I know there have been a couple of FNL threads lately, but I didn’t want to bump them as they (IIRC) specifically asked for non-spoilers for upcoming episodes/seasons. Since I literally finished this last night, here are my observations… (Yeah, I kind of dropped the episode summary. So sue me.)
The Positives…
For starters, it took me this long to watch the entire series because I did not want it to end. I don’t know if I’ve ever done that before - stop watching something because I didn’t want it to end, that is.
Yes, the Taylor’s are one of the more perfectly realized couples on TV. They love, they fight, they’re trying to build a life - it’s real in the way that the Huxtables weren’t (I don’t recall Cliff and Claire having any issues that weren’t resolved in 22 minutes.)
I was surprised at who stayed and who left during the series, especially the big S3 dump which got rid of most of the high school students in the first 2 seasons. Did NOT like seeing Tyra Collette leave and I did NOT like seeing Matt Saracen hang around for another season. (Matt was boring.)
My favorite character: Landry, by far. Didn’t care for Vince in his early days, but he grew on me. I also liked Buddy Garrity far more than I thought I would. Also liked every scene Levi was in (he was the principal of E. Dillon HS.)
My favorite story-line: Jason Street’s, which is surprising because I thought the character was too angelic in the first place. But by the end of S3, when he’s talking to that girl he knocked up - that was some powerful stuff. My God, I was almost crying at the end of it.
The Negatives…
Is there anybody in the history of TV with a more unlikely career arc than Tammy Taylor*?
S1: Housewife
S1-S2: Volunteer Guidance Counselor
S3-S4: Principal of Dillon High School
S4-S5: Guidance Counselor of East Dillon
End of S5: Got hired as Dean of Admissions for a school described as a “near-Ivy”.
Huh?
In the “Keeping it Reals” department, there is Grace Taylor, who might be perhaps the ugliest baby to appear on a network TV show. I told my wife this as I was making my way through the episodes, and her reaction was “I can’t believe it.” However, when she got her first view of Gracie Taylor, Laura’s reaction was, literally, “Oh my God, you’re right - what an unusual looking child.” Note that Gracie isn’t ugly by most standards, but is definitely so by Tv standards. I truly thought that Gracies autism/retardation/hydroencephalitis issues were going to be a large part of the Taylor’s character development. Imagine my surprise that, no, the baby is just unattractive.
Dillon was originally portrayed as a small town of 20,000 people. In addition, there was a shot of a map of Dillon in Season 4 that did, in fact, look like a map of a town of 20k. But it seemed to suffer from Sunnyvale Syndrome, where things just appeared merely to serve the plot. You know, things like the existence of East Dillon High School, the existence of a “poor side of town” (in towns of 20k, they’re usually all poor, all rich, or all middle class), etc.
Excellent series and I recommend it whole-heartedly.
*Rhetorical question as I’m sure there are plenty of examples involving young 25-somethings with positions of authority that they would never have in the real world.