Many years ago my mom had a cat–born a stray out in the country–who was dedicated to mousing. She would spend hours patiently sitting in front of the kitchen cabinets, awaiting her chance to pounce. Unfortunately, she had somehow missed a crucial step in her training, and had no idea what to do with the mouse once she had caught it. Now, by this I don’t mean she simply didn’t know how to kill it. I mean she really just wasn’t sure what should happen next, and it seemed to be a great source of puzzlement to her. “I know my mom told me something…but, what was it she said? Oh, why didn’t I pay attention that day?” My mom, meanwhile, had no desire to have dismembered prey all over the floor, so she took advantage of the cat’s confusion and would coax her into handing over the mouse, a bit spit-covered but generally unharmed. Mom would drop the mouse in a shoe box and race outside, where she would release it in the back yard, careful not to think about how it was probably heading straight back to the house.
After many years, the cat, who was a bit…guileless…came to realize that my Mom was going to trick her into giving up her mouse. She dealt with this by running from my mom, mouse dangling from her mouth. She always got a wild-eyed look at this point. “What do I do with it? What’s the next step? What do I do?!” So one day shortly before Christmas, I was sitting in mom’s living room and I heard the familiar, “No! No! Give it to me! Drop it!” The cat came racing in, carrying the mouse, dodging my mom, and trying frantically to remember the next step. My mom was right behind her, still calling, making lunges to try to reach the cat.
It was all too much for the cat. Somehow, in her attempts to escape my mom, she dropped the mouse. Right under the Christmas tree.
Everything came to a complete halt as the three of us watched the branches of the Christmas tree ripple from bottom to top, like some sort of invisible mechanized ornament had gone mad.
Mom, regaining her senses, exclaimed, “Grab the cat!”
I wasn’t sure why this was necessary at this time.
“Grab her! Before she decides to follow it up the tree!”
Fortunately, this possibility which hadn’t occurred to me, hadn’t occurred to the cat, either. Instead, after a brief ground search, she returned to the kitchen cabinets to resume her hunt there.
Epilogue #1: The mouse did eventually emerge, appearing along the top of the drapes. I placed him in Witness Relocation.
Epilogue #2: One day when the cat was very old, my Mom came home to find her sitting proudly beside a deceased mouse. The mouse had no obvious injuries, and we entertained the possibility that it had in fact died of natural causes, but we didn’t mention this to the cat, and instead praised her for having finally completed her life’s goal.