I know my opinion is not the popular one but, for me, Day of the Dead is the perfect Zombie and Horror film.
In general terms it’s bleak, nihilistic, miserable, hopeless and depicts humans (us, the viewers) losing the fight against the threat. That’s horror.
The gore special effects are very well done. They all look a bit familiar now (and I am not claiming Day of the Dead pioneered any of them) but it’s always disappointing watching a horror film with really obvious fake effects.
In my opinion no one in the film acts out of character or does anything really stupid - other than where they have stupidity as a defining characteristic. Indeed all the characters are following their own clear motivations - even though they tend to be ultimately unhelpful.
So you have a few ‘civilians’ caught up in it. They tend to be the mechanism allowing us to see the situation which has a world being lost to Zombies and two disparate factions:
You have the soldiers who are transitioning from traditional military ‘loyally following orders’ towards ‘getting ready to mutiny’ and are a constant powder keg of pent up violence.
You have the scientists with good intentions, looking for a solution to the Zombie plague, but amorally and misguided, experimenting on dead soldiers. Although this is not known by the soldiers because that would push the soldiers over the edge.
The utter bleakness has the scientists actually onto something as they demonstrate one zombie is showing the possibility of being domesticated. While the soldiers are not impressed and not supportive of this potential breakthrough adding weight to the idea the humans are worse than the Zombies.
I could go on but for me it’s just a solid slice of Zombie Horror. Sets out to, and for me succeeds in doing this, showing how the end game of the Zombie Apocalypse is played out and, spoiler, it’s terrible.
By comparison I don’t like Night of the Living Dead because the black and white filming and cheap gore effects don’t work for me. Plus the characters just seem confused - which is probably what most people would be like if the dead suddenly came to life - which leaves me underwhelmed. I do like the bleak, black humour in the ending.
Dawn of the Dead is very good. The effects are good enough. There’s so many interesting ideas (professional squads trying to clear buildings - although it’s not REALLY clear why living relatives would be so devoted to their former loved ones, the clueless ‘Good Old Boys’ sniping at Zombies in the fields thinking it’s all a game plus the intelligent idea of setting up in a shopping mall.) My objection to the film is I never liked the how and why of a roving motorcycle gang simply riding up to destroy everything. Seemed like it was just bolted on to the film to create a big action set piece. Another satisfyingly bleak ending though.
TCMF-2L