Ever eat eelpout, the poor man's lobster?

A few years ago, a friend of mine had an ice-fishing trip to Lake Winnebigosh. He was taken out to a little cabin on the ice with a yard-square fishing hole. The guide had told them “You can catch walleye and big perch, but if you start catching eelpout, they’re going to grab all your lures before the walleyes see them.” The eelpout, a stout fish, was described as “the poor man’s lobster” for the tender, buttery flesh.

Was that puffery, or are eelpout really that tasty? I saw some pictures, and they’re certainly not a pretty fish. Is it worth asking for, if I travel in that area?

I can not answer your question personally, but here’s a site that you may find of interest.

Egad, that’s an ugly fish. Another one described as “poor man’s lobster,” and equally as pretty, is monkfish. I can say that monkfish is quite delish.

I luvs me some monkfish. Definitely qualifies as poor man’s lobster. Definitely an uggggly fish.

Apparently monkfish tails used to be cut into small pieces, battered and passed off as scampi.

Q: How do you make an eelpout?
A: Shut off his electricity.

Eh, by the way, anyone know what Tilapia tastes like? I’ve never tried it, but I know it is a pretty popular commercial fish on the current market.

The reason I ask is because there’s a manmade lake here (FL) filled with Tilapia. I saw someone catch a full stringer of them a couple days ago. He must have had about twenty 2-4lb. fish! You gotta snag them though, they are not baited (Herbivirous).

Might give it a shot, again (last time I tried I only snagged a small catfish.)

I’ve had eel… Perhaps that’s a poor man’s eelpout?

It doesn’t have a particularly strong flavor but I like it. I typically bake it with some spices and it turns out ok. I imagine you could fry it in various ways as well if that’s what you’re in to.

The poor man’s lobster. Heh, I wish I was old enough to remember when lobster was the poor man’s lobster.

Marc

I had some over the weekend. I would not be able to tell the difference between farm raised tilapia and farm raised catfish in a blind test.

I was gonna make that exact same comment.

At least I got to see a picture of a monkfish. A thread is not wasted if it affords a view of something ugly enough to have grossed out a dinosaur.

Bland, mostly tasteless, sort of with a chalky texture. It’s buffet fodder where I live.

A law back in colonial days forbade people to make their servants eat lobster and turtle too often. Seems they were common, “trash” foods at the time.

Tilapia is a mild fish with firm flesh that will withstand a variety of cooking methods. It takes on the flavor of whatever you cook it with. I made some the other night that was incredibly tasty. I will be happy to share the recipe if you would like.

Sure, a recipe would be great.
Would it hold up on a grill, too?

Yes, it can be grilled.

Recipe - Season your filets with salt and pepper and saute with onion and garlic til fish is almost cooked through. Remove from skillet and add spinach, artichoke hearts, sun-dried tomatoes, roasted peppers and lemon juice. Heat through and add filets back to skillet. Continue cooking until fish is done.

Easy, healthy and oh so yummy.