Do Horses prefer sleeping on their feet?

I’ve always heard that horses sleep on their feet, unless they are sick.
They are more vulnerable to predators lying down. Horses can lock their legs and sleep very comfortably standing up.

I’ve been following this blog of a guy traveling the country in a horse drawn wagon. He’s posted a bunch of photos of his horses lying down.
There’s 3 nice pics of the horses here.
http://www.wagonteamster.com/html/a_nice_day_off_in_gilmer.html

I’ve seen cows and horses asleep on their feet at my uncles farm. Calves often sleep on the ground, but the adults usually stand.

I wonder if extreme fatigue is causing this guys horses to sleep lying down?

Is it an urban myth that horses have a preference?

I can give you an anecdotal response to start things off. Obviously, it’s hard to say what a horse “prefers,” but I don’t see my horses lay down to sleep very often. When they do, it’s mostly in the middle of the day, and one always stays standing to keep watch.

Cows are the other way around. I know everyone talks about how cows always sleep standing up, but my cows laid down a lot. Where I live, we have ranches everywhere, and there are cows laying down on all of them.

I used to work at a stable when I was much younger, in my teens. We had nearly 90 or 100 horses and ponies there.

Horses do choose to lay down for a nap. They aren’t necessarily sick when they do it, sometimes they just want to lay down, I guess. (They will also roll around on their back sometimes like oversized dogs, too. Usually just after you cleaned them up or when they’re damp from rain or at some other very inconvenient time that will require you to spend more time grooming them.)

That said, it seems to me that at night horses almost invariably stand up to sleep. When they do lay down it’s typically, as mentioned, during the day for a nap, not an extended slumber, and often there are other horses awake and alert nearby. Also, a horse has to feel pretty relaxed and comfortable and safe to do this - nervous horses stay on their feet. So, if a horse is spending the night in a roomy box stall (for example) and feels very safe and secure he might decide to lay down - but he doesn’t have to.

Also, when healthy horses lay down for a nap they often are off their feet but still hold their heads upright. Laying out flat on the ground, with the neck stretched out and the head on the ground, might be alarming to horse owner. However, horses that are sick usually display some other signs of it besides just laying down. These signs can be subtle, but they do exist, so lying down + unusual sweating + labored breathing is not good, but laying down + breathing easily and calmly + no sweating probably means the horse just wants to lay down for a short nap, nothing wrong with him at all.

I doubt the horses linked to in the picture are laying down due to “extreme fatigue” - a fatigued horse can still sleep standing up. Also, as noted, they’re still holding their heads up. More likely, they’re very well cared for horses that feel safe with their owner nearby and they’re just taking a quick nap in the sunshine. I also note that their ears are a in a relaxed and confident position, which would be less likely in an ill, beaten-down, or mistreated horse. Looking at the other horses on the site, they all seem like well-muscled, well fed draft horses with healthy, glossy coats. There aren’t any close ups, but from what I could see of their feet their hooves are all in good condition. The horses are alert but relaxed. There’s no way to know for sure, but they look like well cared for horses.

I know sometimes people get concerned with horses being worked, but like people, horses benefit from exercise (at the stable I worked at the horses were exercised daily except in extreme weather, late pregnancy, or if there was some illness or injury and they routinely lived into their mid-20s which wouldn’t happen to poorly fed, mistreated, or unhealthy horses) The horses on the linked site are all draft horses, bred for heavy work and enormously powerful animals. He uses four horses to pull his wagon, and he does give them days off.

In sum - I see no reason to believe those horses are in any way mistreated or overworked.

Thanks. I learn something new every day on the Dope. :wink: I follow the wagonteamster’s blog regularly. He does seem to take good care of his horses. He usually travels 3 or 4 days and then takes a day off to rest. Glad to hear that it’s not unusual for horses to lie down.

The pics make more sense now. The brown horse is on his feet (guarding) while the white one is lying down. They probably switched roles when the brown one lay down.

Aw, man, I’m going to have to go dig up a cite…but…I recall reading that a horse cannot reach deep sleep while being on their feet, and must lie down to reach that level. They only need 2-3 hours of sleep like that.

That said, I’ve owned my mare for 7+ years, and have never seen her lie down. The miniature horse I used to have took regular naps around 10am in the sun–my Arabian? Never. I know she lies down at night because of the stains that decorate her white coat in the morning, but I have never seen it.

The other morning, I was riding around the stable and saw four horses lying down dozing (heads and necks still up–not completely prone). Apparently, it was naptime. My mare, of course, was on her feet.

My (human) newborn is waking and wanting food, so I’ll dig up those cites later. I want to say it was from Horses for Dummies.

Folk wisdom around here has it that when cows are lying down, it is going to rain. I haven’t actually made any serious scientific observations but there does appear to be some truth to this. They stand up when the rain starts falling

They’re good at that, aren’t they? Spend an hour cleaning them up, and three minutes later they’re flat on their back in the dirt waving all four hooves in the air.

The dog is worse, though. After a bath, she doesn’t roll in the dirt – she jumps in the beaver pond and then rolls in a pile of horse poop.

When I was raising cattle, I don’t think there was ever a day when I didn’t see at least some of them lay down. If that folk wisdom was accurate, the cows and I would have floated away…

I used to be barn manager at a 40 horse farm in Virginia. On a nice sunny day you definitely will see them lying flat out in the sunshine (by flat out I mean with their heads down). Yes, they look dead, yes, it’s alarming, and it is also perfectly normal.

They rarely lie down more than an hour or so. There are a couple of reasons for that. Horses need to stand and move for proper circulation (the hoof is a pump activated by being pressed to the ground). Because of the weight of their torso, they also cannot get a really good deep breath when lying down, another reason why lying-down periods are generally short.

If horses do not get a chance to lie down ever, they can become sleep deprived. But it takes weeks for the lack of ability to lie down to affect the horse.
http://www.equisearch.com/horses_care/health/behavior/eqsleep1772/

BTW, horses can be afflicted by narcolepsy. My friend’s horse, a large, sturdy ex-racehorse, passes out while her mane is braided. And by “passes out” I mean 1200 lbs of horse just suddenly collapses. Very alarming, but the symptom never shows at any other time.

Wiki agrees with you:

One of the linked articles mentions horses lying down to sleep in a tie-stall, which, if you aren’t familar with them, are narrow stalls that look just big enough for a horse to stand upright in, and does not allow room to turn around (usually - I have known one or two small, skinny, and very agile horses that managed it). The horse usually enters head first, then has to back out to leave (with the usual caveat that there are a small minority of contrary horses that prefer to back into such stalls so they can see out of them easily.

I can confirm this - the stable I worked at had a mare that frequently chose to lay down in her tie-stall, often alarming the newer staff and students. She didn’t seem to have any problem getting up and down in the narrow stall. Perhaps she felt safe and secure. I don’t really know. Sometimes she’d lean up against one wall or the other, other times just hold her head upright while snoozing. Horses are very much individuals and vary condiseriably in their temperament, habits, and preferences.

I love the Dope! I often wonder about this when I see horses and cows.

There was an article on horses and sleep deprivation in the UK Veterinary Times recently. In particular, it mentioned cases of sleep deprivation in geldings that won’t sleep unless there is a more dominant mare standing guard in the field.

Cows don’t have the anatomical features that allow horses to rest standing up. If they have a comfortable surface to lie on, cows spend up to 14 hours a day lying down, and sleep for around 4 hours.