Does anyone else have a hard accepting republican voters are decent people lately?

Conservatives, and those who voted for trump, in particular, specifically did so because they did not think that america was working out for them. They wanted to make america great again, not take pride in the great country in which they lived. They are the ones who refuse to change as technology, culture and demographics change, and demand that the way it was when they were children is the way it should always be. They are not willing to change their own circumstance, of moving or retraining for a new career, but they want the world to continue to hand them whatever they ask for, because anything less would be a change for the worse.

Conservatives resent that their lifestyle changes as the world changes, and they refuse to change with it.

I disagree entirely that liberals are the ones that life isn’t working out for. Liberals are the ones who can see outside their immediate tribe, and see that things aren’t working out for others. It is not trying to improve our own lot in life, often, our lot in life is relatively comfortable and secure. It is extending that comfort and security to those who have been denied it by our society for generations.

We don’t ask much from those who have the security and comfort in their life. We don’t ask them to give up their necessities of survival to hand to others, we ask that they share some of their luxuries in order for others to survive.

Conservatives are not the only ones who go to work every day to support their families. Progressives do as well. We also use our resources to help other families. Maybe that does mean that we lose out going to disney rather than just to the beach, but it means that other people don’t die from exposure, privation, or lack of medical care.

If all progressive movements are seen as a bunch of dirty entitled hipsters by conservatives, then that explains part of why they have such contempt for those who attempt to address their grievances with the govt and the policies it enforces, I can understand that. But, when conservatives see a group of clean cut white kids carrying Tiki torches and nazi flags, they see a bunch of fine people.

Conservatives constantly complain about taxes, and their tax burden, even though taxes are the lowest they have been in over half a century. They constantly lobby for further cuts, and complain about any possibility of an increase, even as they complain about the deficits that are being run up.

When a conservative does something insensitive that hurts someone, they blame the aggrieved party for being too sensitive, rather than taking any responsibility for the offense on their own.

When someone does something for a purpose of bringing attention to an issue that is important to them, if it is done in a way that conservatives dislike, they complain that they are being offended by those actions, and condemn that expression of speech.

When called on racially insensitive behavior, they double down, insisting that actions and phrases and symbols that have been used historically by open racists for the specific purpose of oppressing others are simply part of their heritage, and should not be associated in the minds of those who were oppressed under those symbols as symbols of oppression.

When they see a mass shooting on TV, rather than consider whether their support for unfettered access to weapons of all kinds may be responsible for what they are witnessing, and could be responsible for the next incident, they instead run out to purchase more, and do anything they can to stop any efforts that could reduce the chances and severity of another incident.

All that said, I see most people as decent people, whether they be conservative, liberal, green, purple, or whatever. Just that someone disagrees with me politically does not mean that I see them as inferior, or stupid, or in any way lessor for their beliefs. I may know that you are a trump supporter, and that won’t keep me from having you as a client, an acquaintance, or a family member. I run games with lots of people that I know voted for trump. I live in the middle of trump territory. It would be difficult, and a bit foolish, to write all these people off.

I do however, think less of some people when they express their political views. When they bring up how evil democrats are, or how great trump is, then I start thinking poorly of them quite quickly. It’s not that they have these views, it’s that these views are counterfactual and illogical. I lost a number of social contacts in the last year, as there were those who could not go an hour without bringing up their thoughts on the matter.

Amongst most of my acquaintances, we have a pretty well enforced rule of no politics. We get together to play games and have fun, and everyone knows that as soon as anything political is brought up, fun ends for everyone. My clients occasionally bring up politics, but I just refuse to engage, and use the excuse that I’m so busy with running this place that I really have no time to pay any attention to such things. Some of my friends and I talk politics, but we are usually on the same basic page. We may have an impassioned discussion on healthcare, and the different priorities of cost, availability, and quality, but we are all in agreement that more people covered is better.

My family, I avoid most of them anymore. It sucks, cuase I used to enjoy being around them, but they will use any topic as a pivot point to get a dig in against me and what they think of my politics. My father somewhat recently said, “And your buddy dennis rodman is hanging out with jung-il (he had a different name for him, and it wasn’t rocket man, but I don’t remember it at the moment.).” Which made no sense whatsoever. Rodman endorsed trump, so he’s not really my buddy there. My father is a basketball fan, and I’ve only tolerated it in order to spend time with him, so it’s not that either. The only thing I can think of is that he is black, and my father isn’t a big fan of black people, so that makes rodman “my buddy”. He felt he won the discussion by the look of bafflement and confusion on my face. And well, I didn’t have a comeback for the line, so I guess he did. And in that winning, I didn’t bother to talk to him for about 3 months.

That is the nature of nearly all political discussions I have with trump supporters IRL, they just make shit up. It doesn’t have to be based on reality. It doesn’t have to be logical, or make a lick of sense. It just has to be hurtful to a liberal, that seems to be enough. After enough of these discussions, even though I try to keep an open mind about them, it does start to become difficult to see these trump supporters as decent people.

It’s hard for me to reconcile good qualities with the willingness to vote for Trump. I don’t understand the priorities at play. I too have family members who voted Trump, and these are people who relied on ACA, for instance, or the children health insurance program, and who would cheerfully shoot someone who grabbed at their daughters or wives the way he bragged of doing. Some of them seem quite gleeful that Trump upsets
their fellow Americans, and that the political divide is deepening. One cut all ties with me because i disagreed with her that transgender children should be separated from cisgender kids, and that they, in her opinion, were predators or something. Before Trump, i considered her one of the sweetest people i knew. Now? Well, we don’t talk. But last time we did she was nasty and hateful.

Another family member, a teacher, was thoroughly horrified that HRC defended a child rapist in court in the 70s. Didn’t blink at the “locker room talk,” allegations of sexual assault, or barging into the dressing rooms of young pageant contestants. We don’t talk about politics at all anymore.

This is how I feel. I suppose I’m lucky that I live in a bubble where I don’t interact with any Trump supporters. The ones I see on TV However are evil and/or profoundly stupid. The may seek people like that out deliberately for better stories, but holy cow, I think we’re in trouble.

I’m open to having a discussion with Trump supporters, I welcome it. It is hard though because a lot of us really can’t rectify being a decent person and being a Trump supporter. It doesn’t make sense to us.

I bolded part of your statement because that I what I meant by hand waving it away. Its not politics. Trump is a whole new level of danger and derangement that I’ve never seen in my adult life. Trump is not Mitt Romney, John Kasich, George Bush, Bob Dole, etc.

There are valid reasons to think Trump is an agent of Vladimir Putin. The dossier written by ex-MI6 agent Christopher Steele (who used to work in undercover Russian relations for England’s intelligence agencies) claims Trump has worked with Putin for years. Trump will lash out at anyone/everyone but never at Putin. Putin is working a disinformation campaign in the US, and Trump is helping him. Trump has had several meetings with the Russians. I hope Mueller’s investigation turns up some decent Russia ties, because having the guy who headed the FBI for 13 years validate these concerns will be helpful.

That doesn’t even take into account that there is good reason to think Trump has multiple mental illnesses that disqualify him from leadership (a narcissistic disorder and dementia probably. Other presidents have had mental health issues like depression, substance abuse, bipolar or anxiety disorders, but it never disqualified them from leadership the way Trump’s illnesses disqualify him), or that he knows less about civics and policy than a 3rd grader. Or his history of criminal and sociopathic behavior. Or the way he is trying to aggravate our racial and religious divisions. The right likes to say Obama was a divider, but he wasn’t. Trump is doing everything he can to divide the country along sensitive fault lines.

Nobody on either side has something like that. I remember when Trump was running, Mitt Romney went on TV and he said one of his kids asked him ‘dad, what did you do to make sure Trump wouldn’t get elected’. Thats a responsible person I disagree with. I disagree with Romney on policy, but he isn’t deeply deranged and potentially treasonous the way Trump is.

I don’t think you understand why so many of us are having trouble rectifying being a Trump supporter with also being a moral, informed, responsible person.

This is basically what defines the right at this point:

I think we are in the same lifeboat together on this point. I have family who can take a discussion about laundry into Hilary is an Evil Cunt territory. I am a very pragmatic person. I have a pretty thick skin. And I am seriously wondering if all their common sense has just flown out the window.

I think the man is mentally ill. I really do. I know he has at least a personality disorder. My armchair analysis of him is that he stopped development somewhere around his fancy prep school days and never went any further. He hasn’t evolved, he hasn’t kept up with society, and he is the exact opposite of a “life-long learner”, which we all should be. He’s too arrogant to think he needs to do any of this.

And yes, I do think less of people who defend him and can’t see any of these things, it is a plain as the nose on your face.

I remember when I was a kid I would read in a magazine about some $50 device you could add to your car and it would increase the MPG by 20% or so. I’d show my dad and he would say ‘if that worked, they’d put them in all the cars that get manufactured’. There were other situations like that too where he said something insightful that made me realize I was being taken.

But now he mindlessly parrots every lie he hears on right wing media outlets. Even if I do do the 30 seconds of legwork necessary to investigate and explain why what he believes isn’t true, it doesn’t affect him. Every media outlet that isn’t right wing propaganda is fake news. And right wing propaganda doesn’t report anything but propaganda. It’d be like if Pravda in Russia had a cult following of people who not only believed everything they read and heard from Pravda, but who believed every news source on earth that wasn’t Pravda was capitalist lies.

How did so many people on the right lose their critical thinking skills? I think it is because right wing media plays on the more primitive emotional centers of the brain (fear, resentment, tribalism, etc) which override the critical thinking frontal cortex. That is my assumption.

First, most people who voted for Trump are middle class and higher middle class. Not poor.

Secondly, I am unaware of any liberal arguments that anyone (besides criminals) need to be punished. Rectifying a legacy of discrimination against one or more groups doesn’t involve punishing anyone (that is, depriving someone of something they would otherwise be entitled to).

Seems to me that it’s conservatives who are the ones kicking poor whites in teeth, not liberals. Who just took away healthcare subsidies? Not liberals. Who wants to cut food stamps to pay for a border wall? Which party is favor of cutting back grants for poor college students? Not liberals.

Conservatives talk a good game of caring for poor white folk, but their policies always betray their rhetoric.

I agree with the first part of your statement; however, they’ve kind of backed themselves into a corner with that one. They spent 8 years demonizing Obama and the Affordable Care Act (merging the two hatreds into their moniker “Obamacare”) - quite a few of their voters *would be enraged if they’re seen supporting the bill rather than tearing it down. Because they told them it was an awful socialist power-play with death panels designed to redistribute wealth away from middle-class families. It’d be great if they were able to work to make reasonable improvements for the ACA, but it probably would be political suicide.

That’s why they couldn’t pass it even with a majority in both houses; more moderate Republicans were worried the cuts to healthcare were too brutal. The tea-party wing were worried the cuts weren’t *brutal enough for their voters to accept. There was no way of reconciling those two positions.

I disagree that people want to see the two sides working together. Their gridlock generally tends to be a good thing. When they come together it’s usually to do something awful that no one agrees with except the corporate donors to both parties. Like ending net neutrality. Or the bill that had a 93% disapproval rating that passed without comment, to allow ISPs to sell your information without your knowledge or consent. Or giving subsidies to corporations with billions in revenue every year.

Compromise is not always a good thing. The compromise between completely awful and reasonable is still awful. The half-way compromise between removing healthcare from 30 million Americans and not removing it from anyone in the recent healthcare debate would have been to remove it from 15 million Americans. The compromise between completely ending Medicaid and food stamps, and not doing so, would be to remove those programs from half the people who rely on them.

Same here! My mother was the one who would sense into me about things when I was a kid, and now I am flabbergasted, wondering where the woman who raised me went. She reads nothing but really, really right-wing crap like this website called Conservative Treehouse, which I went to and came away feeling like I needed to bleach my brain! She brags about how she never looks at anything like the Washington Post, CNN, all MSM is propaganda, etc…Hell she even trash talks Fox and Rush somewhat, too. She is definitely driven by those “primitive emotional centers” you mentioned for sure.

And she grew up in the 1950s in Statesboro, GA, when segregation was normal, and she will contradict her own self about things she told me years ago about all that. She used to talk about how unfair it was and how she felt sorry for black people she knew back then. Now, it’s all about how they all got along it was all just fine and the white kids would all go to the black high school’s homecoming parade on Main Street and everybody would dance and laugh and have a great time. Well, when I try to point out to her that 1) that’s not jiving with what you said 25 years ago, and 2) you have to temper those memories with the fact that you were seeing all that through the eyes of a child and there very well could have been a whole lot going on you were totally unaware of, she dismisses all that as hokum and when did I become such a bleeding heart liberal?

The littlest bit of challenge and/or disagreement sends her into a slobbering fit.

About 1/3 of my Facebook acquaintances are politically conservative, and maybe 100 of them are Republicans. Most (~90%) are decent folks. There are some who are unreasonable or narrow-minded, but most are decent, caring, try-to-make-the-world-a-better-place people, and a sizable number of them donate or give of their time and resources a considerable lot.

The mistake you are making here is your assumption that Congressional Republicans are afraid of their own constituency. They’re not. They’re afraid of their big money donors like the Kochs and Mercers, who have come right out and told them that if they don’t get tax reform done (and previously health care), the wide open money tap that helps to elect them will close. The Kochs and the Mercers, among others – all of whom have a very great deal to do with where we are politically today – are rather nakedly running things now, not even trying much to hide it. Their influence is everywhere.

GOP Donors Threaten to Withhold Funds Unless Their Agenda is Passed Salon

Koch Urgency: Conservative Network Fears Closing Window Associated Press via Yahoo News

A sampling of Koch Brothers’ influence:

Mapping the Koch Brothers’ Massive Political Network WaPo

Heritage Foundation - Kochs
American Enterprise Institute - Kochs
Cato Institute - Kochs
Club for Growth - Kochs
Americans for Prosperity - Kochs
Americans for Tax Reform - Kochs
Concerned Women for American Action - Kochs
Concerned Veterans for America - Kochs
NOVA on PBS - Kochs
Mike Pence - Kochs
Many other Republican candidates - Kochs

Koch money was almost single handedly responsible for the Tea Party.

Similarly, Mercer Influence in 2016 Election Chicago Tribune

Breitbart “News” - Mercers
Steve Bannon - Mercers
KellyAnne Conway - Mercers
Neil Gorsuch - Mercers
Paul Ryan - Mercers
Ted Cruz - Mercers
Cambridge Analytica - Mercers
Citizens United - Mercers
Media Research Center - Mercers
Government Accountability Institute - Mercers
Making American Great - Mercers
America First Policies - Mercers

Again, this is just a sampling. Their money infests everything in our political landscape today. The voters are pretty much beside the point.

What’s especially sad is, many Republicans actually believe the “policies” they espouse are actually their own ideas of principled political “thinking.” They are not aware that these notions have been instilled into them by the propaganda constantly emanating from the disingenuous groups listed above who seek only to advance their own selfish agendas. Brainwashing at its finest.

In response to the OP, I do have a hard time accepting Republican voters as decent people lately.

I’ve had respectful (on my part) conversations with them in an attempt to learn what drives their views. In response, I get parroted talking points that all sound exactly the same. In times past when my dad and I would have political discussions, I was so disappointed to learn his views were merely the very same views I had already heard from every other Fox “News” subscriber I knew. He wasn’t any longer bringing critical thought to what he was being told. He didn’t any longer challenge the veracity of his opinions by seeking out additional information or critically examine the sources – or the agendas – of the information he had blindly accepted.

I am also dismayed to see the extent to which he now dehumanizes those who disagree with his cherished Republican Party lines. Like k9bfriender’s father attributing a goofy “friendship” with Dennis Rodman to him, my father likewise impugns me with cartoonish characteristics of “libruls” which he must know on some level to be untrue of me. That’s a little scary.

I have lost a lot of respect for Republican-leaning persons who now subscribe to this rabid incarnation of blind, liberal hatred. The divide is truly divisive: It has cost me some friendships, strained relations with family members and caused a great deal of sorrow.

In my opinion, if we don’t get this heavy money out of our politics, we are truly doomed.

I concur with you on all this, and guess I didn’t mean to imply it was necessarily liberals “punishing” them. And by punishing I meant by making them the constant butt of jokes, etc… they are indeed ignorant, but they know they being made fun of regularly by comedians, in movies, on late night tv, etc…

AND it is the great paradox of what you say that I can get in my car right now and drive 10 miles into the country into poor white territory and see Trump signs in the yard. They can’t understand they have voted against their own best interests and they have aligned themselves with rich white people who don’t care about them. They truly believe the Democrats don’t want them. I have heard people say this shit. “Well they don’t want nobody that looks like me. I ain’t special interest quota enough for 'em!” Granted, it is an asinine statement, but they realy believe that.

To be fair, there is indeed a sizable contingent of the political left that says just that, especially among Millenials.

https://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2016-11-14/actually-democrats-you-don-t-need-those-white-men

Thank you for this! I am saving your post. This does make total sense to me and it is nice to have it all in one place.

What would you say are the major influencers on the Democratic side? I am not being flippant, I just want to know, because I think it is pretty safe to say Big Money has infiltrated both parties. I would be interested on your take on that.

And I see this as part of the problem too. :frowning: This is exactly the kind of thing that will get picked up and passed around by the likes of Sean Hannity. :rolleyes:

And coming from Slate and Bloomberg, it doesn’t surprise me. I read a wide range of news, listen to tons of NPR. It takes a lot of work to be an informed person these days, and yes, folks, you have to get out of your comfort zone and listen to and read things outside of your wheelhouse, lol! I told my sister to just consider it like you are spying on the other side…whatever it takes, just pull your head out of the rabbit hole! I promise you won’t die if you look at “the liberal media”, and you might actually, um… learn something?

Interesting analyses in this thread on the psychological differences between conservatives and liberals.

I would summarize it the way Philip K. Dick did: It’s a struggle between neophiles, those who embrace change and generally support it, and neophobes, those who fear change and generally oppose it.

I agree that liberals and progressives tend to be those for whom the system *hasn’t worked. They more readily embrace change because they acknowledge there are significant problems in the system. Conservatives, on the other hand, tend to want to halt change. Things are okay now, why change them? In fact, things were even better ten years ago, or 20 years ago, or in the 1950’s. Maybe we should roll back some of the changes that were made? They must be the reason things got worse.

As far as Trump goes, I strongly disagree with everyone here in decoupling him from the Republican Party. Yes, he’s different on a superficial level; he’s a habitual con-man with his businesses, he lies incessantly and transparently, he never admits he’s wrong, he bullies anyone he disagrees with, he has no empathy, he has no self-reflection. But those are all his words; in terms of his policy, he is indistinguishable from a rank-and-file Republican:

  1. Abolishing social safety programs: Check. His attack on the ACA involved a 700 Billion dollar cut to Medicaid. He’s in favor of cutting food stamps to fund his border wall.
  2. Tax cuts for the rich and corporations: Check. His ACA bill involved cutting an exceptional amount of taxes on the rich, solely for the purpose of removing healthcare from the poor. His “tax reform” is another tax cut for the rich. He’s specifically bragging about abolishing the estate tax, which only applies to individuals with $5.5 million or more and couples with $11 million or more, cutting taxes on pass-through income which only applies to large corporations, and lowering the top tax rate from 39% to 34%.
  3. Bloating the military: Check. He asked for a military increase of $52 billion/year - he got $89 billion/year, with no public debate or delays. On top of the current ~ $550 billion/year.
  4. Border security / attacking immigrants: Check. Building a wall, deporting, passing “travel bans.”

The only significant policy difference between Trump, and the standard Republican stance, is that Trump has all the subtlety of a rhino in a china shop. When he talks about immigrants, he doesn’t cloak it in border security, he says “they’re criminals, they’re rapists, some I assume are good people.” When he talks about tax cuts, he doesn’t cloak it in flowery rhetoric about trickle-down economics and unleashing the juggernaut of the American economy. He talks about how his corporate friends will benefit from it, how terribly unfair it is his billionaire friends have to pay taxes, and tells transparent lies about “the highest taxes in history.”

When he pimps the military, he doesn’t quietly add it to a budget proposal, he goes on network TV and talks about “rebuilding our military,” as though we had allowed our ranks to dwindle to a hundred soldiers and a few M-15s, instead of already having the largest military ever assembled in the history of mankind.

If you got out of those articles that liberals “don’t want nobody that looks like me.” then you didn’t read them very well. They are more a resignation that, in order to move forward, while having white guys would be nice, statistically, the are not necessary to win.

This is the closest quote I could find in the slate piece to what you said.

I’m a white guy, and I’ve never been made to feel as thought the left did not want me. But then, I get nuance, and would not take that quote as a personal attack on myself and upon my demographic, and then claim that they say they don’t want me.

The other piece is similar, in saying that those votes are not needed in order to build a coalition, and so if white men choose to go a different way, if they choose to follow the conservative path, then expending efforts trying to get them to change their minds may be a waste.

That is utterly different than your claim that they are saying that they “don’t want nobody that looks like me”.

Not directed at me, but I can answer. One of the biggest things that pushed me away from ultra conservative reactionary that I was raised to be was fox news itself. I would watch it like a good conservative, but it wouldn’t make any sense. They would make claims that didn’t seem backed by facts, conclusions that did not follow from their own narratives, and overall debased themselves and impugned their own integrity. I went from hating Bill Clinton with a passion for all the evil that he did, to asking, “Umm, what evil again?”

Then when Bush was president, and fox news couldn’t stop fawning over him, even as he fucked up left and right, the dissonance was just too much for me. I never got into other cable news channels as much as I did fox. I watched a bit of MSNBC, but certainly not religiously, the “jon stewart show” was entertaining, but I didn’t become a regular watcher until his last couple years. I don’t feel I was indoctrinated into moving to the left by any sort of persuasion or propaganda, I feel I was shoved away from the right by their own hypocrisy.

Someone said that anyone who isn’t a liberal when they are young has no heart, and anyone who isn’t a conservative in their older ages has no brains. As a middle aged white guy who leans liberal, I disagree entirely. I would say that anyone who isn’t a liberal when they are young has no curiosity about the world, and anyone who isn’t a conservative in their older age has kept their curiosity about the world.

If Trump had been a life-long active Republican and if he had been elected only because of an overwhelmingly huge turn-out of registered Republicans I could probably project my hatred to anyone from that party. Since that wasn’t the case I’ll just disagree with them as I normally would and not hold the current situation against the general rank and file.