Final Round -- Best All-Time TV Show

Variety shows (Carol Burnett, SNL)
Talk shows (David Frost, Johnny Carson)
Documentaries (World War I, The Valiant Years)
Costume dramas (Poldark; I, Claudius)
Thrillers (Alfred Hitchcock, Tales of the Unexpected)
Superheroes (The Adventures of Superman; Batman)

Also, according to decade.

Just how many new/other/additional polls are we looking at now? :slight_smile:

Enough to keep us busy for a while!

I’ll do a couple of my suggs after a little bit.

Can hardly wait! (pant, pant…)

It’s back to looking like a Top Half and Bottom Half thing to my eyes. Anybody else see something different here?


View Poll Results: What's the Best All-Time TV show?  
This poll will close on 10-31-2013 at 10:07 AM 

M*A*S*H            28 15.82% 
Breaking Bad       27 15.25% 
Seinfeld           18 10.17% 
The Simpsons       17 9.60% 
The Wire           17 9.60% 
Star Trek: TOS     14 7.91% 

Buffy              10 5.65% 
Doctor Who         10 5.65% 
The West Wing      10 5.65% 
Firefly             9 5.08% 
The Sopranos        9 5.08% 
Band of Brothers    8 4.52% 

Voters: 177 


I tried to vote, but did not find Curb Your Enthusiasm on the ballot.

It was in earlier threads. This is the last of a series of threads.

See Post #49 for the rationale behind this comparison:

Just now in this thread:



=============================================

View Poll Results: What's the Best All-Time TV show?  
This poll will close on 10-31-2013 at 10:07 AM 

M*A*S*H            29 15.76% 
Breaking Bad       28 15.22% 
Seinfeld           18 9.78% 
The Simpsons       17 9.24% 
The Wire           17 9.24% 
Star Trek: TOS     15 8.15% 

Doctor Who         13 7.07% 
Buffy              11 5.98% 
The West Wing      10 5.43% 
Firefly             9 4.89% 
The Sopranos        9 4.89% 
Band of Brothers    8 4.35% 

Voters: 184 

=============================================


The Best All-Time TV Show – UPDATE



=============================================

View Poll Results: What is the Best TV Show of All Time?  
This poll will close on 11-18-2013 at 12:06 PM 

The Simpsons                    19 9.74% 
The Wire                        19 9.74% 
Breaking Bad                    15 7.69% 
The Sopranos                    13 6.67% 
M*A*S*H                         12 6.15% 
Seinfeld                        10 5.13%   88

The West Wing                    9 4.62% 
Doctor Who                       9 4.62% 
Star Trek: TOS                   8 4.10% 
Firefly                          7 3.59% 
Buffy                            7 3.59% 
Band of Brothers                 6 3.08%   46

                                          134

The rest                                   61

Voters: 195



We’re 11 votes shy of this older poll’s participation.

Anybody want to offer an interpretation? :slight_smile:

Do not interpretations belong to God?

Your days are numbered. Your kingdom will be divided between the Medes and Persians.

sorry …

That is so close to what I had figured. We think too much alike.

Hey, one man’s Mede is another man’s Persian.

I’m going to guess that’s not original to you but either way it’s fucking genius.

Close to perfect, I will say!

The Intarweb is attributing it to Bennett Cerf, which sounds about right. Still, kudos to TOWP for a perfect delivery.

See? Now this makes all the other polls and this thread totally worthwhile!
Quite a long set up when you look at it that way…

How do you spell shaggy dog?

I read it in Asimov; can’t remember if he was referencing Cerf.

Voting has slowed down a lot and it may just be that we can’t make it to the 195 voters we had in the earlier “UPDATE” thread/poll. Just six votes away.

But I thought you might enjoy this comparison with how the votes have changed from when you had one choice out of 51 to when it was one out of 12.

I hope this makes sense without a lot of explanation:



http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/showthread.php?t=699986
The Best All-Time TV Show -- UPDATE 

View Poll Results: What is the Best TV Show of All Time?  
This poll will close on 11-18-2013 at 12:06 PM 

                                            View Poll Results: What's the Best All-Time TV show?  
                                            This poll will close on 10-31-2013 at 10:07 AM 

The Simpsons                    19 9.74%    The Simpsons       17 8.99%     -2
The Wire                        19 9.74%    The Wire           17 8.99%     -2
Breaking Bad                    15 7.69%    Breaking Bad       29 15.34%   +14
The Sopranos                    13 6.67%    The Sopranos        9 4.76%     -4
M*A*S*H                         12 6.15%    M*A*S*H            30 15.87%   +18
Seinfeld                        10 5.13%    Seinfeld           19 10.05%    +9 

The West Wing                    9 4.62%    The West Wing      11 5.82%     +2
Doctor Who                       9 4.62%    Doctor Who         13 6.88%     +4
Star Trek: TOS                   8 4.10%    Star Trek: TOS     15 7.94%     +7
Firefly                          7 3.59%    Firefly            10 5.29%     +3
Buffy                            7 3.59%    Buffy              11 5.82%     +4
Band of Brothers                 6 3.08%    Band of Brothers    8 4.23%     +2

Voters: 195                                 Voters: 189 

==========================================================================================

M*A*S*H                         12 6.15%    M*A*S*H            30 15.87%   +18
Breaking Bad                    15 7.69%    Breaking Bad       29 15.34%   +14
Seinfeld                        10 5.13%    Seinfeld           19 10.05%    +9 

Star Trek: TOS                   8 4.10%    Star Trek: TOS     15 7.94%     +7
Doctor Who                       9 4.62%    Doctor Who         13 6.88%     +4
Buffy                            7 3.59%    Buffy              11 5.82%     +4
Firefly                          7 3.59%    Firefly            10 5.29%     +3
The West Wing                    9 4.62%    The West Wing      11 5.82%     +2
Band of Brothers                 6 3.08%    Band of Brothers    8 4.23%     +2

The Simpsons                    19 9.74%    The Simpsons       17 8.99%     -2
The Wire                        19 9.74%    The Wire           17 8.99%     -2
The Sopranos                    13 6.67%    The Sopranos        9 4.76%     -4
Voters: 195                                 Voters: 189 

==========================================================================================



Surely there are five people who have yet to vote in this poll that closes in six days…

I’d be willing to bet that if you redo this poll in 5 years, Breaking Bad won’t make the Top 5, let alone be contending for #1. It’s way too soon for any evaluation of the show to be meaningful.