Doom 3 was disappointing, but fun. The environments are what made the game for me… everyone kept saying how it was all the same throughout, but for some reason, I found a very eclectic mix of designs, all under the umbrella of an overarching theme (it’s a Martian research base… what do you expect?). But every room in Doom 3 feels like it has a purpose, a point, and it’s not just another generic room with five or six monsters inside. Unique pieces of machinery everywhere, not the same five or six doodads repeated endlessly throughout the game.
Here’s the game’s weakness: No outdoors, no mobs. Sure, there are a few moments when you go outside, and even a few moments when you do battle outside… but it should have been expanded. They should have made the air tanks another item like the flashlight… give your suit five minutes of oxygen, and when you start running low, you plug in another tank.
The mobs, though… that’s what’s missing. The original Doom followed the same format as Doom 3… you pick up an item, spawn an enemy. Go through a door, spawn an enemy. Except in the original Doom, it was more like “spawn six or seven enemies at once”… or in a few points, spawn an entire HORDE of enemies. Fuck, who’s picked up the Red Key only to see thirty or forty Pinky demons charging at you seconds later?
I’d like to see Doom 4 copy the same story of Doom 2, and the format… more expansive, open areas to complement the claustrophobic level design, more enemies at once, squad combat… hell, you spend the first quarter of Doom 3 trying to hook up with Bravo Team, and you never get a payoff! What the fuck?
I DID like a lot of the little touches that iD added to the game, however. The introduction of the Lost Soul monsters. The Bathroom Mirror (if you know, I don’t need to elaborate). The utter silence of the Lambda complex… I mean, the Delta complex when you first arrive. Hell. Your return from hell, finding the base even MORE overridden, bloody, demolished, and trashed… as if things couldn’t get any worse…
The end boss is fuckin’ pussy, though. Damn.
I was similarly disappointed by Half-Loadtimes 2 and Far Cry.