One of my work responsibilities is teaching high school students about animal abuse, and one of the topics I cover is dogfighting. To counter the idea that fighting comes naturally to dogs, I explain something that I read a few years ago: animals do not routinely fight to the death with members of the same species. Instead, when two animals clash in the wild, they do a lot of posturing, and then sometimes a few clashes, but as soon as one animal demonstrates dominance, the two animals back away. Animals that don’t end fights before lethality are less likely to survive to reproduce, I explain: even the winner of the fight is likely to suffer serious injuries that reduce their chances of reproduction. Natural selection tends to weed out animals that engage in fatal fighting, and so dogfighters engage in intensive inbreeding and then abusive training and drugging regimens to get dogs to fight to the death.
But this morning I read something that hinted at broad fatal fights between members of the same species, in a fairly reliable source (Stephen Pinker’s The Blank Slate). It didn’t offer details. Does anyone know the truth of this?
If animals routinely fight to the death in the wild–especially if wolves fight to the death in the wild on a routine basis–I’ll need to change my program.
Daniel

