EA Sports Screws PC Gamers (Again)

As an avid PC sports gamer, I should be used to this by now. The ritual of humiliation and self-abasement that is part and parcel of dealing with the avaricious thugs at EA Sports to get my semi-annual fix. It all started (for me) back in the mists of time known as the early 90s, when my platform of choice was the vaunted SNES.

Back then, the yearly editions of the EA Sports franchise (Madden 9x, NHL 9x, NBA Live! 9x) actually showed marked improvement in the games themselves from year to year. For example, I can still remember how cool it was when one-timers made their first appearance in NHL 94, and how full season play was introduced the following year. Sure, there were no other games for which you paid for a new version every year, but it was OK, because the games, by and large, were the best of their genre at the time.

Fast forward 15 years to 2008. I have moved on from the SNES, to the PS1, to the Dreamcast (don’t ask why), and, exclusively for the last 8 years, the PC. In the meantime, EA Sports has gone from good to mediocre to poor. I first started noticing in the late 90s that the amount and/or significance of new features added to the title of the year was steadily dropping, to the point where the game often felt the same as last year’s edition, with only updated rosters. Even worse, the quality control became abysmal, with game-breaking bugs upon release increasingly the norm, and patches slow to come by. Lately, they don’t even try to make versions designed specifically for the PC, instead clumsily porting over the PS2 or Xbox iteration. But at least there were still games to complain about, and very often the on-line fan communities would devise clever tweaks that made the game run well, if not optimally. Until now.

Cued in by the link in Justin Bailey’s signature, I’ve just discovered that EA Sports will, for the first time since the inception of the franchise, not be making a version of Madden 09 for the PC. Mind you, if this was, say… 1997, it wouldn’t be that big of a deal. I’d just by another NFL game. The thing is, in 2008, there won’t be any other NFL game, because those motherfuckers at EA hold an exclusive license. Listen how Peter Moore, President of EA Sports, justifies his decision:

I should have seen this coming. I still tenderly clutch my copy of MVP 2005 (baseball), as it was the last MLBPA-licensed game to be released for the PC (EA holds a similar exclusive license with regard to MLB). But Madden has consistently been the flagship of the whole EA Sports brand, widely out-selling their other games on a yearly basis, and I figured that no matter how half-ass of a job they did on it, there would always be Madden for the PC.

Just to make it explicit, in case it wasn’t crystal clear, EA has an exclusive time-limited license to produce officially licensed NFL games for the PC, for which they presumably paid a not insignificant amount of money, which they are not using. Now, I have some understanding of this on a business level (EA is nothing if not skilled at enriching its stockholders), but on a purely emotional level (these are games, after all) I have to say that this really, really sucks. As such, please allow me to express my frustration via the admittedly juvenile act of paraphrasing Mr. Moore’s remarks:

as committed as a gaming company can be, without actually releasing games

as demonstrated by our incompetence…

…because you losers can’t take the hint and buy a PS3 already

we’re working on an unholy combination of sports and MMORPG’s, because fisting you once a year isn’t quite often enough

because we’re out of ideas

unless you’re hankering for Bocce Ball 09

just buy a PS3 already, loser!

I feel your pain man even though I’m not much of a fan of PC sports game. With the exception of FIFA. I have FIFA '08 and besides a new roster and a different color menu screen I really don’t see the difference between '08 and '07. They pretty much ripped us off for what amounts to a patch to FIFA '07.

I like Madden, but I simply don’t know if I’m getting it this year. It didn’t amaze me last year and the resale for the game was almost nothing.

How large is the market for PC sports games anyway? Surely not large enough to invest the money reworking a multimillion dollar game so that it will work across an infinite number of system configurations. Why bother when they can just make 2 or 3 console versions that will work 100% of the time and sell several million copies each every year?

If I was EA I would abandon PC sports as well.

Sorry bub.

Yeah, I’m thinking I might pick up a soccer game as a quasi-substitute for my football jones. I’m in Europe anyway, so when in Rome…

I’ve heard that Pro Evolution Soccer is even better than FIFA '08, and doesn’t have that EA taint to it. I think I’ll check that one out.

Like I said in my OP, I understand their business reasons for not making Madden for the PC*, but the thing that sucks is, because their license is exclusive, no one else can step up to the plate and make their own NFL game. If this was 1997, I’d just go out and buy Front Page Sports Football. That is not an option now.
*Of course, if they hadn’t burned through all their good will with the fans with years of shoddy releases and lackluster support, then perhaps piracy wouldn’t be such a problem for their business model. Not that I support piracy - I legally purchase every game I play - but a look at Stardock’s business practices shows that companies can indeed make a lot of money selling PC games, even ones without copy protection.

What does piracy have anything to do with it? I mean, they’re PC sports games. I don’t think anyone was buying or pirating them!

Ouch! Low blow. Go back to your PS3, console-boy! :wink:

EA have been screwing the pooch on sports gaming, period, lately. They’re also working a hostile takeover against Take Two Interactive to get their filthy, grubby hands on the publishing rights for Grand Theft Auto IV, with the side benefit of taking over their only major competition for sports games.

Edit: Kudos to the Take Two guys for setting up a poison pill counter to the takeover; the creative industry will take a hit if Take Two is incorporated into the EA behemoth and even the stock holders will have to think twice when letting the takeover take place means the Take Two creative talent will leave with 6 months of 1.5x pay. (And the management will leave with 18 months of 2.5x pay)

Hey Fuji, I’m glad my little site could be of use. It’s only six days old and I have a good feeling about it.

But I think I have to side with the rest here who think this move makes perfect sense from a business perspective. PC-only gamers are a dwindling breed and PC-only gamers who like sports games are an even smaller subset. I’m sorry you fall into this category.

But do you have anything against console gaming? I find (and I imagine I’m not alone) that playing sports games on a PC with a keyboard is not as much fun as using a controller.

Oh, and I just thought I should mention this. EA doesn’t hold the exclusive MLB rights, Take-Two does. And they only hold the third-party rights, so Microsoft, Nintendo or Sony could make an MLB-licensed game if they wanted to. But only Sony chooses to. Take-Two has also never published a baseball game for the PC.

Microsoft actually owns the rights to the High Heat Baseball series, but hasn’t done anything with it ever.

Honestly sports games are more fun on a couch in front of a big TV.

Of course for die-hard sports fans, the PC could offer some very interesting simulation possibilities, but I doubt if that development would pay off financially for a big lumbering company like EA.

Every time someone says this, I look at my PC, hooked up to my TV with HDMI, wireless joypad/keyboard/mouse, and surround sound via SPDIF to my receiver.

Why AREN’T you playing PC games from your couch?

Cuz my 42" Samsung plasma only does a brain-dead 1024x768 widescreen resolution.

But that’s just my situation, I think PC games could move to the living room IF the game makers get together and standardize their controls and tighten up the games so they run well on all systems right out of the box.

Wish it would happen on Linux too, Windows unfortunately is starting to lose it’s way.

If that’s your setup, then playing on a PC or console is cosmetic at that point.

One of us. One of us. One of us.

Porting a game to a different platform is non-trivial exercise. Porting to PC is particularly bad because there are so many different hardware configurations you have to support.

It a simple business decision. Will sales on the platform pay for the port? If not, no port.

(It’s actually a little more complicated. It’s not just a question of if the port will make back it’s investment. It’s a question of how to make the best use of scarce development resources. Will you make more money porting Madden to PC, or using that development team to work on a NEW game for XBox 360/PlayStation 3?)

And, PC games tend to have lower prices; for example on Amazon.com Unreal Tournament 3 PC sells for $34, the PS3 version sells for $52!

But, as mentioned in this thread, there’s still LOTS of PC games coming out.

If I didn’t have a $1500 pc for hobbyist non-gaming purposes, I would be more interested in consoles. As it is, I have the PC and the Wii (and the PS2, but it’s feeding (legally owned) games off the PC hard drive via hdloader anyway–the dvd drive kicked it two years ago)

Aside: 3d rendering/art programs are gorgeous in 1080p.

Keep up the good work!

Nothing against console gaming, per se, but not in my situation. I’m an American living in Europe, and it’s my understanding that consoles here are set up for PAL, and would therefore be useless back in the States with NTSC. Plus, everything here is more expensive. And, I just dropped about €400 upgrading my PC to a dual-core gaming rig. Finally, there’s the fact that I’m more of a simluation-style gamer anyway, and EA always screws up the “realism” settings every year, and with the PC, I can download a mod to patch the game to a reasonable standard. With a console, I’m stuck with no game editing.

I didn’t know that. Of course, Microsoft sucks on an even greater scale than EA, so we won’t go into that right now…