I just watched The End of Oak Street the other day and wanted to discuss the implications of the ending and time travel mechanics…which is impossible to do without spoiling the ending. So be warned.
I’m not going to summarize the movie. But here is the question:
In the epilogue, we see two Jeannettes.
Jeannette 1 who survived and escaped the events of Oak Street to warn her family and
Jeannette 2 who did not experience the event other than inexplicably being warned by herself from an hour or so into the future.
Similarly the Platt family is reunited at the end…sort of.
Denise Platt 1 and her Children 1 who escaped the events with Dave 2 who was warned by Denise 1 before the event (from Dave 2’s POV).
Dave 1 was killed by a dinosaur protecting his family and we can assume the rest of Dave 2’s family were killed after the event occurs.
So here’s the questions:
Which Jeannette is the “real” one? Both?
Is Dave 2 the same person as the now deceased Dave 1?
Before you answer too hastily, consider this. The movie canon specifically indicates multiple instances of people can exist at the same time in the same place.
Dave 2 did not experience the same events Dave 1 did before he died. He simply received a call from his wife shortly before his town vanished. He did not reconcile with his wife, participate in the photo of Dave 1 with some dinosaurs humping, or die protecting his family. In fact, one could argue that his actual family probably died after the event.
Both Jeanette’s are real, one is just a day or so older and significantly more traumatized. The two Dave’s would be very different people for not having experienced what the other went through, and I feel that ultimately Denise would not want to stay with the Dave she saved as he is not the one she reconciled with.
Yeah it’s presented as this “yay happy ending, the family is all together again!” yet he’s in exactly the same place he was before the events happened, so none of their problems have been reconciled and he has not changed or grown at all.