Lady & the Tramp as one of my three or four top animated movies. Alas. Well, there was a little twinge when I passed over Alice in Wonderland for the Emperor’s New Groove. But only a little.

[Yllaria]

1. Cinderella (First Round Bye)

2. The Sword in the Stone

3. The Emperor’s New Groove

4. Bambi (First round Bye)

5. Treasure Planet

6. Lilo and Stitch (First round bye)

7. The Rescuers

8. Sleeping Beauty (First round bye)

9. Fantasia/2000

10. Lady and the Tramp

11. The Little Mermaid (First round bye)

12. The Rescuers Down Under

13. Hercules (First round bye)

14. The Jungle Book

15. Beauty and the Beast (First round bye)

16. The Black Cauldron

17. Robin Hood

18. Mulan (First round bye)

19. Fantasia

20. Pinocchio (First round bye)

21. Brother Bear

22. Aladdin (First round bye)

23. Meet the Robinsons

24. Peter Pan

25. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs (First round bye)

26. The Fox and the Hound

27. The Lion King (First round bye)

28. Home on the Range

[MovieMogul]

33. The Sword in the Stone

34. Alice in Wonderland

35. 101 Dalmations

36. The Rescuers

37. The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh

38. Dumbo

39. The Rescuers Down Under

40. The Jungle Book

41. The Aristocats

42. Robin Hood

43. Fantasia

44. Fun and Fancy Free

45. Oliver and Company

46. Peter Pan

47. The Fox and the Hound

48. Saludos Amigos

Plus–you (or “they”) gave a first round bye to Hercules but pitted Dumbo against Lady and the Tramp?!?!? :eek: :dubious:

[ArrMatey]

1. Cinderella (First Round Bye)

2. The Sword in the Stone

3. Alice in Wonderland

4. Bambi (First round Bye)

5. Treasure Planet

6. Lilo and Stitch (First round bye)

7. The Rescuers

8. Sleeping Beauty (First round bye)

9. The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh

10. Dumbo

11. The Little Mermaid (First round bye)

12. The Rescuers Down Under

13. Hercules (First round bye)

14. The Jungle Book

15. Beauty and the Beast (First round bye)

16. The Aristocats

17. Tarzan (tough call on this one.)

18. Mulan (First round bye)

19. Fantasia

20. Pinocchio (First round bye)

21. Brother Bear

22. Fun and Fancy Free (had to skip this bracket- I’ve seen neither film)

23. Aladdin (First round bye)

24. Oliver and Company (It ain’t gonna win, but I have a personal stake.)

25. Peter Pan

26. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs (First round bye)

27. The Fox and the Hound (didn’t like this one so much, but hated Hunchback)

28. The Lion King (First round bye)

29. Home on the Range

30. Saludos Amigos (See the Brother Bear bracket, above)

[The_Hamster_King]

33. The Sword in the Stone

34. The Emperor’s New Groove

35. 101 Dalmations

36. The Rescuers

37. The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh

38. Dumbo

39. The Great Mouse Detective

40. The Jungle Book

41. The Aristocats

42. Robin Hood

43. The Three Caballeros

44. Fun and Fancy Free

45. Oliver and Company

46. Peter Pan

47. The Fox and the Hound

48. Saludos Amigos

What, no Melody Time?! No Ichabod and Mr. Toad?! Both those classics blow stinkers like *Brother Bear * and *Home on the Range * out of the water. Mr. Toad even has a ride at Disneyland – something that can’t be said for most movies on the list.

[NAF1138]

And away we go…

1. Cinderella (First Round Bye)

2. The Sword in the Stone

3. The Emperor’s New Groove

4. Bambi (First round Bye)

5. 101 Dalmations

6. Lilo and Stitch (First round bye)

7. The Rescuers

8. Sleeping Beauty (First round bye)

9. The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh

10. Dumbo

11. The Little Mermaid (First round bye)

12. The Great Mouse Detective

13. Hercules (First round bye)

14. The Jungle Book

15. Beauty and the Beast (First round bye)

16. The Aristocats

17. Robin Hood

18. Mulan (First round bye)

19. Fantasia

20. Pinocchio (First round bye)

21. Fun and Fancy Free

22. Aladdin (First round bye)

23. Oliver and Company

24. Peter Pan

25. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs (First round bye)

26. The Fox and the Hound

27. The Lion King (First round bye)

28. Saludos Amigos
    Interesting game. I used to work for an animation gallery, so I have seen all of these movies…50 times each, some many many more times. I pick Pinocchio as the best movie not to make it to the final 4 (should be the winner IMO, but I don’t think enough people really remember it) and Snow White as the overall winner.

[storyteller0910]

I know more of these by heart than I’m comfortable admitting.

1. Cinderella (First Round Bye)

2. The Sword in the Stone

3. Alice in Wonderland

4. Bambi (First round Bye)

5. 101 Dalmations

6. Lilo and Stitch (First round bye)

7. The Rescuers

8. Sleeping Beauty (First round bye)

9. Fantasia/2000

10. Dumbo

11. The Little Mermaid (First round bye)

12. The Great Mouse Detective

13. Hercules (First round bye)

14. The Jungle Book

15. Beauty and the Beast (First round bye)

16. The Aristocats

17. Tarzan

18. Mulan (First round bye)

19. Fantasia

20. Pinocchio (First round bye)

21. Brother Bear

22. Aladdin (First round bye)

23. Meet the Robinsons

24. Peter Pan

25. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs (First round bye)

26. The Fox and the Hound

27. The Lion King (First round bye)

28. Home on the Range

[garygnu]

1. Cinderella (First Round Bye)

32. Chicken Little
    33. The Sword in the Stone
    I liked Chicken Little, but Wart as a squirrel wins.

33. Alice in Wonderland
    17. The Emperor’s New Groove
    New Groove should be a higher seed.

8. Bambi (First round Bye)

25. 101 Dalmations
40. Treasure Planet
No contest.

9. Lilo and Stitch (First round bye)

24. The Rescuers
41. Atlantis: The Lost Empire
Again, I liked Atlantis, but the classic wins.

4. Sleeping Beauty (First round bye)

29. The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh
36. Fantasia/2000

13. Dumbo
    20. Lady and the Tramp
    Very bad first round pair.

5. The Little Mermaid (First round bye)

28. The Rescuers Down Under
    37. The Great Mouse Detective
    First ever inclusion of computer animation in a Disney feature.

12. Hercules (First round bye)
Seriously? This wouldn’t even get out of the first round.

21. The Jungle Book
44. Make Mine Music

2. Beauty and the Beast (First round bye)

31. The Aristocats
    34. The Black Cauldron
    The Aristocats ranks among the biggest wastes of my time, ever.

32. Tarzan
    18. Robin Hood
    Another tough matchup. Robin Hood is beloved by me, which beats out the spectacular animation in Tarzan.

7. Mulan (First round bye)
Does not deserve.

26. Fantasia
39. The Three Caballeros
Booo. I don’t want to pick.

10. Pinocchio (First round bye)

23. Brother Bear
    42. Fun and Fancy Free
    Are these seed numbers accidentally switched?

3. Aladdin (First round bye)

30. Meet the Robinsons
35. Oliver and Company
I just don’t like Oliver.

14. Pocahontas
    19. Peter Pan
    Are these seed numbers accidentally switched?

6. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs (First round bye)

27. The Hunchback of Notre Dame
38. The Fox and the Hound
If there’s one Disney feature worse than Aristocats, it’s Fox and the Hound, but that’s a tough decision.

11. The Lion King (First round bye)

22. Home on the Range
    43. Saludos Amigos
    And now, singing: :o :o :o "Saludos Amigos! A fond greeting to you. A warm handshake or twooooooooo. Good friends always doooooooo. Saludos! Amigos! … "

[What_Exit]

1. Cinderella (First Round Bye)

2. The Sword in the Stone

3. Alice in Wonderland

4. Bambi (First round Bye)

5. 101 Dalmations

6. Lilo and Stitch (First round bye)

7. The Rescuers

8. Sleeping Beauty (First round bye)

9. Fantasia/2000

10. Lady and the Tramp

11. The Little Mermaid (First round bye)

12. The Rescuers Down Under

13. Hercules (First round bye)

14. The Jungle Book

15. Beauty and the Beast (First round bye)

16. The Aristocats

17. Tarzan

18. Mulan (First round bye)

19. Fantasia

20. Pinocchio (First round bye)

21. Brother Bear

22. Aladdin (First round bye)

23. Meet the Robinsons

24. Peter Pan

25. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs (First round bye)

26. The Fox and the Hound

27. The Lion King (First round bye)

28. Saludos Amigos

[Zebra]

1. Cinderella (First Round Bye)

2. The Sword in the Stone

3. Alice in Wonderland

4. Bambi (First round Bye)

5. 101 Dalmations

6. Lilo and Stitch (First round bye)

7. Atlantis: The Lost Empire

8. Sleeping Beauty (First round bye)

9. Fantasia/2000

10. Dumbo

11. The Little Mermaid (First round bye)

12. The Great Mouse Detective

13. Hercules (First round bye)

14. The Jungle Book

15. Beauty and the Beast (First round bye)

16. The Aristocats

17. Tarzan

18. Mulan (First round bye)

19. Fantasia

20. Pinocchio (First round bye)

21. Fun and Fancy Free

22. Aladdin (First round bye)

23. Oliver and Company

24. Peter Pan

25. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs (First round bye)

26. The Hunchback of Notre Dame

27. The Lion King (First round bye)

28. Saludos Amigos

If I had only seen one of the movies, I voted for that one.

[UncleRojelio]

1. Cinderella (First Round Bye)

2. The Sword in the Stone

3. The Emperor’s New Groove

4. Bambi (First round Bye)

5. 101 Dalmations

6. Lilo and Stitch (First round bye)

7. The Rescuers

8. Sleeping Beauty (First round bye)

9. Fantasia/2000

10. Lady and the Tramp

11. The Little Mermaid (First round bye)

12. The Rescuers Down Under

13. Hercules (First round bye)

14. The Jungle Book

15. Beauty and the Beast (First round bye)

16. The Aristocats

17. Robin Hood

18. Mulan (First round bye)

19. Fantasia

20. Pinocchio (First round bye)

21. Brother Bear

22. Aladdin (First round bye)

23. Meet the Robinsons

24. Pocahontas

25. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs (First round bye)

26. The Fox and the Hound

27. The Lion King (First round bye)

28. Home on the Range

[Illuminatiprimus]

This sounds like fun… could someone explain what the hell is going on so I can play too?

[Jonathan_Chance]

It’s a single elimination tournament covering most of Disney’s animated movies. For each pair, above, you rank which one you like best. On Friday I’ll report the results and we’ll have round two. Eventually we’ll figure out which one the Dope likes best, overall.

[blondebear]

32. Chicken Little

33. Alice in Wonderland

34. 101 Dalmations

35. The Rescuers

36. The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh

37. Dumbo

38. The Rescuers Down Under

39. The Jungle Book

40. The Aristocats

41. Tarzan

42. The Three Caballeros

43. Brother Bear

44. Meet the Robinsons

45. Peter Pan

46. The Fox and the Hound

47. Home on the Range

[Yookeroo]

1. Cinderella (First Round Bye)

2. The Sword in the Stone

3. The Emperor’s New Groove

4. Bambi (First round Bye)

5. 101 Dalmations

6. Lilo and Stitch (First round bye)

7. Atlantis: The Lost Empire

8. Sleeping Beauty (First round bye)

9. Fantasia/2000

10. Dumbo

11. The Little Mermaid (First round bye)

12. The Great Mouse Detective

13. Hercules (First round bye)

14. The Jungle Book

15. Beauty and the Beast (First round bye)

16. The Aristocats

17. Tarzan

18. Mulan (First round bye)

19. Fantasia

20. Pinocchio (First round bye)

21. Fun and Fancy Free

22. Aladdin (First round bye)

23. Oliver and Company

24. Peter Pan

25. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs (First round bye)

26. The Hunchback of Notre Dame

27. The Lion King (First round bye)

28. Saludos Amigos

[Happy_Fun_Ball]

33. The Sword in the Stone

34. Alice in Wonderland

35. 101 Dalmations

36. The Rescuers

37. The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh

38. Lady and the Tramp

39. The Rescuers Down Under

40. The Jungle Book

41. The Aristocats

42. Robin Hood

43. Fantasia

44. Brother Bear

45. Meet the Robinsons

46. Peter Pan

47. The Hunchback of Notre Dame

48. Home on the Range

[RachelChristine]

1. Cinderella (First Round Bye)

2. The Sword in the Stone

3. Alice in Wonderland

4. Bambi (First round Bye)

5. 101 Dalmations

6. Lilo and Stitch (First round bye)

7. The Rescuers

8. Sleeping Beauty (First round bye)

9. Fantasia/2000

10. Lady and the Tramp

11. The Little Mermaid (First round bye)

12. The Rescuers Down Under

13. Hercules (First round bye)

14. The Jungle Book

15. Beauty and the Beast (First round bye)

16. The Black Cauldron

17. Robin Hood

18. Mulan (First round bye)

19. The Three Caballeros

20. Pinocchio (First round bye)

21. Fun and Fancy Free

22. Aladdin (First round bye)

23. Oliver and Company

24. Peter Pan

25. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs (First round bye)

26. The Fox and the Hound

27. The Lion King (First round bye)

28. Saludos Amigos

[Reloy3]

My choices and comments are in bold.

1. Cinderella (First Round Bye)
   Good, but first seed? really?

2. Chicken Little

3. The Sword in the Stone
   Not even close, I’m surprised they are so close in seeding.

4. Alice in Wonderland
   17. The Emperor’s New Groove

5. Bambi (First round Bye)

6. 101 Dalmations

7. Treasure Planet
   I know I’m going to be in the minority here, but 101 Dalmations just doesn’t do it for me.

8. Lilo and Stitch (First round bye)
   Could make it into the finals just based on the “Why Lilo is late for dance class” scene

9. The Rescuers

10. Atlantis: The Lost Empire

11. Sleeping Beauty (First round bye)

12. The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh

13. Fantasia/2000
    Tough call, both of them might have beat most other movies in my mind.

14. Dumbo

15. Lady and the Tramp

16. The Little Mermaid (First round bye)

17. The Rescuers Down Under

18. The Great Mouse Detective

19. Hercules (First round bye)

20. The Jungle Book

21. Make Mine Music
    I’ve never even seen a copy of Make Mine Music.

22. Beauty and the Beast (First round bye)

23. The Aristocats

24. The Black Cauldron
    The Black Cauldron is an abominable corruption of a wonderful book, but even it beats the Aristocats.

25. Tarzan

26. Robin Hood

27. Mulan (First round bye)
    I hope this one goes all the way

28. Fantasia

29. The Three Caballeros
    Fantasia should be seeded higher.

30. Pinocchio (First round bye)

31. Brother Bear

32. Fun and Fancy Free
    In this corner, Crap vs. Crap

33. Aladdin (First round bye)

34. Meet the Robinsons

35. Oliver and Company

36. Pocahontas

37. Peter Pan
    Aaaagh, Pocahontas must die.

38. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs (First round bye)

39. The Hunchback of Notre Dame

40. The Fox and the Hound
    Wow, a tough one, but the Fox and the Hound wins for sentimental reasons, even though Hunchback is probably a better film. "I’m a hound dog. aaaaaroooooogh"

41. The Lion King (First round bye)

42. Home on the Range

43. Saludos Amigos
    A test pattern beats Home on the Range.

It’s a good thing Pixar isn’t thrown in, only a few traditional Disney stuff would survive the bloodbath.

[NAF1138]

@Reloy3

44. Make Mine Music
    I’ve never even seen a copy of Make Mine Music.

Really? You should track it down, it really is very good. That and Melody Time actually. Good short experimental (at the time) animated features that pick up where Fantasia left off.

Make Mine Music has Willie the Whale, Peter and the Wolf, Johnny Fedora and many other classic shorts in it. It also has the amazing All the Cats Join In directed by Freddy Moore. This short and others like it revolutionized the world of animation, spawning a new minimalistic style of animating that lead to companies like UPA (who did amazing things with the art of animation) and eventually allowed places like Hanna Barbera to be able to get in the game.

IF you can find a VHS copy, and IF you have a VHS machine watch the VHS version. The DVD’s have been sanitized by Disney. The leave the Martins and the Coys out entierly. Same with Melody Time. Modern Disney likes to scew up their past. Unlce Walt (bastard that he was) must be rolling in his grave.