Variety shows (Carol Burnett, SNL)
Talk shows (David Frost, Johnny Carson)
Documentaries (World War I, The Valiant Years)
Costume dramas (Poldark; I, Claudius)
Thrillers (Alfred Hitchcock, Tales of the Unexpected)
Superheroes (The Adventures of Superman; Batman)
It’s back to looking like a Top Half and Bottom Half thing to my eyes. Anybody else see something different here?
View Poll Results: What's the Best All-Time TV show?
This poll will close on 10-31-2013 at 10:07 AM
M*A*S*H 28 15.82%
Breaking Bad 27 15.25%
Seinfeld 18 10.17%
The Simpsons 17 9.60%
The Wire 17 9.60%
Star Trek: TOS 14 7.91%
Buffy 10 5.65%
Doctor Who 10 5.65%
The West Wing 10 5.65%
Firefly 9 5.08%
The Sopranos 9 5.08%
Band of Brothers 8 4.52%
Voters: 177
See Post #49 for the rationale behind this comparison:
Just now in this thread:
=============================================
View Poll Results: What's the Best All-Time TV show?
This poll will close on 10-31-2013 at 10:07 AM
M*A*S*H 29 15.76%
Breaking Bad 28 15.22%
Seinfeld 18 9.78%
The Simpsons 17 9.24%
The Wire 17 9.24%
Star Trek: TOS 15 8.15%
Doctor Who 13 7.07%
Buffy 11 5.98%
The West Wing 10 5.43%
Firefly 9 4.89%
The Sopranos 9 4.89%
Band of Brothers 8 4.35%
Voters: 184
=============================================
The Best All-Time TV Show – UPDATE
=============================================
View Poll Results: What is the Best TV Show of All Time?
This poll will close on 11-18-2013 at 12:06 PM
The Simpsons 19 9.74%
The Wire 19 9.74%
Breaking Bad 15 7.69%
The Sopranos 13 6.67%
M*A*S*H 12 6.15%
Seinfeld 10 5.13% 88
The West Wing 9 4.62%
Doctor Who 9 4.62%
Star Trek: TOS 8 4.10%
Firefly 7 3.59%
Buffy 7 3.59%
Band of Brothers 6 3.08% 46
134
The rest 61
Voters: 195
We’re 11 votes shy of this older poll’s participation.
Voting has slowed down a lot and it may just be that we can’t make it to the 195 voters we had in the earlier “UPDATE” thread/poll. Just six votes away.
But I thought you might enjoy this comparison with how the votes have changed from when you had one choice out of 51 to when it was one out of 12.
I hope this makes sense without a lot of explanation:
http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/showthread.php?t=699986
The Best All-Time TV Show -- UPDATE
View Poll Results: What is the Best TV Show of All Time?
This poll will close on 11-18-2013 at 12:06 PM
View Poll Results: What's the Best All-Time TV show?
This poll will close on 10-31-2013 at 10:07 AM
The Simpsons 19 9.74% The Simpsons 17 8.99% -2
The Wire 19 9.74% The Wire 17 8.99% -2
Breaking Bad 15 7.69% Breaking Bad 29 15.34% +14
The Sopranos 13 6.67% The Sopranos 9 4.76% -4
M*A*S*H 12 6.15% M*A*S*H 30 15.87% +18
Seinfeld 10 5.13% Seinfeld 19 10.05% +9
The West Wing 9 4.62% The West Wing 11 5.82% +2
Doctor Who 9 4.62% Doctor Who 13 6.88% +4
Star Trek: TOS 8 4.10% Star Trek: TOS 15 7.94% +7
Firefly 7 3.59% Firefly 10 5.29% +3
Buffy 7 3.59% Buffy 11 5.82% +4
Band of Brothers 6 3.08% Band of Brothers 8 4.23% +2
Voters: 195 Voters: 189
==========================================================================================
M*A*S*H 12 6.15% M*A*S*H 30 15.87% +18
Breaking Bad 15 7.69% Breaking Bad 29 15.34% +14
Seinfeld 10 5.13% Seinfeld 19 10.05% +9
Star Trek: TOS 8 4.10% Star Trek: TOS 15 7.94% +7
Doctor Who 9 4.62% Doctor Who 13 6.88% +4
Buffy 7 3.59% Buffy 11 5.82% +4
Firefly 7 3.59% Firefly 10 5.29% +3
The West Wing 9 4.62% The West Wing 11 5.82% +2
Band of Brothers 6 3.08% Band of Brothers 8 4.23% +2
The Simpsons 19 9.74% The Simpsons 17 8.99% -2
The Wire 19 9.74% The Wire 17 8.99% -2
The Sopranos 13 6.67% The Sopranos 9 4.76% -4
Voters: 195 Voters: 189
==========================================================================================
I’d be willing to bet that if you redo this poll in 5 years, Breaking Bad won’t make the Top 5, let alone be contending for #1. It’s way too soon for any evaluation of the show to be meaningful.