There are some of us, who are not Orthodox Jews, who keep the Sabbath in our own ways. For example, I won’t do work on the Sabbath, but it’s work as I define it- basically, anything connected to my job, house or yard work, errands, or driving (except to synagogue). I will turn lights on and off (in fact, I will blow out the Sabbath candles before we go to bed, because curious cats and unattended candles aren’t a good mix), watch TV, or play computer games. Under the Orthodox rules, I’d be permitted to read a book for my work, but under my rules, I’m not.
And yes, having sex on the Sabbath is not only permitted, there’s a long tradition of encouraging it. If you find it to be work, you’re probably doing it wrong ![]()
[QUOTE=The Scrivener]
A few years ago, an Orthodox (or perhaps Conservative)'s house in, IIRC, Brooklyn, caught fire because the gas stove was still on when Sabbath commenced, and nobody dared turn it off. (I wonder why they couldn’t ask a gentile person to come and turn the gas off.) The heat built up over the Sabbath night and day to a point where the wood cabinets over the stove caught fire. IIRC, nobody was injured and the whole house didn’t burn down, but there was extensive damage to the kitchen.
How do such Jews weigh the potentially catastrophic outcome in such a case vs. the burden of committing a Sabbath infraction – especially when the catastrophe might jeopardize the lives of others (in this case, any neighbors)? You’d think there’d be some sort of “mea culpa” ritual, ablution, prayer, charitable deed or somesuch offering absolution to those who have deliberately committed a Sabbath infraction, but regret it.
[/QUOTE]
No, Jewish law in fact requires you to break the Sabbath laws if someone’s life might be endangered by following them (and I would say something that might start a fire would qualify, though IANARabbi). The only Jewish laws you’re not allowed to break to save a life are the ones against murder (you can’t kill an innocent person to save your own life, though you can kill in self-defense), adultery (though you’re not required to resist rape to the point of death), and idolatry (you can’t worship another god if someone is threatening to kill you unless you do).
There’s no ritual of penance or anything like that for breaking the Sabbath- you just sincerely regret doing it, and try not to do it again. Fasting on Yom Kippur is supposed to atone for sins like this, between people and God (you have to try to undo the harm you did if you committed a sin between yourself and another person, if possible). But you still fast on Yom Kippur even if you can’t remember committing any specific sins between you and God, so it’s not exactly a ritual of penance for some specific sin.