[QUOTE=xiix]
From the Wiki article on Sherron Watkins that samclem linked:
So the question remains: if Ms. Watkins didn’t provide the info to the outside world, how did it escape?
[/QUOTE]
Enron published it.
Seriously. The information about the Special Purpose Entities were to be found in the regularly filed Annual Reports, proxies, and various other regulatory filings required by the SEC all throughout the 1990s. For example, a 1999 proxy filing by Enron stated flatly that Andrew Fastow was the “senior executive” who was running the off-book SPE’s, which in that year was responsible for 40% of all Enron earnings.
However, the financial press and Clinton’s SEC could be, at best, charitably described as cheerleaders, not regulators. There was a boom on, nobody wanted to spoil the party, and since earnings were going up up up, and since we were in a “New Economy”, such paltry things like financial statements were ignored… even disdained.
The first article that can be determined to be the first true chink in the Enron armor was written in February 19th, 2001 by Fortune magazine writer Bethany MacLean entitled “IS ENRON OVERPRICED?” In it, she essentially asked the question “How does Enron make its money?”
However, it really wasn’t until Skilling started to crack in March 2001 that people really began nosing around. Calling a man who ran a hedge fund an “asshole” in a quarterly earnings conference call didn’t help, nor did his increasingly erratic behavior in the weeks prior to his resignation. When he did resign, he screwed the pooch by first insisting it was for personal reasons, only to mess up the tale by openly admitting to the Wall Street Journal that he resigned because of depression caused by the sinking stock price (which confused the reporters… until they realized the pressure on Skilling was excaberated by the impact the falling prices was having on the entire Enron financial house of cards).
By then, with a falling market, accounting problems at other companies that were appearing at the same time, and a new SEC chief, the press started doing what it stopped doing right about the time the Netscape IPO occurred: it started being business watchdogs again. They picked up those old financial statements and began reading them.
And it took about a month for it all to fall apart.
I find the Enron story to be fascinating, one of those elephants that everybody describes differently. A poster above mentioned Eichenwald’s Conspiracy of Fools, but another honest (and completely opposing) take on the story can be found in MacLean’s The Smartest Guys in the Room. (I tend towards the Eichenwald version: it tends to ring true with my experiences in business in general, and I trust the writer more given my reading of their other works.)