This is not uncommon. Did you have an experience with a bad beer at some time in the past, or did you instead have a preconceived idea of how beer would taste? If it wasa bad experience, do you remember the brand, by chance?
Silenus is correct above. I’d like to add that some beer drinkers really like hops a lot, and for them, beer isn’t beer if hops isn’t the dominant taste. You sound like you’re more like me – not a fan of the bitter hops flavor, but a fan of a solid malt flavor that can compete, or even overbear, the flavor of hops.
A style.
One thing to point out – beers do differ by color, but the color of a beer is not correlated with either the fullness of taste or the alcohol content of a beer. That is, a dark beer is not necessarily more flavorful than a golden-colored beer (i.e. a dark beer can still be swill), nor is it necessarily a stronger drink.
Beers obtain their color by how much roasting is done to the grain before it is used to make beer. Highly-roasted grain will yield a dark colored beer … and lightly-roasted grain will yield a pale golden beer. Now then … with any random dark beer, you will normally taste something quite different from a typical light colored lager, but there’s no guarantee that the dark beer will taste good.
Among most all beer critics (and armchair “beer snobs”), there are two factors that can mark a beer as subpar:
-
use of a proportion of cheap and/or poorly processed grains like rice and corn (prevalent in mass-produced American brews) instead of using exclusively barley or wheat.
-
overuse of hops to mask a weak or bad malt flavor. Also a feature of your Buds, Millers, and Coors, but also of most of the weaker European labels (Heineken, Beck).
I don’t personally feel that one has to make this complicated. Some will say that a malty, dark beer goes with red meat, and that a lighter, hoppier beer should go with chicken or fish.
What I find is that most any beer that I’d care to drink serves more or less as a palate cleanser from which to partake every few bites of a meal. The idea is that the beer should be a refreshing accompaniment … but not something that you keep on tasting while eating your actual entree. There are a few beers that I enjoy alone that are so strong of taste that, for me, they make a poor choice for a meal-accompaniment beer (e.g. double bocks, lambics).