Disney Animated Movie Madness ROUND THREE!

The Game Room
1

Yes, here we are again with round three of Disney Animated Movie Madness! We’re getting down the the nitty gritty here and there’s going to be some difficult choices!

The seedings are beginning to fall into line. We’ll keep voting for this one open until Wednesday evening to keep things moving along. You have two days, people! Get those votes in!

On to the competition!

  1. Cinderella

  2. The Emperor’s New Groove

  3. 101 Dalmatians

  4. Lilo and Stitch

  5. Sleeping Beauty

  6. Dumbo

  7. The Little Mermaid

  8. The Jungle Book

  9. Beauty and the Beast

  10. Robin Hood

  11. Fantasia

  12. Pinocchio

  13. Aladdin

  14. Peter Pan

  15. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs

  16. The Lion King

2

  1. Cinderella (an easy one)

  2. 101 Dalmatians (an easy one)

  3. Sleeping Beauty (a tough one)

  4. The Little Mermaid (a tough one)

  5. Beauty and the Beast (an easy one)

  6. Fantasia (a tough one)

  7. Aladdin (a tough one)

  8. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs (a tough one)

3

  1. Cinderella

  2. Lilo and Stitch

  3. Dumbo

  4. The Little Mermaid

  5. Beauty and the Beast

  6. Pinocchio

  7. Aladdin

  8. The Lion King

4
  1. The Emperor’s New Groove

I love Cinderella, and it’s a classic. But in 5th grade(or somewhere around there) I practically had every line memorized of the Emperor’s New Groove.

  1. Lilo and Stitch
    Stitch and I have a thing goin’, we’re both overly hyper psychotic things.

  2. Dumbo
    This one was insanely tough, but I had to go with a Disney Original (at least I think it is).

  3. The Little Mermaid

  4. Beauty and the Beast

  5. Pinocchio
    Flipped a coin, couldn’t decide.

  6. Aladdin

  7. The Lion King

5

  1. Cinderella

  2. 101 Dalmatians

  3. Sleeping Beauty (Sorry, Dumbo, but the freaky dream sequence with the pink elephants freaks me out.)

  4. The Jungle Book

  5. Robin Hood

  6. Fantasia

  7. Peter Pan

  8. The Lion King (Toughest match-up so far IMO, but had to go with Lion King because I love the soundtrack.)

6

  1. The Emperor’s New Groove

  2. Lilo and Stitch

  3. Dumbo

  4. The Little Mermaid

  5. Beauty and the Beast

  6. Fantasia

  7. Aladdin

  8. The Lion King

(Age: 19)

7

Pretty easy round to judge, really. No tight competitions in my book, with only Lion King up against Snow White being even close.

[del]1. Cinderella[/del]
17. The Emperor’s New Groove
Weak, annoying protagonist up against the funniest and best pure comedy Disney has produced, which happens to be one of my personal favorites. No contest despite some good songs in Cinderella.

[del]25. 101 Dalmatians[/del]
9. Lilo and Stitch
Lilo and Stitch is just plain fun to watch repeatedly, while Dalmatians is only pretty good and gets old quickly.

4. Sleeping Beauty
[del]13. Dumbo[/del]
No contest. Sleeping Beauty is simply beautiful, amazing just to watch. It is my favorite classic.

5. The Little Mermaid
[del]21. The Jungle Book[/del]
What can I say? I have a redhead fetish. Plus the music is second to none.

2. Beauty and the Beast
[del]18. Robin Hood[/del]
As much as I like Robin Hood and watch it often, Beauty and the Beast is a pinnacle achievement. I watch it just as much. If you have the DVD with the “Work in Progress” version, watch it. Glenn Keans is simply amazing. (and more great music)

26. Fantasia
[del]10. Pinocchio[/del]
Like I said, it’s pure art. Plus my favorite villain, Chernabog, is from Fantasia.

3. Aladdin
[del]19. Peter Pan[/del]
Rewatching Peter Pan on the recent DVD release, I decided I didn’t like it all that much. Put it up against Aladdin, it has no chance. When I heard people say Aladdin was better than Beauty, I couldn’t believe them, but when I saw it I was truly amazed. However, Beauty is still better in my book by a score of 99 to 98.

6. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs
[del]11. The Lion King[/del]
Even with Rowan Atkinson, I never much liked Lion King. Snow White still holds up after all these years. It’s truly a great film.

8

  1. The Emperor’s New Groove

  2. Lilo and Stitch

  3. Sleeping Beauty

  4. The Little Mermaid

  5. Beauty and the Beast

  6. Pinocchio

  7. Aladdin

  8. The Lion King

As others have posted - these are starting to get to be difficult choices.

9
  1. Cinderella
    17. The Emperor’s New Groove
    Tough choice. Cinderella has the “dress destruction scene” which is one of the most evil moments in any Disney film. But ultimately I have to give it to New Groove for the strength of it’s animation.

25. 101 Dalmatians
9. Lilo and Stitch
Another tough choice. Lilo is well-executed and has some great moments, but Dalmatians has a better villian and amazing character animation.

  1. Sleeping Beauty
    13. Dumbo
    Chilly and gorgeous Beauty or floppy and sentimental Dumbo? My heart says “Dumbo!”

  2. The Little Mermaid
    21. The Jungle Book
    No contest here. The Little Mermaid is over-rated. Good songs, but the animation is shit. Jungle Book has good songs and amazing animation. Shere Khan and King Louie are absolute masterworks.

2. Beauty and the Beast
18. Robin Hood
Robin Hood is shaky. Great characters can’t help the repetitive animation. Beauty is the best of the modern princess movies.

  1. Fantasia
    10. Pinocchio
    Pinocchio is simply the best movie Disney ever made. Sorry Fantasia.

  2. Aladdin
    19. Peter Pan
    Robin Williams is annoying. Tinkerbell is a hoot. Peter Pan all the way.

6. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs
11. The Lion King
No contest. Snow White is a masterpiece. The Lion King has fart jokes.

10

  1. The Emperor’s New Groove

  2. 101 Dalmatians

  3. Sleeping Beauty

  4. The Jungle Book

  5. Beauty and the Beast

  6. Fantasia

  7. Aladdin

  8. The Lion King

11

Cinderella

101 Dalmatians

Sleeping Beauty

The Little Mermaid

Beauty and the Beast

Fantasia

Aladdin

Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs

12
  1. Cinderella
    17. The Emperor’s New Groove

Up until Kronk tosses the Emperor into the river this is one of the funniest movies ever. It drops off a bit, but damn.

25. 101 Dalmatians
9. Lilo and Stitch
4. Sleeping Beauty
13. Dumbo

  1. The Little Mermaid
    21. The Jungle Book
    2. Beauty and the Beast

  2. Robin Hood

  3. Fantasia
    10. Pinocchio
    3. Aladdin

  4. Peter Pan

  5. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs
    11. The Lion King

13

  1. The Emperor’s New Groove

  2. Lilo and Stitch

  3. Dumbo

  4. The Little Mermaid

  5. Beauty and the Beast

  6. Fantasia

  7. Aladdin

  8. The Lion King

14

  1. Cinderella

  2. 101 Dalmatians

  3. Dumbo

  4. The Little Mermaid

  5. Robin Hood

  6. Pinocchio

  7. Peter Pan

  8. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs

15

  1. The Emperor’s New Groove

  2. Lilo and Stitch

  3. Dumbo

  4. The Little Mermaid

  5. Beauty and the Beast

  6. Fantasia

  7. Aladdin

  8. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs

16

  1. The Emperor’s New Groove

  2. Lilo and Stitch

  3. Sleeping Beauty

  4. The Little Mermaid

  5. Beauty and the Beast

  6. Fantasia

  7. Aladdin

  8. The Lion King

17

Cinderella
Lilo & Stitch
Sleeping Beauty (it has a great villain and Tchaikovsky!)
Little Mermaid (Jungle Book is fun, but nowhere near as good.)
Beauty and the Beast
Pinocchio
Aladdin (sigh. I love Peter Pan. I wanted to be Peter Pan when I was a toddler…but…)
The Lion King (tough one. Snow White is a great film.)

18

The Emperor’s New Groove

Lilo and Stitch

Sleeping Beauty

The Little Mermaid

Robin Hood

Fantasia

Aladdin

The Lion King

19

  1. Cinderella

  2. 101 Dalmatians

  3. Dumbo

  4. The Jungle Book

  5. Robin Hood

  6. Fantasia

  7. Aladdin

  8. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs

Joe

20

  1. The Emperor’s New Groove

  2. 101 Dalmatians

  3. Sleeping Beauty

  4. The Little Mermaid

  5. Beauty and the Beast

  6. Fantasia

  7. Aladdin

  8. The Lion King