Wait - are we talking about dating your friend’s exes after they’ve broken up for other reasons, or are we talking about using your (masculine or feminine) wiles to induce the breakup?
Because I see no problem with the former, and have never understood why some people are so adamant about it. I even had one friend who was dating my ex ask me to promise her that if they ever broke up I wouldn’t hook up with him again. WTF? If he’s single, he’s single, and at that point you have zero control over where he puts his boything.
However, actually inducing a breakup is bad form, though (again IMO) less so than boffing your friend’s sweetie behind their back.
As far as gender discrepancy in poaching over either the short or long term - I’ve never noticed one.
I only have one experience in this to relate: my ex wound up sleeping with her friend’s boyfriend. However, it was quite clear that he initiated entirely. Sure, she chose to go along with it, but he was definitely the one pressing it. He even got them a motel to spend the night in. And I believe she was drunk. (And, no, we weren’t together at the time, though we had rekindled our longtime friendship, although that was a trying time for it.)
Just thought I’d throw that out there–y’all can do the analysis.
ETA: Guy was recently back from being in the army, and his girlfriend was away for some other reason.
I guess because nobody had any idea; it wasn’t intentional. They had been friends for years (all the friends had been within the group) but had only been dating very casually for weeks. Her friends expressed shock at her reaction; she had apparently been harboring it in secret. Nobody said love had to be rational, but then again I never understood why someone would love someone who didn’t love them in return. For me, it always had to be reciprocated.
I guess so. This statement brought me back to the memory of a high school boyfriend, who wrote me a poem about how he cared about me and later told me he loved me and couldn’t wait to sleep with me .