So I recently ate a warning for saying that certain folks who defended Edward Gallagher are “deserving of harm”.
To quote Bone:
In my defense: neither is anything about this situation. So you’ll have to excuse me if I feel like the people making bullshit, disgusting, dishonest excuses for the racist serial murderer and the president pardoning him deserve slightly less than kind treatment.
Fucking hell, I’m trying to imagine hearing this news and not being outraged. I’m trying to imagine the kind of headspace that would lead one to defend this person, or this decision. Every time I put myself in that headspace, it inevitably leads to one of two thoughts:
- “Gallagher? That was that dude who got stuck on an island for 3 seasons, right?” (I’m just assuming this is where D’Anconia is at, although if the sniveling little shit would like to correct me, by all means, fam, knock yourself out.)
or
- “Wow, I’m just straight-up kind of a nazi”.
And you know what they say about what qualifies as a “good” nazi.
I mean, think it through. Really think it through. What does pardoning this guy actually achieve? If you’re not his immediate family, in which case, fine, you have some excuse (although last I checked even the family of serial killers usually come to reality at some point), what possible purpose does this serve? What message does it send?
Maybe it’s about how murdering the right kind of people is okay. That’s fucking disgusting, and also didn’t we recently have Trump saying we should shoot immigrants?
Maybe it’s about how Iraqis don’t have rights. Again: fucking disgusting, a racist blot on humanity, the kind of person we collectively decided we needed to put down even before we found the death camps.
Maybe it’s about how the army is above scrutiny and doesn’t deserve punishment for even the most gross misconduct. Well shit, that is a convenient memo to pass on… to the fucking Schutzstaffel!
Is it against the rules to state that Nazis are deserving of harm? Because “Nazis are deserving of harm” is basically the guiding rule behind every piece of WWII media written since the 40s, the main reason Inglorious Basterds is framed as a movie about heroic insurgents and not psychopathic serial murderers, the main reason WWII shooters are so morally uncomplicated, extremely good advice for literally anyone, et cetera. Killing Nazis isn’t just “not a bad thing”, it’s so morally uncomplicated that we accept it writ large as a baseline for our media, to the point where the person trying to humanize and sympathize with the nazis comes off looking fucking suspect as hell!
And this decision is really fucking hard to defend without being a nazi.
So fuck Edward Gallagher.
Fuck anyone who would defend Edward Gallagher.
Fuck anyone who would defend the asshole pardoning Edward Gallagher.
America is sliding towards fascism. These people are helping it on its merry way. I have no patience for them, and I refuse to acknowledge their basic humanity until they are willing to acknowledge the basic humanity of his countless innocent victims.