This argument has been made by many more eloquent than I but it’s still worth talking about. Is our popular culture resulting in a propensity towards violence? I sincerely wish that the answer could be a definitive no, but I don’t think that that is the case.
What brought this on was the movie Sin City. I saw it for the first time last night, and I found myself laughing a good bit. That got me to thinking: what in the world is so funny about someone getting blown to bits or shot in the head or committing suicide? Stuff like that is tragic, not humorous. If you saw it in the newspaper or on the 6 o’clock broadcast you’d shake your head in disgust at what is going on, shrug your shoulders at the injustice of it all, and that would be the end of it, but at least you’d be disgusted about it if only for a fleeting moment. Contrast that with movies where those sorts of things draw cheers and riotous laughter or awe (as in "Wow! That was cool!). The disconnect there is astounding. Is this an example of our desensitization and/or propensity towards violence? I’ll let you be the judge.
Video games are a similar beast, but they add another element: you are the one doing the killing. One of my favorite games is Call of Duty, a first-person shooter where you are a member of the Allies during World War II. When you’re playing the game it’s easy to hate the Germans for what you know they did during that time, but all the same the game has detailed rendering of faces, thus making them more human, and in some cases requires you to shoot them while they’re wounded and on their knees which these days would be outright brutality and might even be a war crime. On top of that, there are save points, medpacks, and restarts, so you’re essentially immortal, when (I hope) we all know that that is not the case at all. Other games require you to speed in a vehicle with no regard to traffic, and if you hit something you just reset and continue or, in some cases, you get no damage at all.
There is no restart, there is no second chance, and killing someone exacts a toll for most people. Very few people can kill indiscriminately or wantonly. Most people involved in shootings feel considerable remorse or guilt, even in the most justifiable circumstances. But in games and movies there is no remorse. In fact, it’s often portrayed as outright funny. Shoot the guys in an outrageous manner, say something funny, smoke a cigarette, and ride off into the sunset. That’s the plot of too many movies nowadays.
I am loathe to ask this, because I am an advocate of personal responsibility, and while this does not mitigate that responsibility, it may be a justification, albeit a poor one. Are we breeding psychosis among our populace? If so, what do we do about it? The genie is out of the bottle. Or am I just blowing smoke? It could be, and again, I’d like to think so. Even so, I feel a certain awkwardness laughing at violence, because it’s not supposed to be funny, and I can’t help but think that when violence is portrayed that way it lessens the impact, thus making it more, shall we say, accessible than it used to be. I have to raise a son, and he has to go out into a world where he might get hurt or killed for laughs. That scares me. Should it?