So, some thoughts about the way I interpret Exalted psychology, and Dhorain in specific.
In Exalted, Virtues have concrete existence. No matter how you come about your Valor or Compassion or Conviction (or lack thereof), your abundance of the Virtue (or its lack) has tangible, measurable affects on your actions.
Now, Dhorain has deliberately lopsided Virtue scores. The way I’ve been seeing him is having essentially three personalities. His first personality is effectively an entirely constructed personality. He was told that it’s good and correct to care about people, and keep your word, and be a good citizen, and so forth. While he’s operating in this mode, he’s using his stunted Compassion and Conviction scores.
Poke him a bit, and you get a brash, impulsive, arrogant, violent youth; that’s who’s mostly been talking during his in-character bits. In this mode, Dhorain is proud but practical; he really likes finding situations involving hitting bad people, but also has care for his own honor, and to a lesser extent, his own well-being.
Underneath that, you have his Valor and Temperance. This is basically an aimable psychopath/sociopath personality. While acting in this mode (which is basically his Limit Break) he identifies his greatest adversary, attacks it directly until it’s gone or he is, then moves on to the next.
If Dhorain had more of a stable personality, or didn’t have such extreme differences between the two pairs of virtues, I figure he’d have a more integrated mindset. As it is, I plan on playing the influence of his high-value virtues as literal voices in his head. Only wrinkle is, they’re all his voice, just urging him to do different things at different times.