I’ve just read through a book in which several people write on topics related to the place of emotion in the philosophical analysis of experience. Each of the writers in this book seems to assume that emotions feel like something. By this I mean they are saying emotions either have qualia or something like qualia. Qualia are the what-it’s-like of sense perceptions–the “redness” of red and the floweriness of a flowery scent, and so on. So these people are all saying that just as there is a kind of “redness” quality to a sensation of red, so there is a kind of “angry” quality to an emotion of anger.
I can see that this is reflected in the language–emotions are called “feelings” after all.
Only one thing. I don’t know what an emotion feels like. So, for example, if my wife asks me, “Are you angry?” I can answer (usually) right off the bat, but the basis of my answer is not a judgment as to what sort of inner emotional sensation I am having. Nor is my answer based on some primative, non-qualitative understanding of my emotional state. Rather, my answer is based (as far as I can tell) on a quick inventory of the kinds of thoughts I’m having and the kinds of behaviors I’m exhibiting. “Hmmm… I want to hit things, I am trembling slightly, I find myself naturally tending toward incoherence of thought yet strangely able to avail myself of intensely coherent thinking if I concentrate… yes, this is anger. I am angry.” <----not as explicit as all that, but this seems to me to be the thought process, basically.
So my point is, it does not seem to me that emotions have qualities in the way that sensations do.
And my question is, what is it like for others? Do emotions feel like something to you? Is there a quality to emotion? Are there, so to speak, “emotion sensations” you have when you are feeling strong emotions?
Is this something psychologists have written about? When are children able to report emotions and what do we know about the basis upon which they make their reports? I know my three year old can accurately report when he is sad and when he is “better,” but he only ever reports sadness while he is crying so for all I know he is basing his judgment simply on observation of his own behavior.
-FrL-
A better link about qualia